Jump to content

India's XI for the semis


Recommended Posts

 

KL Rahul, Rohit will open. Don't want to mess up something that is not broke

Kohli

 

Here comes the key part

 

Pant , Dhoni, Pandya

 

Dhoni vs Pant who should bat at 4. Since Pant hasn't done badly at 4 i would like to persist him there. Having said that, Dhoni at 5 will have to do two roles. Consolidation and finishing. Is he up for it. or should we put Dhoi at 4 and 3 quick run getters following him? or Dhoni should be in between Hitters?

 

Last bit is no.7. India is now left with 1 sixth bowling option who they hardly used in this world cup. Between Jadhav and KKD who would be the better choice.  KKD might or might not come off. But he is not going to die wondering what would have happened if we had shown intent.  

 

Rohit, Rahul (if shown intent), Kohli, Dhongi (if shown intent atleast against trundler Plunkett), Pant, Pandya, KKD  . This is a good line up for chasing as well.

 

 

 

 

Link to comment
1 minute ago, vvvslaxman said:

 

KL Rahul, Rohit will open. Don't want to mess up something that is not broke

Kohli

 

Here comes the key part

 

Pant , Dhoni, Pandya

 

Dhoni vs Pant who should bat at 4. Since Pant hasn't done badly at 4 i would like to persist him there. Having said that, Dhoni at 5 will have to do two roles. Consolidation and finishing. Is he up for it. or should we put Dhoi at 4 and 3 quick run getters following him? or Dhoni should be in between Hitters?

 

Last bit is no.7. India is now left with 1 sixth bowling option who they hardly used in this world cup. Between Jadhav and KKD who would be the better choice.  KKD might or might not come off. But he is not going to die wondering what would have happened if we had shown intent.  

 

Rohit, Rahul (if shown intent), Kohli, Dhongi (if shown intent atleast against trundler Plunkett), Pant, Pandya, KKD  . This is a good line up for chasing as well.

 

 

 

 

KKD anyday of the week, twice on Sunday.

 

He is a winner - has everyone already forgotten his blitzkrieg against Bangladesh that won us a finals and trophy when we needed something like 36 in last 2 overs and pathetic Vijay Shankar could not put bat to bal.

 

KKD is the best finisher in India right now.

 

Kedar Jadhav is pathetic waste as a finisher.

Link to comment

Well, we still have one more game versus SL to experiment. I want to see Agarwal open with Rohit. Dhoni should bat at 4, he is more likely than Pant to consolidate and get a bigger score (minimum 60-70). 

 

If we play at Edgbaston I hope to see this:

 

Rohit, Agarwal, Kohli, Dhoni, Rahul, Pant, Pandya, BK, Shami, Chahal, Bumrah

 

Some good T20 hitters lower down the order there: Rahul Pant Pandya. Batting to 8. I'd love to see Jaddu in there but don't want to drop 5-7. I don't mind Kartick but again to me Rahul, Pant and Pandya are really attacking players who are more likely to get fast 50s. Rahul is slow as hell opening but when he plays in T20 mode he is pretty fast.

 

Going into knockouts you want a strong top 4 and lets give Agarwal a game versus Sri Lanka, he'll also be unknown which will help us, confident player. 

Edited by ViruDilSeKhelo
Link to comment

With Agarwal comming in ,he is better to play at any position than kartik..

 

May be drop dhoni to 7, play agarwal at 4 or 5.

 

But I think India should play jdega to give the bowling option..At no. 7 with few balls to go..Jadega cannot do worse than kartik or jadhav anyway..

 

That way u can play 3 seemers as well..

 

Link to comment
19 minutes ago, asterix said:

Mayank

Rohit

Kohli

KLR

Pant

Dhoni

HaPa

Jadeja

Bhuvi

Chahal

Bhumrah

+1. with one minor adjustment. Mayank to only play in semis if he plays against Sri Lanka.  Else open with KL and Rohit and  place Kedhar at number 5 so that he can bat with Pant or Kohli.

