Jump to content

What would be your India XIIs if they had to participate in a Test and a T20I match at the same time? Agarkar, More,MSK gives their choices


Recommended Posts

My choices 

 

Test 

  1. Shaw
  2. Mayank 
  3. Pujara 
  4. Kohli (Capt)
  5. Rahane
  6. Vihari
  7. Pant
  8. Ashwin
  9. Bumrah
  10. Ishant
  11. Shami 
  12. Sir Jadeja
  13. Shubhman gill

 

T20s 

 

  1.  Rohit sharma (capt)
  2. KL 
  3. Samson
  4. Iyer 
  5. Hardik Pandya 
  6. DK
  7. Krunal pandya 
  8. Deepak Chahar
  9. Bhuvi 
  10. Saini 
  11. Chahal 
  12. Kuldeep 
  13. SKY
  14. Shreyas gopal 
  15. Krishna 
  • In case this happens in Aus ill take Saini n bhuvi in test match group and add rajpoot n krishna in t20s 
Link to comment
3 hours ago, Suhaan said:

Shikhar Dhawan may well be out of form for life when cricket resumes,i dont think his reflexes will allow him get out of rust after this huge huge break

He will be dropped soon

But Lolli will continue to play him until 2023 world cup.

Link to comment

The guy with the most T20 international 100’s doesn’t make the T20 squad and also no Virat Kohli?

 

our former selectors and 1 potential future chief of selection committee ladies and gentlemen :bow:

 

Edited by maniac
Link to comment

Mayank Agarwal, Prithvi Shaw, Cheteshwar Pujara, Virat Kohli, Ajinkya Rahane, Wridhi Saha, R Ashwin, R Jadeja, Ishant Sharma, M Shami, Jasprit Bumrah

 

 

Rohit Sharma, KL Rahul, Surya Kumar Yadav, Hardik Pandya, Nitish Rana, Dinesh Kartik, Krunal Pandya, Shreyas Gopal, Bhuvneshar Kumar, Deepak Chahar, Yuz Chahal, 

Edited by Sooda
Link to comment
1 hour ago, prudent_kreeda said:

EZovYSwUcAE1ENl?format=png&name=4096x409

and a T20 team with only 4 proper batsmen ?? 

among them also 3 are slow starters 

1 hour ago, prudent_kreeda said:

And we are thinking he can be a very good Chairman of Selection committee. 

after watching this even im having my doubts 

Link to comment

I think on 2nd look Agarkar has a point. You cannot pick the same guy for T20 and Test.

 

Bumrah is one of the best T20 bowler in the world. Heads and shoulders above others. In tests he is good but he is still unproven in India and just had a start to his career.

 

 

Ash-Jadeja,Shami,Ishant and Yadav looks a good enough test bowling attack to take 20

wickets.

 

Where as Bhuvi-Bumrah are our best LOI bowlers at-least on reputation.

 

it makes sense.

 

Link to comment

Priority is test cricket, so will pick my best test XI first. 

 

Tests:

 

Gill

Mayank

Pujara

Kohli (c)

Vihari

Pant (wk)

Jadeja

Ashwin

Ishant

Shami

Bumrah

 

T20s:

 

KLR

Shaw

Iyer

Rohit (c)

Hardik

Karthik (wk)

Gopal

Deepak Chahar (will pick his brother in some conditions)

Bhuvi

Kuldeep

Saini

Link to comment
On 6/4/2020 at 10:01 AM, Ankit_sharma03 said:

My choices 

 

Test 

  1. Shaw
  2. Mayank 
  3. Pujara 
  4. Kohli (Capt)
  5. Rahane
  6. Vihari
  7. Pant
  8. Ashwin
  9. Bumrah
  10. Ishant
  11. Shami 
  12. Sir Jadeja
  13. Shubhman gill

 

T20s 

 

  1.  Rohit sharma (capt)
  2. KL 
  3. Samson
  4. Iyer 
  5. Hardik Pandya 
  6. DK
  7. Krunal pandya 
  8. Deepak Chahar
  9. Bhuvi 
  10. Saini 
  11. Chahal 
  12. Kuldeep 
  13. SKY
  14. Shreyas gopal 
  15. Krishna 
  • In case this happens in Aus ill take Saini n bhuvi in test match group and add rajpoot n krishna in t20s 

i would select a test team and an ODI Team and a T 20 Team.  I will not consider the COMMON POINT ( if they are common so be it).

Among Pacers - I would DROP UMESH, Bring in Deepak Chahar, Avesh Khan and Mohd Siraj. Also would be temted to bring in Shivam Mavi but i am assuming that he is not fit.

