Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
vvvslaxman

Captaincy Ratings (Indian captains)

Recommended Posts

Dhoni's captaincy is atrocious at times. 

 

Reminds me of the days where he captained RPS very poorly.

 

To be honest, in the last 3-4 years, Dhoni's captaincy in IPL has been weird. 

 

Brilliance mixed in with utter chewtiyapa.

Edited by sensible-indian

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

with jadeja i feel dhoni is trying to give him max chance now to find form with both bat n ball and CSK can afford it. 

I feel otherwise, that he is experimenting in situations coz he can. Ill be worried if he does that in a crunch game

 

Was watching Cricbuzz zak show and he was saying same that knowing MS closely thats what he is doing.  Remeber one sehwag interview where he told he gave chawla overs not sehwag(when he had already taken 4 wkts) so he chawla can do something n find confidence 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Dinesh Karthik, the winning captain. Says: "Credit to the management to have taken so many U-19 players. We were a little harsh on Gill earlier, but he's hit first-ball boundaries in the past too, so he's been good. Don't want to hype him up so he doesn't feel the added pressure, but he's special. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
23 hours ago, Ankit_sharma03 said:

with jadeja i feel dhoni is trying to give him max chance now to find form with both bat n ball and CSK can afford it. 

 

Finding form with not getting to bowl and bat. :hysterical:

 

Dhoni fans find ways to give credit to Dhoni from thin air Oh! he is trying to help jadeja find confidence for team India at the cost of CSK. See ! Selfless captain cool.. :cool:  Matlab kuch bhi ! . :hello:

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
12 minutes ago, Pollack said:

Finding form with not getting to bowl and bat. :hysterical:

 

Dhoni fans find ways to give credit to Dhoni from thin air Oh! he is trying to help jadeja find confidence for team India at the cost of CSK. See ! Selfless captain cool.. :cool:  Matlab kuch bhi ! . :hello:

  

But that is exactly what dhoni is doing, not saying that he is right, but he is trying to push Jaddu as batsman. 

Also, its in a way putting his own ass as well as Jaddu's ass on line. Whole world is watching and criticizing him now which they would not have if they would have just used him like previous years. Now Jaddu is just toast as the whole world can watch how bad he is. This is again good for India considering our selectors/captain/coach are watching. lol

Ek teer se 2 nishaan from Dhoni :laugh: 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Pollack said:

Finding form with not getting to bowl and bat. :hysterical:

 

Dhoni fans find ways to give credit to Dhoni from thin air Oh! he is trying to help jadeja find confidence for team India at the cost of CSK. See ! Selfless captain cool.. :cool:  Matlab kuch bhi ! . :hello:

 

on the contrary u need a reason to go at him

here this , forget me being a fan

 

Dnt tell me u knw more then Zaheer khan or u have spend even 1/10 of time with dhoni to even know how he thinks

 

Here is sehwag telling a similar thing, how dhoni likes to give chance to his player to gain confidence back which is a long term prospect 

 

 

Now ull say u knw more then sehwag how dhoni thinks

 

Edited by Ankit_sharma03

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
7 hours ago, Ankit_sharma03 said:

on the contrary u need a reason to go at him

here this , forget me being a fan

 

Dnt tell me u knw more then Zaheer khan or u have spend even 1/10 of time with dhoni to even know how he thinks

 

Here is sehwag telling a similar thing, how dhoni likes to give chance to his player to gain confidence back which is a long term prospect 

 

 

Now ull say u knw more then sehwag how dhoni thinks

 

So how is he giving confidence to Jadeja by not bowling him in almost all the matches. Some way of giving confidence. LOL. But of course now you will say he is giving him confidence only for batting by putting him in fckd up situations (kinda setting him up to fail) ahead of bravo. :hysterical:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, Pollack said:

So how is he giving confidence to Jadeja by not bowling him in almost all the matches. Some way of giving confidence. LOL. But of course now you will say he is giving him confidence only for batting by putting him in fckd up situations (kinda setting him up to fail) ahead of bravo. :hysterical:

he has 7-8 bowlers , not all will get bowling

it also depends on condition n situation. He is giving him a chance to perform at the end of the day he has to perform n gain for himself. The lower u come the less balls u have to get in (basics ye bhi btana padega ab)

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Ankit_sharma03 said:

he has 7-8 bowlers , not all will get bowling

it also depends on condition n situation. He is giving him a chance to perform at the end of the day he has to perform n gain for himself. The lower u come the less balls u have to get in (basics ye bhi btana padega ab)

 

Everyone knows Jadeja is not a batsman who can hit from the get go. So yet again Dhoni giving him confidence by allowing him to face as less balls as possible and with many to score from those. Delusional level is high with this one.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
31 minutes ago, Pollack said:

Everyone knows Jadeja is not a batsman who can hit from the get go. So yet again Dhoni giving him confidence by allowing him to face as less balls as possible and with many to score from those. Delusional level is high with this one.

