Player Ratings [ Ins vs WI ODI Series 2018 ] !!!

[velu]

4 being the passmark and 10 is the highest

 

Hitman : 8

Dhawan : 3

Kohli : 7 [ -2 for his team selection ] 

Rayudu : 7 [ 2 bonus point for sacrificing biriyani ]

Dhoni : 8    [ 2/4 for batting , 4/4 for keeping and 2/2 for Valuable inputs ] 

Jadhav : 7

Jaddu : 7

Bhuvi : 3

Kuldeep : 8

Bumrah : 8

khaleel : 6

 

Rest:-

 

Pant : 5

Umesh : 5

Shami - 5

chahal : 3

Rahul : -5 [ TM felt that he is not warming the bench properly ] 

Pandeyji :  N/A 

 

Edited November 1, 2018 by velu

[Nikola]

You missed shami chacha 

[Global.Baba]

Dhoni 4/4 for batting actually.  Credit where due, he didn’t last too long in the middle this series to waste balls

[velu]

6 minutes ago, Nikola said:

You missed shami chacha 

given 5

[velu]

2 minutes ago, Global.Baba said:

Dhoni 4/4 for batting actually.  Credit where due, he didn’t last too long in the middle this series to waste balls

he scored a cameo as well .. 22 of 14 or 15

[Global.Baba]

1 minute ago, velu said:

he scored a cameo as well .. 22 of 14 or 15

That is fine. As I said the longer he lasts the more he screws up. Since you feel he deserves 8/10, might as well give him 10/10  

 

As our coach saab says go the full monty and throw the kitchen sink and flash hard 

[speedheat]

Hitman : 9/10

Dhawan : 3/ 10 OK bad series but still  a gun odi bat

Kohli : Big fat zero/10

Rayudu : 7/10

Dhoni :     -10/10

Jadhav : 7/10

Jaddu : 7/10

Bhuvi : 5/10

Kuldeep : 8/10

Bumrah : 10/10

khaleel : Big fat zero/10

[velu]

1 minute ago, speedheat said:

Hitman : 9/10

Dhawan : 3/ 10 OK bad series but still  a gun odi bat

Kohli : Big fat zero/10

Rayudu : 7/10

Dhoni :     -10/10

Jadhav : 7/10

Jaddu : 7/10

Bhuvi : 5/10

Kuldeep : 8/10

Bumrah : 10/10

khaleel : Big fat zero/10

 

kohli and dhoni's rating from you understandable

 

why poor rating for khaleel ? he is one of the finds in the series other than bowling little slow

[Global.Baba]

1 minute ago, velu said:

 

kohli and dhoni's rating from you understandable

 

why poor rating for khaleel ? he is one of the finds in the series other than bowling little slow

Did you check his username before asking him that question?

[rkt.india]

why is Jadhav getting 7/10 b playing just 2 games and without even doing much.

[sourab10forever]

Kohli the batsmen : 10...what else could he have done?

Kohli the captain : 4...max 5.

Rohit the batsmen : 7

 

rest were as usual..

 

[velu]

11 minutes ago, rkt.india said:

why is Jadhav getting 7/10 b playing just 2 games and without even doing much.

 

rating for what he did in those 2 games .. 

[speedheat]

14 minutes ago, velu said:

 

kohli and dhoni's rating from you understandable

 

why poor rating for khaleel ? he is one of the finds in the series other than bowling little slow

He is Asia cup find actually... He has regressed on one of the major aspects of pace bowling... All the way from 148kph in domestics to 130kph...:facepalm:  122ks today

[velu]

Just now, speedheat said:

He is Asia cup find actually... He has regressed on one of the major aspects of pace bowling... All the way from 148kph in domestics to 130kph...:facepalm:  122ks today

 

@express bowling 

[express bowling]

5 minutes ago, velu said:

 

@express bowling 

 

His action has been tinkered with, most probably by Bharat Arun.

[Nikola]

39 minutes ago, velu said:

given 5

Shami is poor  and without wife now . He bowled well in 2nd odi to tie else spray gun might have won it for windies. 5 for Shami & 5 for umesh is injustice.

[Nikola]

20 minutes ago, sourab10forever said:

Kohli the batsmen : 10...what else could he have done?

Kohli the captain : 4...max 5.

Rohit the batsmen : 7

 

rest were as usual..

 

Rohit 7 and Kohli 10? Should be 8.5 for Rohit & 9.5 to Kohli.

[Nikhil_cric]

Dhawan - 5

Sharma - 9

Kohli - 10

Rayudu - 7

Dhoni - 2

Jadhav - NA 

Jadeja - 7.5

Bhuv - 7

Bumrah - 10

Chahal - 6

Kuldeep - 7.5

 

[Global.Baba]

45 minutes ago, rkt.india said:

why is Jadhav getting 7/10 b playing just 2 games and without even doing much.

For his winning mentality 

[express bowling]

Poor opponent.

 

No basis for giving anyone high ratings.

 

The only thing to look for is ... who are the players who have failed against this team even ...  and does it merit any corrective action.