Jump to content
Ankit_sharma03

Which would have been a better side - ATG AUS T20 XI vs ATG WI T20 XI (including ex players who never played the format) ???

Recommended Posts

If all time players were playing today and these sides go against each other who would have won ??

I have included current players and tried to select player who wud have played this format the best 

 

Aus ATG XI

 

  1. Gilly (wk)
  2. Watson
  3. Warner
  4. Finch 
  5. Maxwell
  6. Symonds
  7. Hussey (floater)
  8. Warne
  9. Brad hogg
  10. Starc
  11. Lee/ Mcgrath

 

  • Step aside kulcha imagine brad hogg n warne in tandom and if needed they can go for 3 seamers as well
  • why warner at 3 ??? coz he can bat in any gear and allows me to have left right combo 

 

WI ATG XI

 

  1. Gayle
  2. Viv Richards
  3. Lara 
  4. Sobers
  5. Pooran (wk)
  6. Pollard
  7. Russell
  8. Bravo
  9. Narine
  10. Garner
  11. Marshal/Roberts/Holding 
  12. Badree/ Hayden walsh (if they want to play a spinner)

 

 

Link to post
Posted (edited)

Aus xi 

gilly 

hayden 

finch 

maxwell 

symonds 

watson 

Hussey 

warne 

hogg

strac

mcgrath

 

vs wi xi 

gayle 

lara 

viv 

sobers 

pooran

russel

pollard

narine

holding

garner

roberts

Wi batting looks more dangerous.

3-2 in favor of wi 

Edited by kohli
Link to post
21 minutes ago, Ankit_sharma03 said:

If all time players were playing today and these sides go against each other who would have won ??

I have included current players and tried to select player who wud have played this format the best 

 

Aus ATG XI

 

  1. Gilly (wk)
  2. Watson
  3. Warner
  4. Finch 
  5. Maxwell
  6. Symonds
  7. Hussey (floater)
  8. Warne
  9. Brad hogg
  10. Starc
  11. Lee/ Mcgrath

 

  • Step aside kulcha imagine brad hogg n warne in tandom and if needed they can go for 3 seamers as well
  • why warner at 3 ??? coz he can bat in any gear and allows me to have left right combo 

 

WI ATG XI

 

  1. Gayle
  2. Viv Richards
  3. Lara 
  4. Sobers
  5. Pooran (wk)
  6. Pollard
  7. Russell
  8. Bravo
  9. Narine
  10. Garner
  11. Marshal/Roberts/Holding 
  12. Badree/ Hayden walsh (if they want to play a spinner)

 

 

Can you make atg aus test xi vs atg wi test xi 

Link to post
32 minutes ago, GeeGaw said:

He may become ATG for WI but it’s way too early to put Pooran on this list. I would put Johnson Charles in there for the time being. Maybe even Chanderpaul but I don’t know how his game would translate to T20i. 

he aint an ATG but as keeper batsman with lack of competition in WI side it becomes easy for him

Link to post
36 minutes ago, Jay said:

West Indies ATG defecates on any Aussie lineup in the T20 format. 

 

Aussies lack power hitting and good bowlers of Yorkers apart from Starc who is wild. 

Gilly watson warner symonds maxwell finch - how does aussie lack power hitting?? 

That aussie lineup is as scary as it cud get

 

Even wi lack spin bowling quality compare to aus, narine post action change hasnt been half as effective. 

 

Link to post
6 hours ago, Ankit_sharma03 said:

Gilly watson warner symonds maxwell finch - how does aussie lack power hitting?? 

That aussie lineup is as scary as it cud get

 

Even wi lack spin bowling quality compare to aus, narine post action change hasnt been half as effective. 

 

In ODI sure. T20 NhA. There is a reason why they never could win a WC in t20 format. 

 

Depends on pitches anyway. Overall I still don't see them beating the goat version w.indies. 

 

Infact goat Indian T20 side would demolish them I reckon. 

Link to post
On 6/6/2021 at 1:13 PM, Ankit_sharma03 said:

he aint an ATG but as keeper batsman with lack of competition in WI side it becomes easy for him

Fair enough.  It is surprising the lack of batting prowess at the wicketkeeper position WI have had over the years. 

Link to post

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...