Jump to content

'Raped' senior citizen admits to consensual sex


Desi Cartman

Recommended Posts

Disclaimer - Porny DO NOT try this at home! Mumbai police treatment for rape convicts - put your d!ck in a soda bottle and beat the bottle vigorously by a stick (make the carbonated water fizzle). You will be without an erection for a few years.
:ohmy:
Link to comment
Share on other sites

+1' date=' agree with you totally, the cry for death penalty is inappropriate, it should be cut down to a rigourous jail of 15 to 18 years, also i was having a discussion once with a friends dad who is a cop, he said once found guilty of rape and prosecuted for 7 years, the rape accused goes through a living hell in jails, these things are not revealed either by police or court..but its a given that these rape accused undergoes the deadliest of 3rd degrees in jails.[/quote'] What if convict is rich or politically powerful?Do police also give 3rd degree to them Also why don't we hear cases of suicides by rape convicts if treatment is so harsh?
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just relax before you hang her! Feel for the lady... Its not as if he has to undergo some sort of punishment or something..You have to consider her age also while blaming her for not coming out initially' date=' obviously she had to cook up some stories to escape humiliation from the society..As a society we have not matured enough to understand the plight of a lonely old woman indulging in intercourse, [b'] people land society would laugh at her and she has to face social stigma, I can understand if she had cooked up this story...But rightly she had moral courage to accept her mistake to save the accused..Credit to the lady...
You think being raped has less stigma attached to it and what about the stigma of being called a rapist. She was scared of what her children would think...the same children she helped raise.Maybe if she had raised them to be more open minded she wouldn't have had to accuse someone of such a heinous crime. And WTH is wrong with the doctor....since when has sexual intercourse become a sickness. Why the hell was having sex turned into the town's business?She should have told the doctor to mind his/her own business and get going with the treatment instead.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ahmedabad woman, daughter kill Mumbai stockbroker, cut him into 17 pieces http://articles.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/2012-12-24/ahmedabad/35991503_1_ahmedabad-woman-daughter-shah-first

AHMEDABAD: A woman and her daughter from the Maninagar area of Ahmedabad ended the life of a Mumbai stockbroker - with whom both were having an affair - cutting him 17 times, to annex his Rs 17 crore property. Mukti Shah, from the western Mumbai suburb of Kandivli, was found dead in the Anand district of Gujarat on December 12. The 52-year-old woman and her 30-year-old daughter, who were arrested by the Anand police on Friday, have confessed to committing the murder. Shah was killed near Vasad village en route from Ahmedabad to Mumbai. On Sunday, the local crime branch officials recovered the power of attorney for the Rs 17 crore property, which is located in Panvel on the outskirts of Navi Mumbai. Local crime branch inspector R D Dabhi said that the accused are educated and upwardly mobile. The daughter is a fashion designer who had crafted the plan to make Shah sign the power of attorney in her name six months ago. Officials said that this was the first instance of a mother and daughter being involved in such a brutally executed murder. Interestingly, the first clue of a woman being involved in the murder was picked up by Anand superintendent of police who found a plastic bag containing vegetables and a dupatta in Shah's car. Anand police requested the Ahmedabad police to scan call data records which highlighted frequent calls to the two women. They were then picked up for interrogation. The women told police officials said that Shah first came in touch with the woman during his frequent visits to Ahmedabad. The two started an affair and the woman even gave her husband's retirement money to Shah. Later, her daughter too began an affair with Shah and he would regularly go on trips with either the mother or the daughter. When the daughter found that Shah was a rich man and had property in Panvel, a plan began to germinate. On one outing with Shah, she ensured that he became inebriated and had him sign the power of attorney. Later, the two women decided to eliminate him. Third time unlucky The mother-daughter duo wanted to use poison - with which dogs are put to sleep - to kill Shah, but could not draw the poison into a syringe. They then mixed this poison in his tea. When Shah started feeling groggy, the daughter made him sit in the car saying that she would drive him to Mumbai. Her mother sat in the back seat. When the women were sure that Shah had become unconscious, they cut his jugular vein and other veins and dumped him in the car to die. The two confessed that this was their third attempt to finish off Shah. Earlier, the daughter had gone to Lonavala with Shah and had tried to push him off a cliff. When she failed, she again tried to poison Shah in Panvel by spiking his drink, which Shah did not touch. The third time around, the mother lent her a hand and the two succeeded. They wanted to be dead sure After attacking Shah, the two women fled from the car. They were spotted by a motorcyclist who asked them if they were in trouble. The two cooked up a story that they were involved in an accident and needed help. The motorcyclist dropped them at Borsad. After getting down, the two were worried that Shah may still be alive. They took a rickshaw back to the spot to confirm that he indeed was dead.
Hope we are careful enough before demanding laws giving unlimited powers to women. As can be seen not all of them are "abla nari" or innocent victims. Draconian laws in hands of such females can really wreak havoc on the society.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

