Score the players

[Texy]

Dhawan - 1/10 

Murali - 2/10 

Puji - 2/10 

Virushka - 2/10  

Hitman - 0/10 

Pandya - 9/10 

saha - 4/10 

ash - 8/10 

Bhuvi - 9/10

Shami - 4/10 

Bumrah -  7/10 

 

 

 

[velu]

give more marks to shami

[chewy]

5 minutes ago, Texy said:

Dhawan - 1/10  0

Murali - 2/10  0

Puji - 2/10 5

Virushka - 2/10  4

Hitman - 0/10 1

Pandya - 9/10 9

saha - 4/10 5

ash - 8/10 7

Bhuvi - 9/10 9

Shami - 4/10 5

Bumrah -  7/10 7

 

 

 

 

[Rasgulla]

8 minutes ago, Texy said:

Dhawan - 1/10 

Murali - 1/10 

Puji - 2/10 

ViRAT - 3/10  

Maggiman - 1/10 

Pandya - 9/10 

saha - 2/10 

ash - 8/10 

Bhuvi - 9/10

Shami - 5/10 

Bumrah -  6/10 

 

 

 

That's my ratings

[SK_IH]

Dhawan :  -10/10 

Murali : 0/10 

Puji : 2/10 

Virat : 2/10  

Hitman : 3/10 - wese 2 bante hai but 1 point extra for that defining role on 2nd day 1st session

Pandya : 9/10 

saha : 3/10 

ash : 4/10 

Bhuvi  : 11/10

Shami : 4/10 

Bumrah : 7/10

Edited January 8, 2018 by SK_IH

[sergio04]

murli vijay desrve -20

[Gollum]

Dhawan 0.5/10

Vijay 0.5/10

Che 3/10

Kohli 0/10

Rohit 2/10

Saha 6/10

Pandya 8/10

Ashwin 7/10

Shami 5/10

Bumrah 5/10

Bhuvi 9/10

 

[Trichromatic]

1 hour ago, Texy said:

Dhawan - 1/10 

Murali - 2/10 

Puji - 2/10 

Virushka - 2/10  

Hitman - 0/10 

Pandya - 9/10 

saha - 4/10 

ash - 8/10 

Bhuvi - 9/10

Shami - 4/10 

Bumrah -  7/10 

 

 

 

Hitman took a catch and get a zero, Dhawan dropped one and got 1.

 

Dhawan: -2

Vijay: 1

Pujara: 2.5

Kohli: 2

Rohit: 3

Saha: 3 (for catches)

Ashwin: 4

Pandya: 9

Bhuvi: 9

Shami: 7.5

Bumrah: 7

[Lannister]

Dhawan: 0

Vijay: 0.5

Pujara: 3

Kohli: 2

Rohit: 5

Saha: 4

Ashwin: 6

Pandya: 9

Bhuvi: 9

Shami: 7

Bumrah: 7

[adi B]

It was the bowler' s and pandya's show,rest can kill themselves!!

[mishra]

Openers Kohli and hitman should be dropped. I can guarantee 4 new bats with zero practice will still do better.

[maniac]

Dhawan-0

Vijay-0

Chepu-3

Kohli-2

Rohit-3

Pandya-8

Saha-5

Ashwin-7

Bhuvi-9

Shami-5

Bumrah-6

 

[beetle]

Dhawan(-1)--minus 1 for dropping dolly.

Vijay  0

Puji  2

Kohli  2-1(for selection)

Rohit  2

Pandya  8+1(for lifting up team spirit with his batting)

Saha  8( for the brilliant keeping)

Ashwin  6

Bhuvi  10  bowling, batting and frustrating the opposition + a very good catch .

Shami  5

Bumrah 6 

 

 

 

[vayuu1]

Dhawan -1/10
Vijay 2/10
Kohli 2/10
Pujara 3/10
Rohit 2/10
Saha 4/10
Ashwin 4/10
Pandya 9/10
Bhuvi 9/10
Bumrah 7/10
Shami 7/10



Sent from my vivo 1601 using Tapatalk

[Straight Drive]

Dhawan - 1/10 

Murali - 1 /10 

Chet - 5 /10 

Virat - 3 /10  

Rohit - 3 /10 

Pandya - 10 /10 

Saha - 4/10 

Ash -  7/10 

Bhuvi - 10/10

Shami - 7/10 

Bumrah -  7/10 

 

[goose]

Saha is at least 7/8

[abc]

On 08/01/2018 at 7:07 PM, beetle said:

Dhawan(-1)--minus 1 for dropping dolly.

Vijay  0

Puji  2

Kohli  2-1(for selection)

Rohit  2

Pandya  8+1(for lifting up team spirit with his batting)

Saha  8( for the brilliant keeping)

Ashwin  6

Bhuvi  10  bowling, batting and frustrating the opposition + a very good catch .

Shami  5

Bumrah 6 

 

 

 

I haven't added up the runs, but it might be that Dhawan literally scored less runs than he gave away by dropping the sitter. With tail-end wickets, it actually gets harder to fully appreciate the value of a drop. The reprieved tail-ender might only hang around scoring nothing, but he will hold up an end while his more skilled batting partner (here it was AB de Villiers(!!)) plunders away.

[Forever Indian]

Dhawan - -5 /10 (dropping dolly and letting SA score 280)

Murali - 0 /10

Chet - 3 /10 

Virat - 1 /10  (-1 for yaarana picks)

Rohit - 2 /10 

Pandya - 9 /10 

Saha - 5 /10 (10 for keeping and 0 for batting, so average of 5)

Ash -  6 /10

Bhuvi - 10 /10

Shami - 6 /10 

Bumrah -  7 /10

Edited January 10, 2018 by Forever Indian

[speedheat]

First of all nice thread @Texy

Dhawan=  -1000/10  

Bhuvi=10/10

Bumrah =10/10

Pandya= 10/10

Shami=5/10

 

rest all scores "Anda" 

Edited January 10, 2018 by speedheat

[Silva]

Shami getting too much love, his number ended up looking decent because bk, bumrah, and Pandya picked up top order wickets. He had a terrible match.