Jump to content

Ben stokes vs Jason holder vs Sir jadeja vs shakib - The race to become best current test all rounder


Recommended Posts

Ben stokes - 

 

Batting 

Matches - 63

Runs- 4099

Avg - 36.59

 

Bowling 

Wkts- 147

Avg - 32.68

S/r - 59


Jason holder

 

Batting 

Matches - 40

Runs- 1898

Avg - 32.72

 

Bowling 

Wkts- 112

Avg - 25.33

S/r - 59.4

 

Batting wise- Ben stokes

Bowling - Holder

Fielding- Stokes

 

Lets see where this will end. 

Edited by Ankit_sharma03
Link to comment
5 minutes ago, Nikola said:

If we have to just go by stats then jadeja is better than both imo.

 

Batting

1869 runs at avg of 35.26 (63.76 sr) in 71 innings

 

Bowling

213 wickets at 24.62 (60.6 sr) in 94 innings.

 

Im surprised to see jadeja batting avg is 35 , his name shud be added to the list then 

Edited by Ankit_sharma03
Link to comment

Won't go purely by stats....Jadeja in SC, Stokes in SENA, Stokes overall because Jaddu doesn't have much impact outside India. Out of these 3 Holder runner up in SC as well as SENA. All are tremendous cricketers, I will also add Shakib to the mix, purely as an AR I think Shakib has an edge over Jaddu (overall) and he is a gun player in all formats. In fact Shakib must be the most underrated cricketer of the 21st century especially considering what he means to that new cricket nation, Bangladesh. 

Link to comment

Jadeja had/has the potential to become a very good batsman but he I feel he never took it seriously and he didn't have to do much with a formidable batting order. Holder and Stokes are much more important to West Indies and England respectively.

 

Batting - Stokes > Holder > Jadeja

 

On bowling front, Jadeja is easily the best of all the three. Holder has emerged into a great bowler himself and Stokes is the 3rd best.

 

Bowling - Jadeja > Holder > Stokes

 

For fielding - Jadeja ~Stokes > Holder

 

If we also consider the game in pressure situations and the vitality of the player -

 

Jadeja ~~ Stokes > Holder

 

Easily Jadeja is the most underrated player of this era. 

Link to comment
4 hours ago, Ankit_sharma03 said:

Additions to the list

 

Shakib

Batting avg - 39.4

Bowling avg- 31.1

Bowling s/r- 62

 

Sir jadeja

Batting avg-  35.26

Bowling avg-  24.6

Bowling s.r- 60.6

 

 

Can recall some real game changing innings from Jadeja. Shakib is a bog average batsman who hasn't contributed anything to Bangladesh wins/draws. 

Link to comment

Since NZ series in 2016

 

Overall figures
Player Span Mat Runs HS Bat AvDescending 100 Wkts BBI Bowl Av 5 Ct St Ave Diff  
RA Jadeja (INDIA) 2016-2020 32 1374 100* 47.37 1 142 7/48 25.23 5 19 0 22.14 investigate this query
BA Stokes (ENG) 2016-2020 39 2716 135* 38.80 6 93 6/22 28.35 2 57 0 10.44 investigate this query
JO Holder (WI) 2016-2020 24 1239 202* 36.44 2 91 6/42 20.09 7 22 0 16.34 investigate this query
MM Ali (ENG) 2016-2019 30 1328 146 24.59 2 104 6/53 32.56 4 16 0 -7.97 investigate this query
VD Philander (SA) 2016-2020 30 1024 73 24.38 0 94 6/21 22.63 4 9 0 1.74 investigate this query
R Ashwin (INDIA) 2016-2020 35 950 72 22.09 0 172 7/59 25.68 9 11 0 -3.59 investigate this query
MDK Perera (SL) 2016-2019 29 937 92* 20.82 0 97 6/32 39.57 4 12 0 -18.75 investigate this query

 

 

Overall figures
Player Span Mat Runs HS Bat Av 100 Wkts BBI Bowl AvAscending 5 Ct St Ave Diff  
JO Holder (WI) 2016-2020 24 1239 202* 36.44 2 91 6/42 20.09 7 22 0 16.34 investigate this query
VD Philander (SA) 2016-2020 30 1024 73 24.38 0 94 6/21 22.63 4 9 0 1.74 investigate this query
RA Jadeja (INDIA) 2016-2020 32 1374 100* 47.37 1 142 7/48 25.23 5 19 0 22.14 investigate this query
R Ashwin (INDIA) 2016-2020 35 950 72 22.09 0 172 7/59 25.68 9 11 0 -3.59 investigate this query
BA Stokes (ENG) 2016-2020 39 2716 135* 38.80 6 93 6/22 28.35 2 57 0 10.44 investigate this query
MM Ali (ENG) 2016-2019 30 1328 146 24.59 2 104 6/53 32.56 4 16 0 -7.97 investigate this query
MDK Perera (SL) 2016-2019 29 937 92* 20.82 0 97 6/32 39.57 4 12 0 -18.75 investigate this query

 

 

 

Link to comment

Surprisingly there is one guy who has been maintaining very decent numbers atleast a pinch better then stokes

 

 

CDGH, he has played 24 test which is decent 

Batting avg 37 

Bowling avg 31 ( i thoughts its due to home condition but even away his bowling avg is 36 which is not that distant)

 

 

Link to comment
5 hours ago, Khota said:

So the best all rounder in the world Ben Stokes took average of 1 wkt per inning and scored 4.5 runs in an inning. Correct me if I am wrong but both wkts were tails.

 

Once again kindly show me an allrounder.

 

For the upteenth time, all rounders do not exist.

Jo aagaya gurudev

 

U ask me one i give u 4 infact 5 in present world who have done well over a period of time and this is just test cricket....loi will have more 

This list will keep on adding with guys like curran, pandya 

Link to comment
3 minutes ago, Ankit_sharma03 said:

Jo aagaya gurudev

 

U ask me one i give u 4 infact 5 in present world who have done well over a period of time and this is just test cricket....loi will have more 

This list will keep on adding with guys like curran, pandya 

Right now I am just impressed with Stokes. (not really)

Link to comment
6 minutes ago, Khota said:

Right now I am just impressed with Stokes. (not really)

Khota ka swyambar to hai nahin jo impress krke kaam chal jayega

 

Team ka kaam to inse chalta jo wo chala rhe hai and every team is looking for more n more. At the end captain knws what he wants then anyone which is why every team around the world playing n wanting 

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...