Jump to content

Comedian Surleen Kaur targets ISKON & HINDU faith


Texy

Recommended Posts

I would have had no issues had they dared to apply the similar metric to other religions as well. Problem arises when it's all Hindu bashing disguised as comedy. 

 

Can we expect similar jokes about The Prophet and his various (mis)adventures? There in lies your answer. 

Heck can she joke about Guru Gobind's last days as a Mughal Mansabdar) (Yes it's all true. Look it up). 

 

And then we have people randi rona about ICF becoming intolerant. Really folks , do you really expect us to remain silent jab ye sab chutiyapa khuleaam chal ra ho? 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

15 hours ago, Stradlater said:

Heck can she joke about Guru Gobind's last days as a Mughal Mansabdar) (Yes it's all true. Look it up). 

There’s no hard facts.  It’s been refuted by multiple sources and historians. Don’t just go by the translation by an outsider white person, Irwine.  His conclusion was made on mere conjecture by translating Warid’s accounts.    Banerjee has rejected that the notion of service to the Mughals  in the Evolution of Khalsa.  Presence does not mean subservient service. How many of you complain about your history written by outsiders and that no effort has been made to ‘rewrite it’? Furthermore, these accounts are from the chronicles of rival Mughals.  Take it with pinch of salt. 

 

Just to add  a little bit of background context.  Guru Gobind Singh’s father, Guru Tegh Bahadur, (Hind Di Chadar) risked his life to save the lives of Hindu Kashmiri Pandits at the hand of the Mughals and was eventually killed at the orders of Aurangzeb. 

 

Now enter, Guru Gobind Singh, the visionary, the poet, philosopher and revolutionary who would turn ‘sparrows into Hawks’ by uniting the Sikhs into the Khalsa.  Waho Waho Gobing Singh aapay Gur chela.  (The Guru himself became the disciple by taking ‘amrit’ himself from the disciples.  After the battle of Chamkaur, he publicly shamed Aurangzeb with the Zafarnama.  Having fought multiple battles, Guru Gobind also sacrificed his sons, 2 were bricked alive for not converting to Islam and older died in battle. Here’s a family whose three generations were sacrificed.  Submission by being joining the Mughal Army would be in flagrant contradiction to his character and  principles as displayed by his earlier strong opposition and revolutionary  insights.

 

Mere mention of a meeting between him and Bahadur Shah doesn’t indicate that he became subservient to the Mughals via service.  Once again, this has been refuted by Banerjee in The Evolution of Khalsa.  Not to mention, this is account from the rivals, the Mughals.  If that were the case, the Sikhs would have come under the fold of the Mughals. Furthermore, if he did become under the reign of Mughals, why would he be killed by muslims?  Yet after the demise of Guru Gobind, Banda Singh Bahadur led in battle against the Mughals and Bahadur Shah. This would pave the way for Sikh misls in the future and eventually unifying them under Maharaja Ranjit Singh to form the Sikh Kingdom. 

Edited by The Great Punjab
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 6/4/2020 at 2:03 AM, coffee_rules said:

Another rice bag convert stand-up funny boy

 

Same guy prostrating to those who won’t take a joke..

 

EZm6cIrX0AUAUcf?format=jpg&name=large

Well this guy isn't anti-Hindu per se. He made light headed fun of Christianity as well in his other jokes. In real life, he teaches yoga, he teaches Carnatic music and is a professional Carnatic singer. He also prays to Hindu gods. Basically pro Indian culture and anti-west. So this comedy was just light headed. Nothing as crass or offensive as Surleen Kaur. So I wouldn't go far as to say all jokes on hindu should be taken action on. Context and background is required. Especially if comedians make fun of everything not subjected to Hinduism only. 

Edited by I6MTW
Link to comment
Share on other sites

You can’t make fun of Shivaji in Mumbai even with spineless Thackarey at The helm and get away with it. In Agrima’s defence, she was only making fun of Shivaj’s bhakts.

 

She has apologized vehemently after trying to blame ITCell to ShivSena Boss

 

Shivaji is respected all over India, but revered and worshipped in MH. She should’ve known that.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...