^ It will take 50 million such cases to balance the scales given how the society has simply disposed off 50 million women.
Agree..... Who is giving women a free for all to kill .This is a case of murder and they will be treated like murderers.Why use stupid examples like this ? They are talking about fair laws of sexual offenses and some men just need an excuse to not let basic human laws for women. Just pick up the paper and see the number of sexual offenses reported every day....why is this acceptable ? For so long the laws have been tipped in favor of women ...why no caution against that?
Link to comment
Share on other sites

^ It will take 50 million such cases to balance the scales given how the society has simply disposed off 50 million women.
:facepalm: Abortion is not = murder .because of pressure from pro choice activists more and more countries are legalising abortion.By your logic the entire west is full of murderers as they abort .The only difference is they do it without knowing sex of child while Indians do it after knowing sex of child
Link to comment
Share on other sites

:facepalm: Abortion is not = murder .because of pressure from pro choice activists more and more countries are legalising abortion.By your logic the entire west is full of murderers as they abort .The only difference is they do it without knowing sex of child while Indians do it after knowing sex of child
Yes abortion is not murder but the disproportionate abortions are a reflection of the outlook of the society towards women and the need for special laws to safeguard their rights. Any law is prone to abuse and such cases should be dealt with at an individual level but to imply that the misuse of laws is happening to the extent of the discrimination against women means you have no touch with reality.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well' date=' if you don't have a problem condoning 50 million murders, what's one more?[/quote'] You are doing turn around very quickly man. If you are considering abortion as murder, go an talk about 1.5 million murders those happen in US on annual basis. It is such lame argument that doesn't deserve any more response.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

You are doing turn around very quickly man. If you are considering abortion as murder, go an talk about 1.5 million murders those happen in US on annual basis. It is such lame argument that doesn't deserve any more response.
US does not see gender disproportionate abortions. Keep on living in your fantasy world where males are victims of gender based crimes.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yes abortion is not murder but the disproportionate abortions are a reflection of the outlook of the society towards women and the need for special laws to safeguard their rights. Any law is prone to abuse and such cases should be dealt with at an individual level but to imply that the misuse of laws is happening to the extent of the discrimination against women means you have no touch with reality.
The condition of women in India is poor and nobody is denying it .,but if you are thinking that one sided laws are solution to it then I don't know what to say.How much dowry demand is controlled by 498a or how much Domestic voilence s contained after DV act 2005? What Raghav said was sensible that bad women are going to misuse women centric laws as in most of these laws women are considered as victims and there iis always much scope of misuse than any other law Misuse of those laws are going affect both men and women as society will see all women using those laws as bad.also is it not our kanoon say that 100 gunehgaar chhoot jaayein par 1 begunah ko saza nahi honi chahiye?
Link to comment
Share on other sites

The condition of women in India is poor and nobody is denying it .,but if you are thinking that one sided laws are solution to it then I don't know what to say.How much dowry demand is controlled by 498a or how much Domestic voilence s contained after DV act 2005? What Raghav said was sensible that bad women are going to misuse women centric laws as in most of these laws women are considered as victims and there iis always much scope of misuse than any other law Misuse of those laws are going affect both men and women as society will see all women using those laws as bad.also is it not our kanoon say that 100 gunehgaar chhoot jaayein par 1 begunah ko saza nahi honi chahiye?
One misuse of law by a female is equivalent of taking justice away from one genuine victim. It doesn't help anybody male or female or society at large. Such cases should be dealt with equal severity as actual cases of crime. These were the numbers of conviction in DV act, 2005 presented in parliament recently by minister Krishna Teerath. Y2009 About 7803 cases were registered and only 8 people were convicted. Y2010 Cases increased to 11736 and only 5 convicted. Y2011 Dropped to 9431 and only 3 convicted. This number simply shows that how many husbands were harassed by this law whom court eventually found not guilty of any crime. One need to understand making strong law is not solution of problem. There should be more focus on law enforcement than law itself.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

The condition of women in India is poor and nobody is denying it .
Nobody is denying it? Look at Raghav's posts in this and other threads and you would think poor men are being victimized by demonic women.
,but if you are thinking that one sided laws are solution to it then I don't know what to say.How much dowry demand is controlled by 498a or how much Domestic voilence s contained after DV act 2005? What Raghav said was sensible that bad women are going to misuse women centric laws as in most of these laws women are considered as victims and there iis always much scope of misuse than any other law
Every law is misused in India. Your suggestion is anarchy? You talk about laws - there are laws which prevent determination of the gender of the child and subsequent abortions. How many of the 50 million imbalance created by such practices have been convicted?
Misuse of those laws are going affect both men and women as society will see all women using those laws as bad.also is it not our kanoon say that 100 gunehgaar chhoot jaayein par 1 begunah ko saza nahi honi chahiye?
Females are systematically discriminated against in our society on a very large scale. They need specific laws to protect this discrimination. Misuse of the law must be dealt with in it's own way but it's crazy to suggest women in India don't need specific laws or the misuse of the law is remotely as widespread or as big a problem as discrimination against women.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...