What should be India's top 6 for the ODI world cup

[rkt.india]

TBH, Rohit according to me has past it as an LOI batsman.

[Majestic]

SKY bowling will solve the problems.

[Jay]

2 hours ago, rkt.india said:

Rohit

Dhawan/Shaw

Kohli

Pant/Kishan/Rahul as wk

Sky

Pandya

Jaddu

Chahar

Bishnoi/Sundar

Bumrah

Siraj/Prasidh

 

This is 16 member squad. Can have Ruturaj in place of Shaw because he is good against spin.

Would take gabbar over rohit In loi. We don't need kuli and rohit at all tbh.

If we are *ing playing boult or shaheen. Use a *ing leftie is what we need to do. Our management is beyond retarded. They know leftie In swing is our kryptonite yet they will still play useless rohit and kela. 

 

Kela should be middle order. Period. Number 5. Or he can go kiss his own ass. 

 

Number 1 and 2 should be a leftie like dhawan or ishan with gaikwad.

[anish2tweet]

TOP 6

Rohit

Ishan Kishan / Shaw (Must play for Power Play)

Kohli

Dhawan/KL Rahul (I would prefer Dhawan over Rahul as he is more consistent)

SKY

Pant

 

Next 5

Jadeja

Deepak Chahar

Shardul Thakur/Bishnoi

Bumrah

Shami/Prasidh

 

If we want to play 2 spinners, then go for Bishnoi ahead of Thakur.

 

Edited January 25, 2022 by anish2tweet
Included Shaw as he is very important for PP

[rkt.india]

1 hour ago, Jay said:

Would take gabbar over rohit In loi. We don't need kuli and rohit at all tbh.

If we are *ing playing boult or shaheen. Use a *ing leftie is what we need to do. Our management is beyond retarded. They know leftie In swing is our kryptonite yet they will still play useless rohit and kela. 

 

Kela should be middle order. Period. Number 5. Or he can go kiss his own ass. 

 

Number 1 and 2 should be a leftie like dhawan or ishan with gaikwad.

Ishan Kishan is unreliable top of the order.

[Jay]

53 minutes ago, rkt.india said:

Ishan Kishan is unreliable top of the order.

Panty then. Only time you get to smash is in power play vs top bowlers and death. 

[Adamant]

2 hours ago, Jay said:

Would take gabbar over rohit In loi. We don't need kuli and rohit at all tbh.

If we are *ing playing boult or shaheen. Use a *ing leftie is what we need to do. Our management is beyond retarded. They know leftie In swing is our kryptonite yet they will still play useless rohit and kela. 

 

Kela should be middle order. Period. Number 5. Or he can go kiss his own ass. 

 

Number 1 and 2 should be a leftie like dhawan or ishan with gaikwad.

But we used Ishan Kishan against Boult in the world t20, didn't help much. 

[anish2tweet]

But we used Ishan Kishan against Boult in the world t20, didn't help much. 

Give him more chances. Sab ko ek ek chance denge tho, we could not have seen the likes of Jadeja etc

Sent from my CPH1819 using Tapatalk

[Jay]

9 minutes ago, Adamant said:

But we used Ishan Kishan against Boult in the world t20, didn't help much. 

How many chances did he get before that game? Can't just Chuck him In there without match practice in a pressure game. 

[Swag]

Rahul, Dhawan, VK, Rohit & Iyer in a top 5 gives me absolutely no confidence.

We will bash minnows but fall at the first major hurdle.

[rkt.india]

6 hours ago, Jay said:

Would take gabbar over rohit In loi. We don't need kuli and rohit at all tbh.

If we are *ing playing boult or shaheen. Use a *ing leftie is what we need to do. Our management is beyond retarded. They know leftie In swing is our kryptonite yet they will still play useless rohit and kela. 

 

Kela should be middle order. Period. Number 5. Or he can go kiss his own ass. 

 

Number 1 and 2 should be a leftie like dhawan or ishan with gaikwad.

Last WC, Rohit was our biggest player.

[QuarantineTormentino]

Having dhawan, rohit, Kohli, KL and Shreyas as 5 out of your top 6 esp in LOIs is just asking for disaster lol. At max only 2 of them should be there. Ideally Rohit (captain) and Kohli (even though he’s not the batsman he once was he’s still unbelievably consistent. At his worst he’s still a better no.3/4 than Iyer/KL. He may have lost his ability to score quickly, but he’s still very good at accumulating runs and dropping sheet anchor)

Edited January 25, 2022 by QuarantineTormentino

[vvvslaxman]

Unless they strengthen 5/6/7 they ain't wining anything.  Right now none of them are reliable. We used to make fun of Kedar Jadhav. Looking back he played in one of the most difficult batting position. His career strike rate is over 100. Jadeja at no.7 has a strike rate of 94. It is not enough. Basically he scores 23 runs in 25 balls on an average.

[Majestic]

10 minutes ago, vvvslaxman said:

Unless they strengthen 5/6/7 they ain't wining anything.  Right now none of them are reliable. We used to make fun of Kedar Jadhav. Looking back he played in one of the most difficult batting position. His career strike rate is over 100. Jadeja at no.7 has a strike rate of 94. It is not enough. Basically he scores 23 runs in 25 balls on an average.

Jadhav was very good for a couple of years (2016-18) but then was past it.

[Vijy]

1. Shaw --> inconsistent opener who scores at 120 SR

2. Kishan/Pant (wk) --> inconsistent opener who scores at 120 SR

3. Gaekwad --> should be capable of both attack and defense, based on the context

4. Gill/Rohit/Virat --> this is the designated consolidator, who will tuk-tuk if early wkts fall. And will bat down the order if a big partnership occurs at top

5. KLR/SKY --> I do not like KLR as opener, but I do think he has done well at No. 5

6. Pandu/Sundar --> both are batting ARs, who can fulfill 6th bowler option

 

Another option:

1. Shaw

2. Rohit/Dhawan --> senior opener, there to tuk-tuk. Rohit can also captain

3. Gaekwad

4. KLR/Kohli --> consolidator in case of early wkts.

5. Pant/KLR (wk)

6. Pandu/Sundar

 

In either team, here is the batting till 9 IMO:

 

7. Deepak/Lord

8. Axar

9. Markande/Rahul Chahar --> both can bat a bit, and are wrist spinners. Bishnoi is another option.

 

10. Boom/Shami

11. Siraj/Prasidh