Jump to content
SK_IH

Aus vs India - 1st T20 at Brisbane [ 21 Nov 2018 @ 01:20 PM IST ]

Recommended Posts

8 minutes ago, Frustrated said:

Apart from Bumrah, our fast bowlers don't look penetrative on flat wickets.  Bhuvi is s**t.   Khaleel looks decent but is new and has long way to go. 

We are loosing matches because of our bats. Our spinners and pacers are almost best in class. Combined together, They are best, be it in limited overs or tests.

 

We totally faught or dominated in England, South Africa simply because of our bowling

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
44 minutes ago, Ankit_sharma03 said:

 

 

 

So was it rohit's idea to make DK keep ??

 

 

I THINK PANT will be keeping in Test , so he is performing wicket-keeping duties to get accostmed to pace and bounce here on Australian pitches 

Edited by PSB_Zone

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Bcci had announced Pant as wkt keeper against Windies too ...but it did not happen.Woh rohit hain na Pant ka dushman ,dhoni ka dost.
Why do you Think rohit is against Pant ?
Pant hasn't done anything to him and they seemed friendly as well

Sent from my CPH1609 using Tapatalk

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, UrmiSinhaRay said:

Why do you Think rohit is against Pant ?
Pant hasn't done anything to him and they seemed friendly as well

Sent from my CPH1609 using Tapatalk
 

Because of dhoni. Rohit has a soft corner for dk and he needs dhoni to back him for captaincy. If Pant does well in LOIs then both dk and dhoni will be in danger of being out of the team.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
16 minutes ago, mishra said:

I thought Rohit backed Pant

Kahan?He didn't play him as keeper. He is the specialist keeper....although bcci selected Pant as the main keeper.

He had to play Pant because keeping him out was not an option .

Does dk play as keeper for his state team?

Edited by beetle

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
8 minutes ago, beetle said:

Kahan?He didn't play him as keeper. He is the specialist keeper....although bcci selected Pant as the main keeper.

He had to play Pant because keeping him out was not an option .

Does dk play as keeper for his state team?

He has backed him Pant will get his chance if you see Haddin was successor to Gilly. When Gilchrist was on his last legs even then he was keeper and Haddin was playing as a fielder same way Pant will get his chance main job he should do at the moment is to perform with the bat.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, UrmiSinhaRay said:

Why do you Think rohit is against Pant ?
Pant hasn't done anything to him and they seemed friendly as well

Sent from my CPH1609 using Tapatalk
 

    I think it was common sense  from stakeholders

 1. Keeping in indian pitches is much difficult than in AUs and some drops here by Pant would have put lot of pressure .

 2. Since he is test WK in AUS this will give him good practice.

  3. Both Dk & Pant are being evaluated . DK kept in India , Now Pant;s turn. 

  No need to look for conspiracy in everything. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites



    I think it was common sense  from stakeholders
 1. Keeping in indian pitches is much difficult than in AUs and some drops here by Pant would have put lot of pressure .
 2. Since he is test WK in AUS this will give him good practice.
  3. Both Dk & Pant are being evaluated . DK kept in India , Now Pant;s turn. 
  No need to look for conspiracy in everything. 


1) honestly if you've to push someone you've to push them in deep water.
Pant succeeded in England too which was good.
If we baby him and Aloo Bhatt him into team, then at the end he's Gonna lose.
Also drops hoga hi.
At the end he's doing well though I don't think he serves all the praise.
2) I agree
Note:
To be frank, I think India should go for a rotational wicketkeeper thing that England practices given the amount of games they play.

3) good idea but we know Pant will stick if Kohli gets in his way

Sent from my CPH1609 using Tapatalk

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
He has backed him Pant will get his chance if you see Haddin was successor to Gilly. When Gilchrist was on his last legs even then he was keeper and Haddin was playing as a fielder same way Pant will get his chance main job he should do at the moment is to perform with the bat.
Rohit doesn't really back anybody.
He plays the same XI all through and tries to be friends with everybody.
Let's see what happens when he becomes the full time captain.
Tab maaza aayega

Sent from my CPH1609 using Tapatalk

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites



Because of dhoni. Rohit has a soft corner for dk and he needs dhoni to back him for captaincy. If Pant does well in LOIs then both dk and dhoni will be in danger of being out of the team.


That's because DK saved his ass in that final that made #MakeRohitCaptain possible.
Right now I don't want to really give my mind to all these crazy conspiracy theories but you know - I kinda want to agree with you

See , Rohit is playing his own game.
He's not as loyal to Dhoni as we are thinking - hum toh socha Kohli bhi Dhoni ka lieutenant hai.
Ultimately Aanda nikla.
That said, Rohit is probably hand in gloves with Dhoni and is balancing both of VK and MSD for his own game

MSD is not a moron and probably the VK fallout episode taught him about trust. (if he hadn't already earlier) .
He won't let Rohit that easily and Rohit too knows that.
He has the backing - he needs MSD'S political prowess to succeed.


One possible major mistake Kohli has committed is publicly taking Pant under his wings and declaring to the world openly and brazenly that He finally overthrew Dhoni.
This made Pant to susceptible to attack from the Dhoni brigade.
Dhoni rarely leaves people who dares to go against him - and the fact is these guys don't even know until they're in the muck.

Possibly Pant can get away- but seriously I doubt now given that he officially joined Team King Kong and challenged Dhoni-which makes him difficult to switch sides.

Rohit is anyways going to purge Kohli affiliates from team after he becomes permanent captain .
Hardik is already hanging around Dhoni which makes things suspicious even more

Sent from my CPH1609 using Tapatalk

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
50 minutes ago, Switchblade said:

He has backed him Pant will get his chance if you see Haddin was successor to Gilly. When Gilchrist was on his last legs even then he was keeper and Haddin was playing as a fielder same way Pant will get his chance main job he should do at the moment is to perform with the bat.

Dhoni is on last legs and Pant is his substitute.

Then where did dk come in between.

How is the gilcrist and haddin example the same? Where is the third keeper here?

 

Dk has been forced in to keep dhoni safe in ODIs.

 

If anyone should be playing as batsman and fielding as a normal player, it should be DK ....not Pant.

 

What backing ?

Playing a keeper as  pure batsman is not backing. 

He played him because he is selected in the team.

 

Edited by beetle

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Dhoni is on last legs and Pant is his substitute.

Then where did dk come in between.

How is the gilcrist and haddin example the same? Where is the third keeper here?

 

Dk has been forced in to keep dhoni safe in ODIs.

 

If anyone should be playing as batsman and fielding as a normal player, it should be DK ....not Pant.

 

What backing ?

Playing a keeper as  pure batsman is not backing. 

He played him because he is selected in the team.

 

I don't think Dhoni considered Pant a real threat earlier-if he does it is because of Kohli.

 

Pant continuing into Rohit era is bleak more so after his obvious association with Kohli..

It's funny to think that Dhoni will resist teaching a lesson to his detractors.

 

DK is obviously there to save/protect Dhoni's ass - and I personally believe after 19WC, they'll select Ishan Kishan into the team too and pit him Against pant.

It does help that Kishan plays in MI and is from Jharkhand

 

 

Sent from my CPH1609 using Tapatalk

 

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest, sign in to access all features.

×