Jump to content

maniac

Members L2
  • Content count

    41,875
  • Runs

    635,390 
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    81
  • Time Online

    374d 12h 37m 32s

Everything posted by maniac

  1. I have said this many times on this forum in case you missed it let me re-state,I was a fan of Dhoni the player from 2004-2011. After 2011 I thought as a player he was on the down but still for a couple of years after that there was definitely a T.I.N.A factor but I will come back to that. Now as a captain I did not mind him initially and I thought even though he was tactically not great, a.he was a luckly mascot b. He seemed to be a likable guy that everyone in the team could player around.Him coming from a small,non-powerful cricket region did not bring a baggage of politics with him and I thought he was the right man for the job. Now let us look into this bs that oh Dhoni won us all these cups etc. T20 In 2007 WT20- All the inspiring performances came from- Yuvraj,RP Singh,Gambhir,Irfan Pathan and even Sreeshanth,Uthappa and Rohit Sharma to some extent...Dhoni did next to nothing but that was still acceptable because as I said he was the guy with the midas touch and also he was a good supporting act,not everyone gets to be a hero,you need supporting characters too in a movie and he was just that and the lack of hype made it seem good for what it was. Also as I mentioned,he seemed a likable guy that no one really minded leading the team. Not this bs inspiring leadership crap everyone keeps harping on...How many people call Gavaskar an inspiring captain for winning us the World Championship in 1985? it was a young team that pulled it off. Now 2009 was a disaster but fine,defending champions fair enough.....2010 lost badly, 2012 another shot- Lost badly all the while not a single show of leading from the front...didn't we have better options in the T20 format come 2014? Tests Till 2008 He was the understudy of Kumble. 2009 and 2010 he did well but he had a team of Sachin,RD,Laxman,Sehwag,Zak,Bhajji etc etc. fast bowlers stepped up here and there to win us games. Neither was he an inspiring captain nor he showed any special vision. Decent at home,poor abroad but overall captain of a very good team. Again a guy who just went with the flow. Now once he started getting powerful is where the problem started....in 2010 SA series,he destroyed the morale of a rampaging Sreeshanth. Sure,Sreeshanth was obnoxious and annoying but great captains have always worked with guys they hated for the greater good. In 2011 the debacle where his bowling in the first session was a universally ridiculed move took the gas out of the balloon in one move. Infact he was removed from captaincy in tests in 2012 by Mohinder Amarnath before Sreeni Mama stepped in....so was he deserving of this great leader status? ODI's One format where he was a gun player again till may be 2011. Won the WC again with a gem of a team...Played a good innings in the final where it was the 3rd best innings in the game and you are calling the greatest performance in a final lol. He had his utility in this format but his approach has become stale and not evolved with the changes. After the WC,Before and after the CT his results were pretty poor too,so don't know where teh hype is coming from. Now As far as IPL goes. Great performances in the IPL have not seen Rohit Sharma or Gambhir escape criticism for their failures or Poor or mediocre performances in IPL has not impacted Virat Kohli's reputation as a great of the game. Dhoni is just media hype and creation...when it comes to Sachin or any most ATG's ,there is documentary evidence as to why he is a great...with Dhoni it is always,he took 50% of the wickets,or some crap like that. Hence,the annoyance...I personally think Dhoni is a India ATG across 2 of the 3 formats absolutely but he is snot even the Top 10 greatest cricketers produced by India leave alone the world....this hype makes me want to throw up.
  2. We already are on the same page he was a poor test captain,so no arguing that ok fair enough he won the WT20 in 2007,he got kicked out in the first round in 2009,2010,2012.....How many captains have lasted so many failures? was it justified for him to go on and on and on despute failures in that format-so now that is 2/3 formats where he was a failure. Now coming to ODI cricket-Dhoni is a serviceable player in this format no doubt unlike the other 2 formats. I believe no one had a problem with him captaining in 2015 WC as the captain of the defending champions. I have said many times before I was a big fan of Dhoni the player till 2011(never rated his captaincy but thought he was a lucky mascot) . Dhoni has cost us a lot more matches than he has won in recent times......His finishing comes in games where any half decent player can do the same in easy situations....Can you remind me when was the last time Dhoni won a match for us from a position where the game was lost? the only 1 I can remember was that England game with partnership from Yuvi another guy who was over the hill at that point. Dhoni the keeper is also over-rated, he is good when he keeps to spinners but bang average to pace bowlers. He gets the hate because a)because of this cringe-worthy hype...I mean what kind of a narcissist you have to be to produce your own biopic b) There are better alternatives C) He has brought in a lot of politics,favoritism into the game that has undone the hard work of the previous generation
  3. What’s up with the stereotype? Amitabh Bacchan,Govinda all won LS seats because people voted for them for being cinema Stars....Mayawati has statues all over UP...will you walk out of 90% of Maharashtra if you say something against Bal Thackeray? Most states vote for leaders who are cult of personality....every state has atleast one actor from that region who is a movie star. Even though I agree with most of your post why bring region and stereotype into it?
  4. maniac

    Dhoni : a polarizing persona.