He cant be sent in top or middle, were ever they can they are sending him. He was given a chance against RCB up......

its not about only batting its also about bowling, he is giving him chance as much as he cud keeping team interest 

 

U have to give ur player a chance to do something but keeping in mind its doesnt affect team much. They are in top so they can afford

 

Height of baal ki khaal nikalana

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
43 minutes ago, Pollack said:

Everyone knows Jadeja is not a batsman who can hit from the get go. So yet again Dhoni giving him confidence by allowing him to face as less balls as possible and with many to score from those. Delusional level is high with this one.

le 2 wkt le gaya, constant backing

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, Ankit_sharma03 said:

le 2 wkt le gaya, constant backing

Dude if he is getting selected in team continously he is going to do well in some matches. In any case the point of argument was not whether he was backed or not after all jadeja was playing every match without bowling or batting. You made a point that he is giving confidence to Jadeja for greater good of India at the expense of CSK which is crap. Jadeja doing good (not even outstanding) in two or three matches of 14 matches to be played total isn't anything special. Play even Joginder Sharma for all 14 matches he will too do good in a few. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, Pollack said:

Dude if he is getting selected in team continously he is going to do well in some matches. In any case the point of argument was not whether he was backed or not after all jadeja was playing every match without bowling or batting. You made a point that he is giving confidence to Jadeja for greater good of India at the expense of CSK which is crap. Jadeja doing good (not even outstanding) in two or three matches of 14 matches to be played total isn't anything special. Play even Joginder Sharma for all 14 matches he will too do good in a few. 

i never said greater good of india, its only good for CSK

The idea is to give player confidence in whole tournament coz ull need every at some point of time .

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Cant find any other relevant thread so will post here. 

 

Williamson's move in the 18th over to give the ball to Brathwaite caused the loss. 

 

The moment i saw Brathwaite, i knew CSK can be back. And that guy ended up bowling pies in the arc. :hysterical:

 

Unbelievably stupid move. Should have bowled bhuvi, kaul and then sandeep.

Edited by sensible-indian

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, sensible-indian said:

Cant find any other relevant thread so will post here. 

 

Williamson's move in the 18th over to give the ball to Brathwaite caused the loss. 

 

The moment i saw Brathwaite, i knew CSK can be back. And that guy ended up bowling pies in the arc. :hysterical:

 

Unbelievably stupid move. Should have bowled bhuvi, kaul and then sandeep.

yep he should have bowled bhuvi in that over,totally inane move 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 minutes ago, SK_IH said:

yep he should have bowled bhuvi in that over,totally inane move 

Fauf was going to go after any bowler. Their moves were good. Where the miscalculated was unexpected batting skills of Shardul Thakur. You really think someone liek Markhende could have pulled off what Thakur did?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
38 minutes ago, vvvslaxman said:

Fauf was going to go after any bowler. Their moves were good. Where the miscalculated was unexpected batting skills of Shardul Thakur. You really think someone liek Markhende could have pulled off what Thakur did?

bhuvi would have been difficult to hit , when bhuvi had only 6 runs to defend,the match was as good as gone

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 minutes ago, SK_IH said:

bhuvi would have been difficult to hit , when bhuvi had only 6 runs to defend,the match was as good as gone

Fauf was in the zone. He smashed Bhuvi for a six in the end. CSK had just 2 wickets in hand with Bhuvi and Kaul to bowl. All they had to do was bowl 3 or 4 dot balls to Thakur

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 minutes ago, vvvslaxman said:

Fauf was in the zone. He smashed Bhuvi for a six in the end. CSK had just 2 wickets in hand with Bhuvi and Kaul to bowl. All they had to do was bowl 3 or 4 dot balls to Thakur

faf found it difficult to hit an over before that , bhuvi is world class,now way he would have been smashed like a braithwaite,it was a tactical blunder

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Just now, SK_IH said:

faf found it difficult to hit an over before that , bhuvi is world class,now way he would have been smashed like a braithwaite,it was a tactical blunder

He could have smashed Brathwhite or Sandeep in the last over. Bhaji might have connected a few against Bhuvi. You never know.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 minutes ago, vvvslaxman said:

He could have smashed Brathwhite or Sandeep in the last over. Bhaji might have connected a few against Bhuvi. You never know.

last over pressure is different, in last 4 overs of the inning one should never take chances with mediocre bowlers, 20 runs over changes the games, i remember it was corey anderson vs rcb , even if your best bowler goes for runs it doesnt matter atleast he is your best option

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Carlos move made sense. He gave less than 6 rpo before his over. His or Kaul wouldn't matter at that time. What Kane missed was not bowling Bhuvi in the 19th. He would have been against Thakur. If he could have picked a wicket or conceded around 8 runs or something. Kaul/Sandeep anyone would have fancied defending around 15 in the last over. Kaul was kind of a mistake but again who would have thought Thakur would end up with three boundaries in that over.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 hours ago, Sonix768 said:

Carlos move made sense. He gave less than 6 rpo before his over. His or Kaul wouldn't matter at that time. What Kane missed was not bowling Bhuvi in the 19th. He would have been against Thakur. If he could have picked a wicket or conceded around 8 runs or something. Kaul/Sandeep anyone would have fancied defending around 15 in the last over. Kaul was kind of a mistake but again who would have thought Thakur would end up with three boundaries in that over.

Actually Kaul was better than Bhuvi in the match. He was landing his yorkers perfectly. Even he bowled very well to Thakur. But nobody expected how Thakur was able to manuoever the ball except the 2nd ball. First ball was intentional. But it was lucky it went between the slip and keeper. He connected all the balls very well in that over. Let us not forget how Vijay shankar struggled against Fiz not long ago in the end overs.  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Sign in to follow this  

Guest, sign in to access all features.

×