Jump to content

3 wicketkeepers for 3 formats


Recommended Posts

8 hours ago, CalcuttaNightReader said:

Saha place in tests should not be questioned. He is a must for tests. Parthiv will have to wait. 

Like i said, DK LOI, Saha Tests. Dhoni retirement. 

Saha is fine but out of DK,Parthiv and Saha the best performer gets the nod.

No one should be gauranteed any spot.

Edited by Khota
Link to comment
8 hours ago, Ankit_sharma03 said:

Did u even see parthiv keeping in SA, 

Ball kolkata ja rhi thi , wo dive kanpur men marta tha

 

Parthiv shud never wear india's cap again

He had a miscue. I am sure others have never done anything wrong. His batting is a major upgrade.

Link to comment
5 hours ago, CalcuttaNightReader said:

we should give Saha the same confidence we gave Dhoni. A test wk needs assurance, only then he can perform his best. 

In tests if you have to play 5 bowlers then runs are t be expected from Wkt Kpr. If he can deliver then it is fine.

Link to comment
2 minutes ago, CalcuttaNightReader said:

yes but there is also value in a very good wk. some1 who will not miss chances to take a wicket is more valuable than some1 will be average wk and give you 50 runs. Dont you think so?

To be the top dog you need a wkt kpr who is error free and can score also.

Link to comment
5 hours ago, Ankit_sharma03 said:

a miscue , their were 4-5 .

its all about 20 wkts cant have some one screwing those 20 wkts with horrendeous keeping 

Is it a coincidence that he was playing in the test india won after he shileded the top order. Anyway on principle if you are a horrendous keeper you dont deserve to be inthe team but Parthiv is very capable.

 

Currently the pecking order for Indian cricket in all formats is:

 

1 Karthick

 

Daylight

 

2 a/ 2b  Parthiv /Saha (interchangeable in tests other formats Parhiv better)

Link to comment
5 minutes ago, Khota said:

Is it a coincidence that he was playing in the test india won after he shileded the top order. Anyway on principle if you are a horrendous keeper you dont deserve to be inthe team but Parthiv is very capable.

 

Currently the pecking order for Indian cricket in all formats is:

 

1 Karthick

 

Daylight

 

2 a/ 2b  Parthiv /Saha (interchangeable in tests other formats Parhiv better)

shielding, he just made some 16 runs...how is that shielding . U knw what shielding go watch aakash chopra innings in Aus or bangar in headingly 

Neither did he made many runs of played many balls

 

Parthiv is a terrible keeper , having him in the side acyually cosst u 2-3 wkts .....he proved agian in Sa test where he missed around 5 chances. Huge

 

M quite sure we have seen the last of him in international keeper 

 

Karthik is a better batsman , but yet to prove his keeping better then saha who is the best keeper in world

Link to comment
3 minutes ago, Ankit_sharma03 said:

shielding, he just made some 16 runs...how is that shielding . U knw what shielding go watch aakash chopra innings in Aus or bangar in headingly 

Neither did he made many runs of played many balls

 

Parthiv is a terrible keeper , having him in the side acyually cosst u 2-3 wkts .....he proved agian in Sa test where he missed around 5 chances. Huge

 

M quite sure we have seen the last of him in international keeper 

 

Karthik is a better batsman , but yet to prove his keeping better then saha who is the best keeper in world

Those 16 runs were more than the 16 or less made by Vijay and the specialist opener Rahul. yes he protected them.

Link to comment
20 minutes ago, Ankit_sharma03 said:

vijay made 25 which is more then 16 and played 127 balls now that what u call shielding n taking the shin of the new ball 

So why did Rahul come one down if he was selected as an opener?

Link to comment
9 hours ago, Khota said:

So why did Rahul come one down if he was selected as an opener?

1st reason as given below 

 

8 hours ago, kruiser said:

Because Parthiv could not flash his bat at any other position! Captain thought the hard ball will be easy to hit streaky boundaries.

2nd reason- to try a left hand right combo to upset bowler rhythem at start 

3rd- KL has been mishandled by team man management so u shudnt be shocked

 

N if u really think that team mngmt thinks parthiv is a better open then rahul, bet ull see rahul in squad in next test not parthiv....N if u havent watch cricket before batting changes is done sometimes to surprise the opposition as well, doesnt mean they ll start opening with parthiv from now on

 

 

and watch this video 100 times before even giving parthiv case, the guy doesnt even go in the right direction of the ball

Such keeping has no place in international cricket. 

 

Link to comment
3 hours ago, Ankit_sharma03 said:

1st reason as given below 

 

2nd reason- to try a left hand right combo to upset bowler rhythem at start 

3rd- KL has been mishandled by team man management so u shudnt be shocked

 

N if u really think that team mngmt thinks parthiv is a better open then rahul, bet ull see rahul in squad in next test not parthiv....N if u havent watch cricket before batting changes is done sometimes to surprise the opposition as well, doesnt mean they ll start opening with parthiv from now on

 

 

and watch this video 100 times before even giving parthiv case, the guy doesnt even go in the right direction of the ball

Such keeping has no place in international cricket. 

 

Noone is denying Dinesh is the best. So leave that discussion alone.

 

The only reason Rahul did not open was because he was a dis,mal failure and they thought he could score runs at 1 down. He still failed. I have zero problems with DSinesh as wkt kpr in any format it is Rahuls position I question?

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...