    Darren Sammy won 2 WT20s as a captain What is the criteria for this stat here?
  5. So many exciting talents coming up...just today we saw Prasidh and Abhishek....Makarande earlier and obviously all the batting superstars but yet we see Chawla,Vinay etc etc getting contracts. Disgusting
  6. maniac

    Congrats Badri

    Times have changed for sure...back in the day if a former international cricketer was now working as a coach for a team called “Team Karaikudi” that would have made a sob story and a riches to rags story.
  7. maniac

    Experts back Dhoni at No. 5 in Indian ODI team

    I looked through the OP to see who these “experts” are
  8. Good stuff...pretty sure Adam Gilchrist was inspired by Aussie great keeper Rod Marsh for keeping and Viv Richards for his batting ....this is on similar lines
  9. I mean how blatant is the cheating that is happening....it is just pointless watching this game.
  10. I think the voice of our generation L.Siva towards the end was trying to justify his place as a batsman too
  11. Have to watch him bat...if the team management are backing him for his bowling then good luck with that...need to see him bat....so far looked assured in some cameos...at this point he is Ravindra Jadeja circa 2008-2009...hope he has a much better career with the bat than Jadeja,as a bowler though Jadeja is already one of the best spinners we have produced as much as that is a mind fk....and unless it is an anomaly like Jadeja's bowling success,Sundar needs to show some flair and potential with the bat soon.
  12. Saha at his best can score a ugly but resilient 20....DK a beautiful 30 and Parthiv an attractive 40. Now for those additional 20 odd runs and some aesthetically pleasing viewing,the downside is these 2 will single-handedly revive careers and by that I mean careers of opposition batsmen. Cook will be praying right now to have one of these 2 as the keeper for the England series lol
  13. Our greatest ever keeper bat in tests is injured While a freeloader is celebrated for a fluky IPL victory where he had all of maybe 1% contribution at best,our unsung hero who has won us crucial games and is injured ahead of a big series is being largely ignored Too many fans with a lack of cricketing acumen
  14. Cricbuzz is a "chennai centric" website.....Harsha doesn't seem to have too many employment options these days. I will leave the rest for you guys to figure out.
  15. Douglas Marillier of Zimbabwe owned us and Australia with a couple of freak innings, Kamran Akmal played a blinder against us in that Irfan Pathan hattrick match, remember Peter North(I think it is Peter) owning Pakistan with his left arm spin,There was this player for Canada who hit the fastest WC 100 against WI in 2003.....This CSK win was just like a coming together of multiple freak occurrences where good teams like SRH,MI etc etc were caught off guard.A rare fluky occurence I wouldn't read too much into it
  16. CSK winning the IPL is like a run of the mill result like Srilanka winning the WT20 in 2014. They just found themselves in some convinient situations and they had these freak flash in the pan performances by one of the players when the whole team flopped. Neither did they have inspiring captaincy.It was a disaster at that front and they seemed to have been bailed out by these above mentioned freak occurrences. It is just one of those random occurences ...still a mediocre team though.
  17. maniac

    Deepak Chahar is a must for India in 2019 world cup

    No trundlers please
  18. Mad respect..... now the beast will be unleashed fully in LOIS and this is the guy who has done pretty much everything in those formats.
  19. Does he really have to marry them? From the pic it looks like they all get along just fine, if you get my drift :)
  20. Let me answer that for you.... I am definitely rattled that there is an “online opinion poll” conducted somewhere on the internet to determine if my “online persona is cool or not” WTF you seem to reach new levels with every post I concede
  21. Agitated lol....this is called clutching at straws...”other guy” lmfao...yeah I am a desi living in the US.congrats on figuring that out . I have seen you quote this movie multiple times before too trying to engage me on that and I brushed it aside.... never thought someone can be capable of character profile based on a random username and avatar on an online forum....you break new barriers of stupidity every time you post Anyways you seem to be hung up on what’s cool and what’s not,that is a big sign of lack of self esteem lol....I don’t like to indulge in personal attacks but just pointing out the obvious .Anyways as far as Hardik goes he might be a mediocre cricketer according to some or a supremely gifted cricketer but a guy who plays cricket at the highest level or IPL for the matter of fact is cool in my book...hell pretty much every one on this forum will jump at the opportunity to get a selfie with the much maligned Vinay Kumar if they get that opportunity because definetely a guy who debuts at Perth has done a lot more than you and me so that makes him cool too...so what the fk are you blabbering about. Are you one of those gay fashion stylists during Oscar red carpet who determine what is cool and what is not and gossip and judge people? clearly everything points towards that
  22. maniac

    SIXes of the tournament

    Yep....2nd most elegant 6 hitter in India right now
  23. Sometimes you are choo chweet but I felt the same way about those little hamsters...but apparently those assoles bite too
  24. Dude WTF....yeah I get it....you have seen the movie idiocracy ...you seem to be obsessed with it....you figured out some pop culture references good for you lol. You remind me of that Russell Peters joke were the Indian guy at Times Square looks at other Indians and says WTF he is here too? You probably are offended that I get the pop culture reference too that you thought only you had figured out....that’s why you keep harping on it...I have tried to brush it aside before too lol. anyways since you tried to figure me out let me try too...let’s see... whatever 0 fks given
  25. It’s all in good fun from my end still

Guest, sign in to access all features.

×