 

I want Dhoni to come after Pandya as it gives Pandya additional freedom. Also he should be given license to go bang bang.

 

Link to comment
5 minutes ago, mishra said:

+1. with one minor adjustment. Mayank to only play in semis if he plays against Sri Lanka.  Else open with KL and Rohit and  place Kedhar at number 5 so that he can bat with Pant or Kohli.

 

I want Dhoni to come after Pandya as it gives Pandya additional freedom. Also he should be given license to go bang bang.

 

Yes, I forgot to add. If Mayank is already here, he needs to play the last league match against SL. I noticed KLR is aware of Mayank's presence and hence he was trying his best to play better in the last match. So it's good to select Mayank and it'll keep KLR on toes and not take things for granted.

 

Mayank

Rohit

Kohli

KLR

Pant

HaPa

Dhoni

Jadeja

Bhuvi

Chahal

Bhumrah

 

This team can win the WC... Unfortunately Kohli and team management will have other ideas and might even go with 'no change' against SL.

Edited by asterix
Link to comment
2 minutes ago, vvvslaxman said:

kuldeep is a MUST period.  Archer went for like 79 runs against Pakistan. Did they drop him?  Kuldeep is a game breaker. 

Thats very good post. Kuldeep is must. For me, it should be between Jaddu and Kedhar. What we really want. IMO, With left right combo in opponent side, We are better off having Jaddu as a bowler cum bat instead of Kedhar.

Link to comment
11 minutes ago, vvvslaxman said:

kuldeep is a MUST period.  Archer went for like 79 runs against Pakistan. Did they drop him?  Kuldeep is a game breaker. 

yes, but not on slow pitch Edgbaston... He will be taken to cleaners with the short boundary. You need a Darter like Jaddu.

Link to comment
5 minutes ago, mishra said:

Thats very good post. Kuldeep is must. For me, it should be between Jaddu and Kedhar. What we really want. IMO, With left right combo in opponent side, We are better off having Jaddu as a bowler cum bat instead of Kedhar.

Jadeja is definitely far better than Jadhav as far as bowling is concerned. Battingwise, Kedar is not performing at all and even Jadeja can take singles like him. I would be tempted to play Jadeja over Kedar in all the remaining matches. 

Link to comment
2 minutes ago, asterix said:

yes, but not on slow pitch Edgbaston... He will be taken to cleaners with the short boundary. You need a Darter like Jaddu.

 In that game against England, first 25 overs, we were not prepared, May be they wanted Kohli to run the things by himself. But if Thala and Rohit are active from ball 1 in terms of team management, I am certain that they will make Kuldeep as effective as he could be.

 

Link to comment
29 minutes ago, asterix said:

yes, but not on slow pitch Edgbaston... He will be taken to cleaners with the short boundary. You need a Darter like Jaddu.

They are more comfortable against Right arm seamers than spinners regardless of the last match. They created an illusion in that match like they are some super duper players against spin. They picked 51 (16, 11, 24) runs from last 3 overs of shami.  They can very well target both bhuvi and shami and we can do nothing about it. They practice against such bowlers day in day out. 

Edited by vvvslaxman
Link to comment

^ I think key to success against England is how good we play against Jason Roy. he averages over 60 at destructive SR. Now watch carefully the way he bats. Only weak spots I can see in his batting style is  yorker length or if the ball bounces on 3 4 5th stums just at the height of his belt waist. Get him out as early as possible. Else forget semis

Link to comment

This is Chahal's break down

 

7,9,3,11,15, 6, 2,10,15,12

 

Targeted easily in the end after 40th over.  No wicket to speak. Usually bowls well in the middle. Couple of big overs of 11 and 15 upset our flow. Few reverse sweeps, slog sweeps clicked for them. With slow turn he was up against it. Otherwise he is an impact bowler. If they want to leave out a spinner drop him and pick Jadeja in place of him. India needs 2 spinners against England.  In one match they won't become specialist players against spinners. 

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...