Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
Ankit_sharma03

What would be your All time Asia ODI XI

Recommended Posts

Since we are at picking XI and the next game has some days , Lets pick An Asia ODI All time XI 

I have seen a lot of All time Asia test XI list, hardly seen a few Asia XI for ODI

 

For Overseas

1. Jayasuria

2. Sachin

3. Kohli

4. Sanga/miandad (havent seen miandad play so its gets tough to make a choice)

5. yuvraj 

6. Dhoni (capt)

7. Kapil

8. Imran

9. Wasim

10. Murali 

11. Malinga 

12th. Razzaq (really hard to miss him, fielding went against him )

 

For subcontinent 

 

1. Jayasuria

2. Sachin

3. Kohli

4. yuvraj

5. Dhoni (capt)

6. Imran

7. Kapil

8. Afridi (over many spinner, well his leg spin, a lil better fielding then many pakistani and batting )

9. Akram

10. Malinga 

11. Murali 

 

 

  • Fielding and running was a huge criteria, so i never considered many players . Specially playing against World XI these two areas shud be good

Share this post


Link to post

Sanath Jayasuria

Sachin Ramesh Tendulkar

Virat Kohli

Arvinda Desilva

Yuvraj Singh

Dhoni (c)

Kapil Dev 

Shakib ul hasan / Abul razzaq

Wasim Akram

Muralitharan

Shoaib Akhtar

Share this post


Link to post
12 minutes ago, Jimmy Cliff said:

A subcontinent XI for all conditions

 

Tendulkar

Jayasuriya

Kohli

Abbas

Miandad

Dhoni (c)

Kapil

Imran

Akram

Saqlain

Murali

No yuvraj singh?

 

1 minute ago, kira said:

Sanath Jayasuria

Sachin Ramesh Tendulkar

Virat Kohli

Arvinda Desilva

Yuvraj Singh

Dhoni (c)

Kapil Dev 

Shakib ul hasan / Abul razzaq

Wasim Akram

Muralitharan

Shoaib Akhtar

Thought about shakib but dnt u think  that with yuvi and sanath and now shaqib thats to much of left arm spin 

Share this post


Link to post
5 minutes ago, Ankit_sharma03 said:

Thought about shakib but dnt u think  that with yuvi and sanath and now shaqib thats to much of left arm spin 

Couldn't think of any other spin bowling allrounder, maybe I'll replace him with an extra batsman like ganguly or raina or even azharrudin

Share this post


Link to post

Tendulkar

Jayasuriya

Kohli

Sanga

Jayawardene

Dhoni

Waqar

Wasim

Malinga

Akhtar

Murali

 

Wouldn't mind a second front line spinner but I can't think of any I would have over the four fast bowlers I've chosen. Sanath's filth will have to do if needed.

Share this post


Link to post
9 minutes ago, YCCC said:

Tendulkar

Jayasuriya

Kohli

Sanga

Jayawardene

Dhoni

Waqar

Wasim

Malinga

Akhtar

Murali

 

Wouldn't mind a second front line spinner but I can't think of any I would have over the four fast bowlers I've chosen. Sanath's filth will have to do if needed.

 

Can't argue with the 2 Ws, but picking Akhtar & Malinga in an all-time Asia ODI XI and excluding Kapil is a bit of a stretch.   Kapil was a gun bat and all-world fielder.     I would think Zaheer Abbas is getting unfairly overlooked as well - haven't watched him bat live, but the guy's numbers are top-shelf.  Easily enough to displace one of Kohli/Sanga/Jaya.  Kohli may be hard to keep out after he's done piling up the ODI runs though.  

 

Share this post


Link to post
15 minutes ago, sandeep said:

 

Can't argue with the 2 Ws, but picking Akhtar & Malinga in an all-time Asia ODI XI and excluding Kapil is a bit of a stretch.   Kapil was a gun bat and all-world fielder.     I would think Zaheer Abbas is getting unfairly overlooked as well - haven't watched him bat live, but the guy's numbers are top-shelf.  Easily enough to displace one of Kohli/Sanga/Jaya.  Kohli may be hard to keep out after he's done piling up the ODI runs though.  

