India's New Middle order player and finisher

[helperononline]

Which new players we should give chance in the middle order let us Chuck our jadhav,dhoni and karthick they are all aged out

Top 3 is already settled (Rohit,shikhar and Kohli) 

May consider p.shaw or Shreyas iyer if one of them is injured 

 

NO4 POSITION -

Gill ( in experienced but he is good technically)

Rahul ( can try him at 4 and 1 )

Rahane ( experienced can consolidate better )

 

NO5 Position-

Pant ( very good batsman but  I don't trust his keeping)

Ishan kishan( inexperienced but he is good technically)

Raina( experienced can be included if reduces his belly and becomes fit once dhoni goes we need experienced finisher)

No 6 position

Vijay Shankar 

Manish Pandey 

No7 pandya or jaddu

 

 

 

 

[srh08]

All good options. Include Iyer who IMO is the top contender for a middle order slot

[prasen82]

1 and 2 

Mayank, KL rahul , shaw

3

Kohli

4

Shubman gill/ shreyas

5

Nitish rana/abhishek Sharma

6 

Pant

7

Pandya

 

All these players should get chances down the line..

[IndianRenegade]

7 hours ago, helperononline said:

 

NO5 Position-

Pant ( very good batsman but  I don't trust his keeping)

Ishan kishan( inexperienced but he is good technically)

Raina( experienced can be included if reduces his belly and becomes fit once dhoni goes we need experienced finisher)

 

 

 

 

No Raina at least in the ODI set up, he does have a few year of cricket left in him. But by the next WC he will already be 36, it’s a another matter if he is currently on fire, and fit. But it’s not the case, we should look forward and not backwards. Both pant and ishan are inexperienced but the only way to solve that is to play them more.

Edited July 14, 2019 by IndianRenegade

[First class]

4 hours ago, srh08 said:

All good options. Include Iyer who IMO is the top contender for a middle order slot

He impressed me a lot with his captaincy in IPL, that too at such a young age. 

[Tendulkar1996]

Rohit

Dhawan (Mayank,Shaw reserve)

Kohli (Gill backup)

Gill or Iyer

Vihari (can bowl,Parag long shot,Shaw can also be tried as lower order hitter)

Pant (Kishan reserve - can bat at 5 if needed)

Pandya/Jadeja

 

Thing to note is one of top 5 needs to be 6th bowler.

[Vijy]

Openers: Rohit, Dhawan (short-term)

Long-term: Shaw, Pant (wk), Rohit (?), Gaekwad

 

No. 3 short-term: Kohli

No. 3 long-term: Gill

 

No. 4 and 5 short- and long-term: Gill, KLR, Mayank, Iyer

 

No. 6 and 7 short- and long-term: Jaddu, Hardik, Abhishek, Lomror, Hooda, Krunal [lack of pace-bowling AR options is worrying. Not convinced by shankar]

 

 

[Ankit_sharma03]

We already have similar thread