Who do you think is the culprit behind yesterday's defeat to West Indies?

[Umairee95]

India’s hopes of an early finish to the series were shattered by the hosts in Antigua, as West Indies snatched an unlikely 11-run win over the visitors on Sunday (July 3) in the fourth ODI to leave the series well-poised at 1-2.

Edited July 3, 2017 by Umairee95

[Texan]

MSK Prasad

[Laaloo]

 

[Rasgulla]

This guy he was plotting behind so he could make his Mumbai lobby boy Rohit sharma captain and take us back to those dark days of 90s

[Nonbeliever]

 

[speedheat]

This man!!

[maniac]

[RAZPOR]

Biggest culprit is kaptaan kohli,for showing zero vision and taking the team backwards,i honestly liked dhoni as a captain even in his last few years better than this guy.

[sscomp32]

Kohli for absolutely shambolic thought process and no thinking about the future at all. Pant deserved to play all 4. Doesn't matter if he drops dhoni yuvi dhawan kedar or even himself. 

[sscomp32]

1 hour ago, Texan said:

MSK Prasad

Agree but kohli has to share the blame for not playing pant. 

Edited July 3, 2017 by sscomp32

[New guy]

[Cricketics]

In no particular order

 

Kohli-Dhoni-Rahane-Dhawan-Pandya-Jadhav-Karthik-Jadeja

 

All are expected to score and when the situation was run a ball, they either batted too slow or did not put price on their wicket.

 

The whole batting line up and all these guys have played enough international cricket to throw the game like that.

 

All are to be blamed, one shouldn't have any soft corner for any player whether for a young or for older player.  Lets move on and accept that some seniors need to go and the young ones need to be given more and more chances even if they fail in few games as it is common to fail early in your career.

 

 

 

[Ankit_sharma03]

When the problem lies in over all mental approach

1-1 match reason dhundh ke kuch nahin milega...........

These problems will keep coming back in some other shape...............

 

Its simple we are playing like Fattu's 

[Vilander]

Am i the only one genuinely happy for windies. did you see those guys dancing...i mean they are winning an ODI at home against us..it ment more for them and they did well.

 

The pitch was difficult to bat on, Rahane scored ( slow but scored), top order bottled up ( problem ?), DK needs to go away and not come back, Pandya and jadeja need to come up the order and put a price on their wicket.

Dhoni may be needs to think what he is doing with his legacy, he is a great ODI player and there comes a time when it is good to get out while the decision is still his.

Pant needs to debut pronto, Pandey/Rahul need to come back into the scheme quickly. They all need to get 40 odd games prior to WC to be ready.

Its time for this madness to end, Dhoni/Yuvi should have never traveled to WI for this series and Kohli needs to show results after lettign Kumble go.

Edited July 3, 2017 by Vilander

[RAZPOR]

4 minutes ago, Vilander said:

Am i the only one genuinely happy for windies. did you see those guys dancing...i mean they are winning an ODI at home against us..it ment more for them and they did well.

 

The pitch was difficult to bat on, Rahane scored ( slow but scored), top order bottled up ( problem ?), DK needs to go away and not come back, Pandya and jadeja need to come up the order and put a price on their wicket.

Dhoni may be needs to think what he is doing with his legacy, he is a great ODI player and there comes a time when it is good to get out while the decision is still his.

Pant needs to debut pronto, Pandey/Rahul need to come back into the scheme quickly. They all need to get 40 odd games prior to WC to be ready.

Its time for this madness to end, Dhoni/Yuvi should have never traveled to WI for this series and Kohli needs to show results after lettign Kumble go.

They played great by their standard,but in the long term i don't see how this helps them,their problems are much deeper.

 

[Vilander]

Just now, RAZPOR said:

They played great by their standard,but in the long term i don't see how this helps them,their problems are much deeper.

 

one thing i noted is that, they were more passionate than the ' t20 stars'. And they are playing this format since they play the domestic formats in ODI. More power to them.

[jusarrived]

1 hour ago, Cricketics said:

In no particular order

 

Kohli-Dhoni-Rahane-Dhawan-Pandya-Jadhav-Karthik-Jadeja

 

All are expected to score and when the situation was run a ball, they either batted too slow or did not put price on their wicket.

 

The whole batting line up and all these guys have played enough international cricket to throw the game like that.

 

All are to be blamed, one shouldn't have any soft corner for any player whether for a young or for older player.  Lets move on and accept that some seniors need to go and the young ones need to be given more and more chances even if they fail in few games as it is common to fail early in your career.

 

 

 

 

Glad that some one mentioned this . Am sure we will find replacements for slow players , but do we have players who put a price on their wicket ? 

[Tendu_10]

This guy he was plotting behind so he could make his Mumbai lobby boy Rohit sharma captain and take us back to those dark days of 90s

 

how about u show some respect. instead of baseless accusations

 

Sent from my SM-G920F using Tapatalk

 

 

[Rasgulla]

5 minutes ago, Tendu_10 said:

 

how about u show some respect. instead of baseless accusations

 

Sent from my SM-G920F using Tapatalk

 

 

Shastri says no !!!! 

 

Mumbai lobby does exists

[Tendu_10]

Shastri says no !!!! 

 

Mumbai lobby does exists

 

tendu recommending shastri doesnt mean he is some mumbaikar mafioso.

 

n behind rahane in the team.

 

 

 

Sent from my SM-G920F using Tapatalk