 

The reason i had to miss waqar was coz for it was malinga vs waqar for me and that malinga's action was like a variety and again havent seen waqar bowl much at his peek.

Havent seen Zaheer abbas as well and i think he has played played 60+ odi games which is not that a big sample, also no idea about his fielding and did he bowl??

 

Share this post


Link to post

S.Tendulkar

S.Anwar

V.Kohli

Sangakara (batsman)

MSDhoni

Ashwin

Shahid  Afridi

Wasim Akram (captain)

MUrlidharan (534 ODI and 800 test wickets)

Waqar

Vass.(he will bats up at # 9 if his team needs)

 

12th man

Robin Singh (India)

 

Kapil rev injured not available.

 

Comments

Team need more all rounder iN ODI TO WIN CUP:

 

 

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
9 minutes ago, Wapas said:

S.Tendulkar

S.Anwar

V.Kohli

Sangakara (batsman)

MSDhoni

Ashwin

Shahid  Afridi

Wasim Akram (captain)

MUrlidharan (534 ODI and 800 test wickets)

Waqar

Vass.(he will bats up at # 9 if his team needs)

 

12th man

Robin Singh (India)

 

Kapil rev injured not available.

 

Comments

Team need more all rounder iN ODI TO WIN CUP:

 

 

 

 

Afridi won't even get into a 2nd XI, the most garbage player to play more than 300 odis. Also there is no way a pakistani is captaining an asian odi side ahead of dhoni. This has to be by far the worst asian odi XI on this thread

Share this post


Link to post
15 minutes ago, Wapas said:

S.Tendulkar

S.Anwar

V.Kohli

Sangakara (batsman)

MSDhoni

Ashwin

Shahid  Afridi

Wasim Akram (captain)

MUrlidharan (534 ODI and 800 test wickets)

Waqar

Vass.(he will bats up at # 9 if his team needs)

 

12th man

Robin Singh (India)

 

Kapil rev injured not available.

 

Comments

Team need more all rounder iN ODI TO WIN CUP:

This has to be the most senseless 11

 

5 batsman and 6 bowler....most bizzare combination 

Itni bowling ka karna kya hai 

At 6 - ashwin ( u dnt want some hitting i guess)

At 7 u hve one of the most unreliable batsman, afridi at 8 wud have still made more sense

 

U havent even selected all rounder like Kapil, razzaq n imran 

Share this post


Link to post

Think , just to make it interesting , we should put a stipulation in that a minimum of two and max of three players from each country- in other words two Bangladeshis, 3 each from Ind, Pak, SL

 

Can have a few interesting combos that way

 

Tendulkar

Jayasuriya

Sangakarra

Virat

MSD

Matthews

Shakib

Wasim

Mashrafe

Saqlain

Waqar

 

 

 

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
1 hour ago, Ankit_sharma03 said:

This has to be the most senseless 11

 

5 batsman and 6 bowler....most bizzare combination 

Itni bowling ka karna kya hai 

At 6 - ashwin ( u dnt want some hitting i guess)

At 7 u hve one of the most unreliable batsman, afridi at 8 wud have still made more sense

 

U havent even selected all rounder like Kapil, razzaq n imran 

I have more allrounder but you not realized till I play with your team 

Share this post


Link to post
1 hour ago, Sooda said:

Think , just to make it interesting , we should put a stipulation in that a minimum of two and max of three players from each country- in other words two Bangladeshis, 3 each from Ind, Pak, SL

 

Can have a few interesting combos that way

 

Tendulkar

Jayasuriya

Sangakarra

Virat

MSD

Matthews

Shakib

Wasim

Mashrafe

Saqlain

Waqar

 

 

 

 

 

If you loose SRT and SanGa early VIRAT need to bats next 35 over to finish under 300.Confirm with Laloo

Edited by Wapas

Share this post


Link to post
1 hour ago, kira said:

Afridi won't even get into a 2nd XI, the most garbage player to play more than 300 odis. Also there is no way a pakistani is captaining an asian odi side ahead of dhoni. This has to be by far the worst asian odi XI on this thread

Afridi 8000 runs in ODI 

Afridi. 395 wickets in ODI

Afridi. 351 sixes in ODI : 127 catches too.

