Jump to content

Aus v Ind - Umpiring watch thread


Recommended Posts

Quote
73.6

Ashwin to Pat Cummins, no run, good review! Seemed a goner in naked eye but HotSpot/Snicko don't have much to offer and Cummins survives. Got forward to this ripping off break and the ball lobbed up off the pads to FSL. Initial feeling was that there was some glove and in fact, Snicko did show a very faint murmur but the ball wasn't close enough to the glove for the third umpire to be convinced. What an eventful over though!

 

Link to comment
Quote
73.1

Lyon to Rahane, no run, India review: Fair delivery. Did it brush the glove? HotSpot shows nothing front on and Snicko reveals that it's missing the bat by some distance. Straight off the flap off the pad. Checks for lbw and that's missing leg by a country mile. Third review overturned off Lyon's bowling Rahane got forward slightly to block and overspin from Lyon meant he got beaten on the inside edge and it lobbed to Finch at FSL off the flap off the pad. No bat

 

Link to comment
Quote
39.2

Lyon to Pujara, no run, that's a brave call from Nigel Llong to give Pujara leg-before. The premise is that he's hid his bat behind pad, so there's no shot offered which nullifies the fact that the impact is outside off. It's not just the impact that has to be taken under consideration though. Pujara had skipped down the pitch, so is this bouncing over the stumps? Ball-tracking says that it is. Another successful review from Pujara. Quite surprised that Llong raised his finger actually, there was so much to consider

 

Link to comment
Quote
23.5

Lyon to Pujara, no run, Pujara has been given caught behind and he wants a review. It's a fair delivery, can't say much with the naked eye, HotSpot doesn't reveal much and there's a flat line on the Snicko as well. 'There's nothing on that', says Chris Gaffaney, he wants one more look at the HotSpot and then asks Nigel Llong to overturn his call, NOT OUT. Successful review from Pujara, but it was a lame shot, a nothing shot really, looking to play off the back-foot and with a horizontal bat - to one that was spinning back in, lucky not to have edged it

Quote
23.5

Lyon to Pujara, no run, Pujara has been given caught behind and he wants a review. It's a fair delivery, can't say much with the naked eye, HotSpot doesn't reveal much and there's a flat line on the Snicko as well. 'There's nothing on that', says Chris Gaffaney, he wants one more look at the HotSpot and then asks Nigel Llong to overturn his call, NOT OUT. Successful review from Pujara, but it was a lame shot, a nothing shot really, looking to play off the back-foot and with a horizontal bat - to one that was spinning back in, lucky not to have edged it

Quote
39.3

Ashwin to Khawaja, out Caught by Pant!! Ripper from Ashwin! With the kind of form and patience Khawaja was showing, it needed something special to get him out and that's exactly what India's off spinner has produced. Slowed this down considerably and got the off break to kick up off the pitch, Khawaja wasn't entirely forward to it and ended up getting a faint bit of glove on it. Pant instantly knew it and so did the Indians but it took a DRS to convince Dharmasena. A tiny mark on HotSpot was enough for the third umpire who was rather quick to overturn the on-field call. This is a massive, massive moment in the game. India now are firmly on top. Khawaja c Pant b Ashwin 28(125) [4s-1]

Quote
80.4

Starc to Ishant, no run, Ishant shoulders arms to a ball that swings in on middle stump and hits him on the kneeroll. Just the sight of it tempts Nigel Llong to raise the finger. But I reckon this would be high. No hesitation from Ishant in going for the review and ball-tracking shows that it would've comfortably bounced over the top

 

Link to comment

Seeing the number of wrong decisions against india overturned by drs ( two pujara not outs are the final difference ) - 

is nigel long the new bucknor ? does he have a vendetta or just not good?

god bless drs . we would have won monkeygate but for Bucknor and lack of drs 

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...