Test team

  1. Rohit 
  2. mayank
  3. Pujara
  4. Virat
  5. prithvi will play ahead of shubman gill and rahane. prithvi or shubman gill are my choices.
  6. Vihari or hardik pandey
  7. pant 
  8. kuldeep
  9. Shammi
  10. bumrah
  11. Saini
  12. Ishant is 12th man.

odi

  1. shikhar
  2. rohit
  3. virat
  4. kl rahul
  5. shreyas iyer
  6. hardik pandey
  7. Sanju Samson
  8. jaddu
  9. deepak chahar
  10. Prasidh krishna
  11. shammi or bumrah but only one of them
  12. Mohd Siraj

t20 team

  1. kl rahul
  2. rohit
  3. surya kumar yadav
  4. shivam dubey- hard hitting all rounder , once virat sent him ahead of him and he batted well, indicates that they guy has serious talent. i feel he is better than Vijay Shankar.
  5. hardik Pandya....- hard hitting india's no 1 all rounder
  6. krunnal Pandya- spinning all rounder.
  7. rishabh pant
  8. deepak chahar- pace all rounder
  9. rahul chahar ahead of yuzvendra chahal- spin bowler 
  10. bumrah
  11. bhuvi
  12. Avesh Khan- new fast bowler who can easily bowl 4 overs at 140 K pace specially with the new ball and fetch few wickets.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Edited by vishalvirsingh
Link to comment
5 minutes ago, vishalvirsingh said:
  • prithvi will play ahead of shubman gill and rahane. prithvi or shubman gill are my choices.
  • Vihari or hardik pandey

prithvi is not a no.5 batsman 

Pandya has not played 5 day cricket for long , so playing him in test is risking his body again 

6 minutes ago, vishalvirsingh said:

Sanju Samson

not a no.7 batsman , his runs come when he bats in top 3

8 minutes ago, vishalvirsingh said:
  • surya kumar yadav
  • shivam dubey- hard hitting all rounder , once virat sent him ahead of him and he batted well, indicates that they guy has serious talent. i feel he is better than Vijay Shankar.
  • hardik Pandya....- hard hitting india's no 1 all rounder
  • krunnal Pandya- spinning all rounder.
  • washngton sundar- spin all rounder 

extremely weak batting

SKY is not good at 3 for international cricket

Dubey batting against quality fast bowling is poor

Krunal- batting against quality fast bowling is one the poorest 

sundar at 7 - not a great option either

 

 

Link to comment

in my t 20 team...india"s hardest hitters of the cricket ball are being played - likes of SKY,shivam Dubey, Hardik, Krunnal,rishabh.

Rohit and KL will provide stability.

deepak chahar , bumrah n bhuvi are our best t20 pacers and a rookie fast bowler avesh khan.

rahul chahar is a good spinner n can be ahead of KULCHA as kulcha give too many runs.

 

Link to comment
3 minutes ago, Ankit_sharma03 said:

prithvi is not a no.5 batsman 

Pandya has not played 5 day cricket for long , so playing him in test is risking his body again 

not a no.7 batsman , his runs come when he bats in top 3

extremely weak batting

SKY is not good at 3 for international cricket

Dubey batting against quality fast bowling is poor

Krunal- batting against quality fast bowling is one the poorest 

sundar at 7 - not a great option either

 

 

Prithvi is our Best Batting Talent who scores runs fast in TEST so we have to fit him into a test 11, he is going to replace RAHANE sooner than later. if mayank continues to do well in opening , we cant play Prithvi at no 1 , rohit is Premium. so Prithvi at rahane's place is the only choice. Second choice is shubman gill.

if it is a fast Pitch ( in england or australia), game is won by the medium pace all rounder. we cannot afford to play VIHARI when the Pitch requires a fast bowling all rounder and thats why I have kept it as Vihari as first choice but in fast conditions - hardik.

SKY can play at other batting spots ( not no 3) but his exploits have been great recently and he has batted against best indian fast bowlers so I definitely think that he should be tried out in T20 cricket.

in T20....i have gone for Rishabh/KL and Rohit as Main batsman and others like hardik/dubey/SKY/Krunnal as BIG Game changing Batsman. t20 is about 20 overs and KL and rohit have a tendency to score 50's so in normal conditions we do not need a Shreyas Iyer or a manish Pandey but a SKY or DUBEY OR Hardik to fire straight.

krunnal bowls left arm fastish spin, fields well and bats OK- over all , he is a COMBO Pack and so I would pick him.

washington is dropped as I had missed rishabh.

 

 

 

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...