Share this post


Link to post
3 minutes ago, Wapas said:

Afridi 8000 runs in ODI 

Afridi. 395 wickets in ODI

Afridi. 351 sixes in ODI : 127 catches too.

Kapildev in 226 matches ODI One century vs Zimbabwe 61 sixes in ODI career  and 253 wickets 3700 runs 

Share this post


Link to post
1 hour ago, Ankit_sharma03 said:

This has to be the most senseless 11

 

5 batsman and 6 bowler....most bizzare combination 

Itni bowling ka karna kya hai 

At 6 - ashwin ( u dnt want some hitting i guess)

At 7 u hve one of the most unreliable batsman, afridi at 8 wud have still made more sense

 

U havent even selected all rounder like Kapil, razzaq n imran 

Saeed Anwar scored near 9000 ODI runs with 63 scores of  over 50 alone in ODI 

Share this post


Link to post
1 hour ago, Sooda said:

Think , just to make it interesting , we should put a stipulation in that a minimum of two and max of three players from each country- in other words two Bangladeshis, 3 each from Ind, Pak, SL

 

Can have a few interesting combos that way

 

Tendulkar

Jayasuriya

Sangakarra

Virat

MSD

Matthews

Shakib

Wasim

Mashrafe

Saqlain

Waqar

 

 

 

 

 

No doubt about jayasurya talent in ODI  with 270 sixes,13000 runs 300 wickets but I never like him because real cricket is test cricket 

he despite playing and Lable with great all rounder finished his career with 98 test wickets and under 7000 test runs.

Share this post


Link to post
23 minutes ago, Wapas said:

Afridi 8000 runs in ODI 

Afridi. 395 wickets in ODI

Afridi. 351 sixes in ODI : 127 catches too.

I guess averages don't matter now. Even a gully cricketer would make as many runs and take as many wickets if he's constantly picked to play for 20 years even though he didn't deserve it.

Share this post


Link to post

SRT, Wasim, Waqar, Murali, Kohli and Dhoni are automatic picks in the line up.

 

Sanath gets into team with his batting and bowling. Anwar can get into team as opener. 

 

Sangakara is debatable. Even many lankans rate De Silva higher.

 

Fast bowling ARs - Kapil, Imran - pick any.

 

Yuvraj was a clutch player.

 

1 slot can go to Shakib, Miandad, Ganguly. 

 

 

 

Share this post


Link to post

Sachin

Sanath( Anwar very close but sanath can bowl)

Kohli

Inzi

Miandad

DHONI

Kapil

Imran

Akram

Saqlain( yes 2 off spinners but better to play with ur best )

Murli

 

 

Share this post


Link to post

LOL at people overlooking Kapil for XI over Imran.

Kapil was a guy with way better economy rate and way better strike rate with the bat. Neither are good enough to command a top six spot. And an ideal guy for #7 is someone who can bash quick runs as well as rescue a side from crisis (both claims in LOIs Kapil > Imran) and be a perfect 1st change bowler.Kapil ticks this box better than any other candidate in the world...with Klusener only competition.

Share this post


Link to post
1 hour ago, Muloghonto said:

LOL at people overlooking Kapil for XI over Imran.

Kapil was a guy with way better economy rate and way better strike rate with the bat. Neither are good enough to command a top six spot. And an ideal guy for #7 is someone who can bash quick runs as well as rescue a side from crisis (both claims in LOIs Kapil > Imran) and be a perfect 1st change bowler.Kapil ticks this box better than any other candidate in the world...with Klusener only competition.

I will take both in my team with kapil at 7 and imran at 8, akram 9

Share this post


Link to post
16 hours ago, Muloghonto said:

Sachin

Jayasurya

Kohli

Sangakkara

Yuvraj

Dhoni

Kapil

Akram

Saqlain

Murali

Waqar

I'd go with pretty much the same team.

 

Just wondering if Kumble instead of Saqlain so there is variety in the attack

Share this post


Link to post
15 hours ago, goose said:

Sanga has just hit 7 centuries from 12 innings on the English county circuit.

