Jump to content
MultiB48

So Liberal

Recommended Posts

16 minutes ago, bharathh said:

Boycott says Hi

 

May as well become a Swara 2.0 now. 

Actually it may be Swara effect. True story. I met a Pakistani. He convinced me that Mohammed Ali Jinnah was not responsible for partition but it was Nehuru and Patel. Basis was Cabinet Mission recommendation.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1946_Cabinet_Mission_to_India

 

But somewhere in back of my mind, it came coming that it cant be as simple as that I had to do a lot of studying to understand why INC rejected the idea. Basically, it was to do with Muslim Leagues communal activities.The citations by Ambedkar and all anti India activities in runup to Independence and support of delayed independence and hundreds of other material. Sum total of it was when Jinnah agreed to Cabinet Commission, he himself was not confident of Pakistan surviving/managing at the same time loosing millions of pottential population to convert to Islam.

 

So, one has to be very carefull when indulging in disscussions else you yourself get sold the wrong idea.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Chadha is a complete idiot I bet 99% Indians don't know what exactly happened in Galwan..  It's well hidden by both Indian & Chinese govt...  Only tid bits have come out. 

 

PoK is not coming unless u want a nuclear exchange. It's a huge chunk of land.   It's for standard domestic audience consumption....  Just like Paxtani Jernail says Kashmir will be back to Pak for its delusional awaam. 

They celebrate defence day for freakin 1965 war lol....  Indian tanks rolling in Lahore & Sialkot almost getting captured is their victory lol

Link to comment
Share on other sites

12 hours ago, Lone Wolf said:

Chadha is a complete idiot I bet 99% Indians don't know what exactly happened in Galwan..  It's well hidden by both Indian & Chinese govt...  Only tid bits have come out. 

 

PoK is not coming unless u want a nuclear exchange. It's a huge chunk of land.   It's for standard domestic audience consumption....  Just like Paxtani Jernail says Kashmir will be back to Pak for its delusional awaam. 

They celebrate defence day for freakin 1965 war lol....  Indian tanks rolling in Lahore & Sialkot almost getting captured is their victory lol

Even if we take PoK with the existing people there it will only be like shooting ourselves in the foot. Our army would be chasing their tails vs the populace there which is completely pro-Pak. Only major advantage is that we can take over the areas where launch pads are and get closer to flat lands which are tougher to defend for Pak. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

20 minutes ago, bharathh said:

Even if we take PoK with the existing people there it will only be like shooting ourselves in the foot. Our army would be chasing their tails vs the populace there which is completely pro-Pak. Only major advantage is that we can take over the areas where launch pads are and get closer to flat lands which are tougher to defend for Pak. 

It will be existential threat for Pakistan....  India would pick & choose date & time & entire Islamabad would be under siege in hours....  KPK would be in smokes in a couple of hours via another front. 

Kashmir prevents mechanized infantry warfare...  Any country with its 100% control would have massive massive advantage. 

Not to mention all that water resources...  Pakistan may as well accede itself to India than losing PoK. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, Lone Wolf said:

It will be existential threat for Pakistan....  India would pick & choose date & time & entire Islamabad would be under siege in hours....  KPK would be in smokes in a couple of hours via another front. 

Kashmir prevents mechanized infantry warfare...  Any country with its 100% control would have massive massive advantage. 

Not to mention all that water resources...  Pakistan may as well accede itself to India than losing PoK. 

But that would turn nuclear. So no point going for it unless we can take over Pak also .. only taking PoK is inviting nuclear war. China wont remain neutral 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, bharathh said:

But that would turn nuclear. So no point going for it unless we can take over Pak also .. only taking PoK is inviting nuclear war. China wont remain neutral 

Indians need to be very clear. PoK is neither Punjab or Pakistan. Pakistan calls it Azad Kashmir for a reason.  Deep down in their heart, every Pakistani startegic affairs expert knows that one day India will come for it . Congress passed unanimous resolution in parliament to retrieve PoK in event of Pakistani army does excesses in poK and Narsimha Rao ji, So Indian intention o get PoK has support across party line.

 

A nuclear war will finish Pakistan for good. Not only that, Most likely UN will end up disarming all Muslim nations as well. Now question is, Will Punjabis and Pakistanis risk their existence for sake of these so called Azad Kashmiris who allmost all of themselves have left that land for UK and EU ?

IMO, War will be only faught in Kashmir. Point is can Indian army and diplomacy afford a war in Kashmir or shall we wait few more years to make the gap between two nation wider while further reduce the gap between India and China.

Edited by mishra
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 12/1/2022 at 1:19 AM, diga said:

Our friends from Lemuria should know this well ... they have had some success with Sterlite

Even in the Kudankulam nuclear protest which didn’t work out.

 

https://www.opindia.com/2017/06/church-backed-activism-fueled-the-kudankulam-protest-republic-tv-report/amp/

 

https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/a-decade-on-kudankulam-nuclear-plant-protesters-say-still-face-ordeal-101654455406226-amp.html

 

 

Edited by coffee_rules
Link to comment
Share on other sites



×
×
  • Create New...