Jump to content

Batsmen let Dravid Down : Gundappa Viswanath


Recommended Posts

'Batsmen let Dravid down' If there is one cricketer who continues to be respected and revered long after his playing days, he is Gundappa Viswanath. The original 'Little Master' of Indian cricket, whose artistic, aesthetic and elegant batsmanship bordered on the sublime, was the last gentleman cricketer, all factors considered. It was said, and continues to be, that Vishy, as he is affectionately known the world over, is such a gentle, noble person that he wouldn't even hurt a fly, let alone speak ill about an individual. But India's shocking ouster from the World Cup has not only disappointed this cheerful, humble soul, but also made him criticise our players. In a rare interview with Haresh Pandya, Viswanath discusses India's disastrous campaign in the Caribbean. Your comments on the performance of Team India, which was billed as one of the semi-finalists in the ongoing World Cup... I don't want to make any comment. If our players play like this, I really feel I shouldn't make any comment on them or their performance. Your tone indicates that you are very upset by India's shocking exit from the World Cup, even before the Super Eight round. As a former India player, humbly proud of having represented my country in an era when the game wasn't at all engulfed by the crass commercialism of today, I must admit I'm not just upset but extremely hurt by the way this team has brought humiliation to the nation. It's the most pathetic performance imaginable. Is this a way to play cricket at the international level? Even we had not played that badly in the first two World Cups, despite the fact that we had very little or no experience of one-day cricket. I'm sure many must have been disillusioned about our present players. What do you think could be the reasons behind India's shoddy performance and shocking defeats at the hands of Bangladesh and Sri Lanka? What's the point discussing such things now? No point crying over spilled water. I think each and every member of the Indian team should indulge in some sort of introspection. So much media hype was built around our players long before the first ball was bowled in the World Cup. Did they become victims of the media hype? I don't know. When you play at the international level and compete in as prestigious an event as World Cup, you should be mentally strong to handle any sort of hype and pressure. Don't you think the BCCI may ask Rahul Dravid to step down or directly dismiss him from the captaincy in the wake of what his team has done in the Caribbean? Dravid's captaincy has nothing to do with India's ouster from the World Cup in the preliminary round itself. It's not his fault. We lost to Bangladesh and Sri Lanka not due to his captaincy. It's his batsmen who let him down. What can a captain, howsoever astute, do in such a situation? Agreed, sir, but don't you think the reins of Team India should now be given to a younger captain? Where's the right candidate? You've to groom a captain, you've to give him time to be mentally prepared for the most difficult job in Indian cricket. You can't pitchfork someone into the cauldron of captaincy and begin to expect positive results. But first of all, let him, whoever he may be, prove to have what it takes to lead the Indian team. Don't you think India has had enough of foreign coaches? If you're talking about Greg Chappell, well, the BCCI has already hinted at his replacement. And even if his contract is renewed, I don't think the Aussie will like to coach this team. I'm told Sandeep Patil's name is being tossed about as a likely replacement. Who do you think should coach the national team, a foreigner or an Indian? What difference does it make? What can a coach do, whether he is from India or abroad, if our players continue to perform the way they did in the World Cup? Cricket is a team sport and each and every player has to contribute for the success of his team. Your coach can only guide you, advise you; he can't go out and even play for you. Do you think there should be drastic changes in Team India in the aftermath of its World Cup debacle? I think there should be at least some changes. In fact, the BCCI has already hinted at what you call drastic changes. But you can't drop all the players together. You've to be careful about the exclusion as well as inclusion of some particular players. What have you to say about Sachin Tendulkar's performance in the World Cup? He has already announced that he is keen to play in the 2011 World Cup as well... Let's not blame Tendulkar or any other individual player. It's a collective failure of the entire Indian team, particularly its batsmen, to deliver when the moment came. If Tendulkar is still enthusiastic, fit and in form, who can stop him from playing in the next World Cup? But he has to show the kind of form and consistency he is famous for. What is your reaction to the treatment meted out to a senior player like Anil Kumble? This hasn't happened with him the first time. In the last World Cup, too, he had been relegated to a mere passenger. Is this a way to treat a great player who has rendered long and loyal services to the country? How can you afford to leave him out in a crucial match? I'm not surprised that he has already announced his retirement from one-day cricket.

Link to comment

Re: Batsmen let Dravid Down : Gundappa Viswanath This is what all Chappell haters should learn: Cricket is a team sport and each and every player has to contribute for the success of his team. Your coach can only guide you, advise you; he can't go out and even play for you. Repeat after me fellows !