How many has Gary Ballance hit on the "county circuit"?  How many runs did the 50 year old Chanderpaul score this year? How are the county studs Westley, Stoneman, Malan doing in international cricket so far.   County cricket is domestic cricket.   Let's not get carried away extrapolating Sanga's county performances.  

Share this post


Link to post
7 hours ago, PSB_Zone said:

I will take both in my team with kapil at 7 and imran at 8, akram 9

Wouldn't Waqar be a better choice to complement Kapil and Akram?  Don't need Imran's stodgy batting in a star studded lineup, and Waqar is a notch above Imran as a pure bowler, longevity aside.  

Share this post


Link to post
9 hours ago, Trichromatic said:

SRT, Wasim, Waqar, Murali, Kohli and Dhoni are automatic picks in the line up.

 

Sanath gets into team with his batting and bowling. Anwar can get into team as opener. 

 

Sangakara is debatable. Even many lankans rate De Silva higher.

 

Fast bowling ARs - Kapil, Imran - pick any.

 

Yuvraj was a clutch player.

 

1 slot can go to Shakib, Miandad, Ganguly. 

 

 

 

Ganguly was a gun ODI player by 90s standards.  But he would miss out next to Jayasurya, especially since you have Tendy as the other opener.  

Share this post


Link to post

No one's picking Aravinda De Silva ? Very underrated odi batsman and big game player as well.

 

Sachin

Jayasuriya

Kohli

Desilva

Jayawardene

MS Dhoni

Kapil

Imran

Wasim

Muralitharan

Malinga

 

 

Only doubt for me would be between Miandad and Jayawardene but tipped for Jayawardene for him big game temperament.

Share this post


Link to post
1 hour ago, BeautifulGame said:

No one's picking Aravinda De Silva ? Very underrated odi batsman and big game player as well.

 

Sachin

Jayasuriya

Kohli

Desilva

Jayawardene

MS Dhoni emoji767.png

Kapil

Imran

Wasim

Muralitharan

Malinga

 

 

Only doubt for me would be between Miandad and Jayawardene but tipped for Jayawardene for him big game temperament.

Shouldn't Waqar be ahead of Malinga or Imran? 

Share this post


Link to post
Shouldn't Waqar be ahead of Malinga or Imran? 
When picking All time XIs I always prefer one who has performed in world cups .Because otherwise most of them are individually great bowlers anyway.

So with Waqar , He missed 1992 with injury , got carted around in 96 QF, dropped for 99 and struggled badly in 2003 WC.

That takes a lot of gloss of his record for me particularly when it comes to picking world XIs.

Also we already have Malinga who is a great death bowler and and have Akram as well .

So Imran as new ball first change bowler ,made more sense for me along with the added batting depth as bonus.

Share this post


Link to post
53 minutes ago, BeautifulGame said:

When picking All time XIs I always prefer one who has performed in world cups .Because otherwise most of them are individually great bowlers anyway.

So with Waqar , He missed 1992 with injury , got carted around in 96 QF, dropped for 99 and struggled badly in 2003 WC.

That takes a lot of gloss of his record for me particularly when it comes to picking world XIs.

Also we already have Malinga who is a great death bowler and and have Akram as well .

So Imran as new ball first change bowler ,made more sense for me along with the added batting depth as bonus.

what has Imran done as a bowler in WC?

Share this post


Link to post

Imran the ODI bowler over Waqar ? LOL.

And Imran's ODI batting is not useful in anycase. He was a tuk-tuk batsman who averaged 30. i.e., not good enough for middle order and not good enough for lower order. I'd take Razzaq over Imran in ODIs....

 

Share this post


Link to post

Alltime Asia ODI XI:

tendulkar

Jayasurya

Kohli

Sangakkara

Dhoni (wk)

Yuvraj Singh

Kapil Dev (c)

Wasim Akram

Waqar Younis

Saqlain Mushtaq

Muttiah Muralitharan

 

12th man: Shakib

 

Edited by Muloghonto

Share this post


Link to post

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Sign in to follow this  

Guest, sign in to access all features.

×