Jump to content
Under_Score

Progress of Punjab under the new leadership of Bhagwant Mann

Recommended Posts

3 hours ago, ravishingravi said:

As expected, he is going to double down on socialism and govt jobs to avoid structural problems which frankly no govt can solve. I don’t begrudge them. State is a gone case. A very tough cocktail of jaahil, fundamentalists, addicts and revolutionaries. 
 

If AAP plays smart, they should keep handing out as much as possible because honestly Punjab is in the bag. They can run deficit as high as possible and central govt will fund them. But they can do good story around turnaround which may never happen. 

Why will centre fund them? Assumption that Centre will be blackmailed because of strategic importance of state may not be absolute.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

And the figures being quoted are 35,000 crore is lost per year in Punjab due to evasion etc.

 

Aap promises will add  a burden of 20,000 crore.

 

Aap have also promised no new taxes.

 

So the key question is how efficient are Aap in plugging said holes.

 

If they can get 15000 from the evasion column into the revenue column (easier said than done). Then imo they will have fulfilled their promises.

 

I was looking at punjab and the share of informal is on the higher side.

 

I feel this approach wont reduce the punjab debt burden in % terms but will not add to it either.

 

If you look at Maharashtra, Devendra Fadnavis achieved a lot of debt reduction via closing loopholes and clamping down on evasion.

 

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

13 hours ago, mishra said:

Why will centre fund them? Assumption that Centre will be blackmailed because of strategic importance of state may not be absolute.

 

Centre will be blackmailed and centre has an incentive to intervene. If you see Delhi during covid 19, AAP screwed up big time. Amit Shah took over and normalised the situation. But who remembers ? 

 

Punjab bonds are not worthless yet. But pretty soon they will pressure govt to increase their budget. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 3/19/2022 at 10:53 PM, sarchasm said:

 

Punjab runs on bheekh from rest of India in the form of grants from center. The plan is to enhance government spend mindlessly and ask center for money - and when denied - cry about Punjab not getting its due etc. Create a sense of grievance combined with hateful khalistani manure being mainstreamed.

 

Only today, these langarjeets have stopped vehicles from Himachal entering the state because the government in Himachal confiscated khalistani flags from a bunch of them.

 

Many, many people predicted this would happen. The beggars of Punjab want Hindu money.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Posted (edited)

The Congress & Akali Dal are responsible for the present situation in Punjab....especially the Badals who just focused on making money & more money. This is the main reason AAP was given a chance by the people of Punjab this time.

 

Bhagwant Mann probably thought that if Ambanis & Adanis can get massive loans waived off....then He can also try. I feel sorry for him....He had to ask for this because of the mistake done by other crook politicians.

 

From the article posted below, not sure what the actual numbers are....still you can't deny that BJP helped crooks like these & also Election fund providers like Ambani & Adani.

 

The Modi government has waived Rs 68,607 crore of the top 50 bank loan defaulters, including Nirav Modi, Mehul Choksi and Vijay Mallya, the Congress alleged on Tuesday citing an RTI reply from the Reserve Bank of India (RBI).

 

https://www.businesstoday.in/latest/economy-politics/story/bjp-govt-waived-rs-68607-crore-of-bank-loan-defaulters-alleges-congress-256685-2020-04-28

 

 

Edited by Under_Score
Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, Under_Score said:

The Congress & Akali Dal are responsible for the present situation in Punjab....especially the Badals who just focused on making money & more money. This is the main reason AAP was given a chance by the people of Punjab this time.

 

Bhagwant Mann probably thought that if Ambanis & Adanis can get massive loans waived off....then He can also try. I feel sorry for him....He had to ask for this because of the mistake done by other crook politicians.

 

Eh? When did the waivers happen? Was this ever proven? But it is puzzling that a math genius who went to IIT states that he knows where money for freebies will come from and then come begging for money through Mann? 

 

What happened? Galti se mistake? 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, bharathh said:

 

Eh? When did the waivers happen? Was this ever proven? But it is puzzling that a math genius who went to IIT states that he knows where money for freebies will come from and then come begging for money through Mann? 

 

What happened? Galti se mistake? 

Do you think that BJP is a very clean and non-corrupt party?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, Under_Score said:

Do you think that BJP is a very clean and non-corrupt party?

You made the claim .. I don't know if they are clean and non-corrupt. So far nothing has been proven against them. If what you are saying is true - that is a very serious offence.

 

But do prove your claim. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, bharathh said:

You made the claim .. I don't know if they are clean and non-corrupt. So far nothing has been proven against them. If what you are saying is true - that is a very serious offence.

 

But do prove your claim. 

Nothing gets proved against any ruling party in India when they are still in power....same goes to Congress as well. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 minutes ago, Under_Score said:

Nothing gets proved against any ruling party in India when they are still in power....same goes to Congress as well. 

A lot of scams against the Congress were proven. In fact barely a week went by when a new scam against someone in UPA 2 was brought up. So basically you just made up what you said? 

Edited by bharathh
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, bharathh said:

A lot of scams against the Congress were proven. In fact barely a week went by when a new scam against someone in UPA 2 was brought up. So basically you just made up what you said? 

Any ruling party....doesn't matter BJP or Congress....until it is in power, it will wield the corrupt wand & nothing gets proven...only when power changes at the centre....Sarkari babus start spilling the beans since they are now under the control of 'New' Govt. You can deny all you want....your choice. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 minutes ago, Under_Score said:

Any ruling party....doesn't matter BJP or Congress....until it is in power, it will wield the corrupt wand & nothing gets proven...only when power changes at the centre....Sarkari babus start spilling the beans since they are now under the control of 'New' Govt. You can deny all you want....your choice. 

So why not wait until something gets proven before making up stuff? 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Under_Score said:

Do you think that BJP is a very clean and non-corrupt party?

Its most efficient transparent and competent along with grand plans. Do you think Chinese leadership didn’t take Kickbacks. But they delivered. Same is true with BJP. They have two groups. Ones groups job is to ensure BJP doesn’t get bankrupt to loose election for lack of funds

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, bharathh said:

So why not wait until something gets proven before making up stuff? 

I know for certaininty that Sarkari Baboos aren’t happy under BJP as cut is directly dealt at too level and closed. Cut percentage compared to project is negligible vis a vis how much contractors had to pay during Congress era.

 

To simplify, Congress era they wanted to make a millions when doing project worth 8-10 million. In BJP era they make 5-10 million and do a project worth billion. So they are earning more then Congress.

Edited by mishra
Link to comment
Share on other sites

See i think mann will try to get as much as possible. He will ask for 50k crore knowing full well CG wont give. Its a political move with no downside.

 

Punjab should get its fair share. But other states too will demand...there is a formula

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites



×
×
  • Create New...