pandya vs ms dhoni

[sergio04]

who is better batsman in test

pandya has already a overseas hundred

and a 93 

Edited January 14, 2018 by Laaloo

[lamellavig]

Pandya

[Shunya]

[Austin 3:!6]

Is this a revenge thread for the Pandya vs Rohit Shamra thread?

 

 

Jeez...how desperate these 'Tailunt' fans are?

 

@OP - No amount of logic can prove Sharma is a not a FTB and no amount of hatred can prove that MSD was not a genuine match winner.

 

 

[speedheat]

Bass kar bhai, dhoni ko in dino itna dhoya hai Maine ki ab mujhe khud guilty feel ho rahai  

[speedheat]

Pandya

[Pollack]

Where's damn poll??

[maniac]

3 minutes ago, Austin 3:!6 said:

Is this a revenge thread for the Pandya vs Rohit Shamra thread?

 

 

Jeez...how desperate these 'Tailunt' fans are?

 

@OP - No amount of logic can prove Sharma is a not a FTB and no amount of hatred can prove that MSD was not a genuine match winner.

 

 

No...Rohit fans have not said Rohit needs to keep playing...in fact he has been average on an individual level but still everyone said his place can be questioned....only objection is the irrational hate.

 

MSD fans on the other hand have defended his place and said there is no alternative even when he singlehandedly lost matches through lunging in 2 formats.

 

Not even comparable. 

[maniac]

Also There seems to be the Indian fan liking a particular player and being subjective with criticism and the 2nd category seems to be the Dhoni fan 

[Austin 3:!6]

4 minutes ago, maniac said:

No...Rohit fans have not said Rohit needs to keep playing...in fact he has been average on an individual level but still everyone said his place can be questioned....only objection is the irrational hate.

 

MSD fans on the other hand have defended his place and said there is no alternative even when he singlehandedly lost matches through lunging in 2 formats.

 

Not even comparable. 

Rohit Sharma avgs 9 in SA. Is that an average performance for you?

Let MS avg below 10 in any country...we would stop defending him. Even a 40 year old lunging Dhoni at this stage can offer more in test cricket than this talent-less tailender

 

[Adi_91]

Just now, Austin 3:!6 said:

Rohit Sharma avgs 9 in SA. Is that an average performance for you?

Let MS avg below 10 in any country...we would stop defending him. Even a 40 year old lunging Dhoni at this stage can offer more in test cricket than this talent-less tailender

 

@maniac‘s point of view will be, he still scored above his avg of 9, so he is an ‘above average’ batsman. 

[maniac]

Just now, Austin 3:!6 said:

Rohit Sharma avgs 9 in SA. Is that an average performance for you?

Let MS avg below 10 in any country...we would stop defending him. Even a 40 year old lunging Dhoni at this stage can offer more in test cricket than this talent-less tailender

 

Sample set is too less...and when it comes to average Dhoni must have felt like aryabhtatta the day he discovered remaining notout a increases the average  hasn’t stopped the pointless

notouts since.

[Austin 3:!6]

9 minutes ago, maniac said:

Sample set is too less...and when it comes to average Dhoni must have felt like aryabhtatta the day he discovered remaining notout a increases the average  hasn’t stopped the pointless

notouts since.

MS avg 29 in SA with highest score of 90...not a single not out.  Played 7 test matches.

 

Rohit avgs 9 there after 4 tests.

 

Thora logic bhi use kar bhai...only writing big paragraphs dont make it true.

 

MS peddled his avg by staying not outs is an argument I heard a lot in green forum by parosis, never expected that filth entered in Indian fans mind too. Its the same lame logic people uses saying whenever Sachin score centuries India loses.

 

 

 

[Laaloo]

30 minutes ago, Pollack said:

Where's damn poll??

Added 

[maniac]

5 minutes ago, Austin 3:!6 said:

MS avg 29 in SA with highest score of 90...not a single not out.  Played 7 test matches.

 

Rohit avgs 9 there after 4 tests.

 

Thora logic bhi use kar bhai...only writing big paragraphs dont make it true.

 

MS peddled his avg by staying not outs is an argument I heard a lot in green forum by parosis, never expected that filth entered in Indian fans mind too. Its the same lame logic people uses saying whenever Sachin score centuries India loses.

 

 

 

29 average+ mediocre keeping is a benchmark now??

 

Great!!!

 

sure Rohit failed but didn’t you say Dhoni was like Gilchrist in comparison to Saha?

 

Border waale forum pe kam samay bithaayen @beetle

[sergio04]

38 minutes ago, Austin 3:!6 said:

Is this a revenge thread for the Pandya vs Rohit Shamra thread?

 

 

Jeez...how desperate these 'Tailunt' fans are?

 

@OP - No amount of logic can prove Sharma is a not a FTB and no amount of hatred can prove that MSD was not a genuine match winner.

 

 

this is good thread

dont bring tailunt discussion in this thread

[speedheat]

Voted Swagg se karenge sab ka swagat... Pandya re pandya 

[speedheat]

Why do every thread gets so Hot on Icf when I post in it, am I so Hot??? 

[Austin 3:!6]

3 minutes ago, maniac said:

29 average+ mediocre keeping is a benchmark now??

 

Great!!!

 

sure Rohit failed but didn’t you say Dhoni was like Gilchrist in comparison to Saha?

 

Border waale forum pe kam samay bithaayen @beetle

 

Comprehension issues much? No one is saying avg 29 is a benchmark.

 

You said Dhoni peddled his stats with not outs which is factually incorrect as per cricinfo. The same country tailunt avgs 9.

 

You said sample size is small but again stats say Rohit only played 3 tests less in SA compared to MS.

 

And when did I say Dhoni was like Gilchrist?

 

Anyway I am outta here...tailunt fans vent their frustration on Dhoni everytime their hero fails (which is regular BTW)

 

[sergio04]

2 minutes ago, Austin 3:!6 said:

 

Comprehension issues much? No one is saying avg 29 is a benchmark.

 

You said Dhoni peddled his stats with not outs which is factually incorrect as per cricinfo. The same country tailunt avgs 9.

 

You said sample size is small but again stats say Rohit only played 3 tests less in SA compared to MS.

 

And when did I say Dhoni was like Gilchrist?

 

Anyway I am outta here...tailunt fans vent their frustration on Dhoni everytime their hero fails (which is regular BTW)

 

dude 

this is pandya vs dhoni thread

if u want to prove dhoni is better than tailunt

then open a new thread

otherwise stick to topic