Link to comment

Re: Batsmen let Dravid Down : Gundappa Viswanath

Dravid's captaincy has nothing to do with India's ouster from the World Cup in the preliminary round itself. It's not his fault. We lost to Bangladesh and Sri Lanka not due to his captaincy. It's his batsmen who let him down. What can a captain, howsoever astute, do in such a situation?
Good point. One can blame captaincy/coaching/tactics etc. if we had not managed to make the SF from the Super 8 but losing to BD and then the abject surrender against SL is not the captain's fault. What strategies/motivations/team meatings etc. did these bunch of non performers need to beat the BD jokers who are being thrashed mercilessly by every team.
Link to comment

Re: Batsmen let Dravid Down : Gundappa Viswanath

Dravid's captaincy has nothing to do with India's ouster from the World Cup in the preliminary round itself. It's not his fault. We lost to Bangladesh and Sri Lanka not due to his captaincy. It's his batsmen who let him down. What can a captain, howsoever astute, do in such a situation?
Good point. One can blame captaincy/coaching/tactics etc. if we had not managed to make the SF from the Super 8 but losing to BD and then the abject surrender against SL is not the captain's fault. What strategies/motivations/team meatings etc. did these bunch of non performers need to beat the BD jokers who are being thrashed mercilessly by every team.
The batting failures were all mental. The team on the field sagged like an 80-year old pair of balls. And this sheet that's just hitting the prop. all points to the fact that the team was unhappy. How is a team expected to perform when it is unhappy? Dravid leads, and the buck stops with him. If there were players with attitude problems, he had the power to drop them (a la symonds/flintoff) them and chose not to exercise it. If there were issues with the coach, they can be discussed and sorted out. Bruised egos could have been inflated, hurt feelings could be salved. I was happy when he insisted on Sehwag's inclusion -- he needed to show more gumption elsewhere though.
Link to comment

Re: Batsmen let Dravid Down : Gundappa Viswanath

Dravid's captaincy has nothing to do with India's ouster from the World Cup in the preliminary round itself. It's not his fault. We lost to Bangladesh and Sri Lanka not due to his captaincy. It's his batsmen who let him down. What can a captain, howsoever astute, do in such a situation?
Good point. One can blame captaincy/coaching/tactics etc. if we had not managed to make the SF from the Super 8 but losing to BD and then the abject surrender against SL is not the captain's fault. What strategies/motivations/team meatings etc. did these bunch of non performers need to beat the BD jokers who are being thrashed mercilessly by every team.
The batting failures were all mental. The team on the field sagged like an 80-year old pair of balls. And this sheet that's just hitting the prop. all points to the fact that the team was unhappy. How is a team expected to perform when it is unhappy? Dravid leads, and the buck stops with him. If there were players with attitude problems, he had the power to drop them (a la symonds/flintoff) them and chose not to exercise it. If there were issues with the coach, they can be discussed and sorted out. Bruised egos could have been inflated, hurt feelings could be salved. I was happy when he insisted on Sehwag's inclusion -- he needed to show more gumption elsewhere though.
and u forgot, we had players like Ganguly, Tendulkar, Sehwag, Yuvraj, Dhoni, who were enuff for pulling of victory against bangla.. but didnt. and u still blame the captain.. why not these too???
Link to comment

Re: Batsmen let Dravid Down : Gundappa Viswanath

Dravid's captaincy has nothing to do with India's ouster from the World Cup in the preliminary round itself. It's not his fault. We lost to Bangladesh and Sri Lanka not due to his captaincy. It's his batsmen who let him down. What can a captain, howsoever astute, do in such a situation?
Good point. One can blame captaincy/coaching/tactics etc. if we had not managed to make the SF from the Super 8 but losing to BD and then the abject surrender against SL is not the captain's fault. What strategies/motivations/team meatings etc. did these bunch of non performers need to beat the BD jokers who are being thrashed mercilessly by every team.
The batting failures were all mental. The team on the field sagged like an 80-year old pair of balls. And this sheet that's just hitting the prop. all points to the fact that the team was unhappy. How is a team expected to perform when it is unhappy? Dravid leads, and the buck stops with him. If there were players with attitude problems, he had the power to drop them (a la symonds/flintoff) them and chose not to exercise it. If there were issues with the coach, they can be discussed and sorted out. Bruised egos could have been inflated, hurt feelings could be salved. I was happy when he insisted on Sehwag's inclusion -- he needed to show more gumption elsewhere though.
Good point. After reading all the rumous (thanks to shivji for the root of the word), i have come to a conclusion that Dravid as an off-field captain is pretty inept and indecisive in his approach. Knowing Dravid's goodie-goddie nature, he would have tried to look good to both the coach & the team & failed miserably in the process. He must have shown a bit more courage & lined up the other party (opposite to whichever side he took), so everyone pulled together in ONE direction. The best way Dravid can function is under complete team harmony with a cooperative coach. Either BCCI needs to give him that or simply replace him.
Link to comment

Re: Batsmen let Dravid Down : Gundappa Viswanath

The batting failures were all mental.
One doesn't need brains and a functioning mind to beat a cr@p team like BD. Even if the entire team was involved in a round of kabaddi before the match they should have been able to beat $hit like BD.
Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...