Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
vvvslaxman

Captaincy Ratings (Indian captains)

Recommended Posts

1) Rohit sharma. He has an okay day with his captaincy. Last 2.3 overs game was changed by Bravo. Can't blame him much. 7/10

2) Ashwin. Probably the best Indian captain on display 8/10

3) Gambhir. Team selection was poor. Batting order was also poor. 5/10

4) Karthik. He got away with some bizarre moves. Also batted well. So 6/10

5) Kohli . Most insipid captaincy you can see. He was just not showing any interest 2/10

6) Dhoni -There is not much of an issue with captaincy. Just that entire team sucked balls. 6/10

 

 

 

 

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ashwin was OK for his first outing. DD is just a very weak team. Bowling axar inside power play with GG playing was a bad move. Likewise he made some questionable decisions like sending yuvi at no 3, not bowling stoinis etc.. let's see how he fares against likes of MI , RCB

 

DK was better IMO. Bowling vinay Kumar at the end was a bad move but to restrict this lineup under 200 was commendable.

 

Anyways no use discussing IMO. DK Ashwin and rahane got no chance to become white ball captain for India. Kohli is our captain for atleast 7 yrs. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

right now its to early to say anything. teams are new so they all will need time to figure out new players n strategies. Someone like ashwin comes with clean slate , gambhir comes with exp of working with diff players so now he needs time to adjust his ideas to new player like today he must have realized bowling mishra in powerplay is not same as bowling narine or chawla. 

 

T20 is a fats paced game n they ll make mistakes , but at this point its to early to say nything. At the end a captain needs a strong team as well.  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

To much credit given to ashwin. 

It was a freak show by Rahul and good batting by nair that took them home.

They went to the 19th over inspite of the start they got....that itself is a big negative. This was his chance to get the teams net rate up.

 

I would not give him more than a 6 .

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, UnknownGenius said:

That was because if UV. And you know Ash can't drop Yuvi first game as captain for Punjab in Yuvi's home ground

 

Ashwin hands are tied with Yuvi scenario

Yeah..

.but I would wait for  a more ' normal' match before I call him good.

Other than giving single over to bowlers , I don't think he was that great.

He talks too much about himself and his plans. Better let the work do the talking .

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Karthiks Rana ploy worked against abdv and kohli. Msd ash where not poor as in they did not do anything stupid. Rohit did not or could not do anything during bravo onslaught but he was probably just expecting to wim at that time. Kohli was poor captain during sunil narains innings not bringing in umesh earlier. So its

 

Karthik

 

Ash

Msd

Rohit

 

Gambir

Kohli

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
7 minutes ago, vvvslaxman said:

Tomorrow Williamson vs Rahane.  Kohli has to create a culture where lower order steps up consistently.  That ruthless attitude is not there both with Indian side and RCB side.  

Especially when you've got decent replacement in both the sides waiting to replace the ttf 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, adi B said:

Especially when you've got decent replacement in both the sides waiting to replace the ttf 

Kohli is somewhat rigid with his selections, strategies, moves. Today he inexplicably opened with Chahal instead of Sundar.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Just now, vvvslaxman said:

Kohli is somewhat rigid with his selections, strategies, moves. Today he inexplicably opened with Chahal instead of Sundar.

Yup and he hardly ever bowls more than 5 bowlers ,he is pretty old school in that regard and trusts experienced players to bail him out (which is a wrong notion)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, beetle said:

To much credit given to ashwin. 

It was a freak show by Rahul and good batting by nair that took them home.

They went to the 19th over inspite of the start they got....that itself is a big negative. This was his chance to get the teams net rate up.

 

I would not give him more than a 6 .

:rofl: 

 

How is it his fault if Yuvraj was tuk-tuking in the middle overs? 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Rohit and Ashwin are definitely the best of the lot . Both are very shrewd and will make a difference more often than not with their captaincy . 

 

Virat continues to pick players based on reputation , he just does not have it in him to drop big players . Never has a plan B . 

 

GG is similar to Virat , more emotions than a strategist but does the basics a lot better than Virat .  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
11 minutes ago, DHONI_FANN said:

I would rate Dhoni's captaincy 10 out of 10. Despite having such a crappy team CSK managed to beat Mumbai under his able leadership. Credit where due :giggle:

frankly pathetic team selection , when we have 3 genuine all rounders , its lame to pick 4 more bowlers 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 hours ago, sensible-indian said:

4 overs in and i can say DK's captaincy today has been one of the dumbest i hav seen in a long time.

It defied logic which even made me suspicious. Including VK in the team itself is a dumb decision. But giving him 20th over is even more dumb. That too two matches in a row. There is some backroom forces are working overtime.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

DK goes past Kohli, to bottom of ladder for captaincy, bowling VK in first and last over, DK could have snuck a few VK overs in when a Dhoni and Jadeja were crease and save Narine for latter 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ashwin was sh*t yesterday.

 

Didn't play Gayle in Chinnaswamy.

 

Didn't bowl stoinis despite Mohit Sharma getting ass-whooped. Could have played Gayle if he needed only a Batsmen.

 

Kept Mohit Sharma for the last over.

 

Didn't bowl out Mujjeb Ur Rahman when he was on fire. He was at 3-0-10-1 at one stage and RCB was under pressure after losing VK . One more Wicket atm of either Ab/De-kock and it could have been game on. Gave him the 17 over instead and AB went after him.

 

 

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, sourab10forever said:

Ashwin was sh*t yesterday.

 

Didn't play Gayle in Chinnaswamy.

 

Didn't bowl stoinis despite Mohit Sharma getting ass-whooped. Could have played Gayle if he needed only a Batsmen.

 

Kept Mohit Sharma for the last over.

 

Didn't bowl out Mujjeb Ur Rahman when he was on fire. He was at 3-0-10-1 at one stage and RCB was under pressure after losing VK . One more Wicket atm of either Ab/De-kock and it could have been game on. Gave him the 17 over instead and AB went after him.

 

 

 

 

Interesting how good moves are perceived as bad ones. 

 

His captaincy was brilliant yesterday except maybe not giving Stoinis a try. Gayle could hav played. 

 

With some luck, could hav won a handicapped match defending a sub par total on a belter with virtually no pacers (Tye was good in the end though). 

Edited by sensible-indian

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, sensible-indian said:

Interesting how good moves are perceived as bad ones. 

 

His captaincy was brilliant yesterday except maybe not giving Stoinis a try. Gayle could hav played. 

 

With some luck, could hav won a handicapped match defending a sub par total on a belter with virtually no pacers (Tye was good in the end though). 

not luck , just poor fielding . 

Yuvraj singh missed 2 boundaries while fielding n mujib missed one thats 12 runs their .......game lost 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 2018-04-09 at 1:30 PM, Laaloo said:

Same **** different year.

RCB needs to do a revamp. For starters, get some good bowlers. Rohit has been the best out of the lot. Been using his bowlers strategically even though the result does not show. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Sign in to follow this  

Guest, sign in to access all features.

×