Jump to content

Match Thread: India Vs Hong Kong | 4th Match| Group A, Asia Cup at Dubai | Sep 18 2018


tweaker

Recommended Posts

5 minutes ago, Laaloo said:

So even hong Kong has a better wicketkeeper than us @SecondSlip

Keeping is underrated. A team like Hong Kong, whose medium pacers aren't express (to put it gently) can really benefit from a class keeper. Other teams prefer to go for a batsman who occasionally keeps, because batting stats are easier to compare, while judging keeping requires you to watch the match and use your brain, which overpaid selectors couldn't be arsed to do. I have no doubt that the likes of Matthew Cross, McKechnie et al. would find it difficult to break in to a top side, although one could argue for their selection (if they were eligible) on their keeping alone.

Case in point: Matthew Cross. Assume he were to play for England (it's probably not hard to find an English ancestor somewhere down the line), he would be kept out by someone like Jos Buttler or Johnny Bairstow. Although Cross' keeping is miles better, his batting is probably a level or two lower (although he did a decent job in front of the wicket when Scotland beat England earlier this year), and he would not get to play - simples! In Scotland or Hong Kong, there is no such "batsman with keeping gloves somewhere at the bottom of his kit bag" knocking on the door, so they can invest in their best keeper.

Also, small Associate nations have a very small talent pool, which makes it easier for national level selectors to keep closer tabs on players, especially such finer (difficult to quantify, i.e. read off at a glance from the scorebook) details like keeping skills - like was he standing up to the stumps to a high 120s medium pacer, stopping the batsman from using his feet, and still stop extras (which Pant seems unable to do even when standing back and the ball bursts through his hands to hit his helmet positioned behind him) - and go on to effect dismissals like freakish caught-behinds ...

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...