Jump to content

IPL 2023 XI ( Initial version)


Majestic

Recommended Posts

No team is purely selected based on a season of IPL. If so, Ind would have to change its team every year (which can be a recipe for disaster) :facepalm:

 

It is like someone making a team of the season of BBL or whatever and then suggesting that Aus should be playing these players (and as if Aus is only going to play in Aus)

Edited by zen
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Suddenly we hear, national side selection can't be based on IPL performance

Few years ago,fraudya fans were adamant about replicating MI and superimpose it on national side,goals tend to shift, that's periodic subject to convenience :wp23:

 

Who said one season performance?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 hours ago, Suhaan said:

Suddenly we hear, national side selection can't be based on IPL performance

Few years ago,fraudya fans were adamant about replicating MI and superimpose it on national side,goals tend to shift, that's periodic subject to convenience :wp23:

 

Who said one season performance?


If you are referring to my post, nothing like that is implied :hmmm:

 

I said that selections based on one-season performance should be avoided (even BCCI has made that general guideline iirc based on learnings from experience). Exceptions include a tried & tested player who is showing good form, a player who can bring in a particular skill immediately (Harshal was brought in the past for his death bowling, Umran for pace, Varun C for mystery spin, etc., but these guys have been in and off too or been conditions specific), when a team is seeking to replace those past their prime (and there is some unusual widely spoken talent available), etc.

 

The key group of players, around whom a team (whether IPL or national or whatever) is built (or to be built in a rebuilding initiative), remains the same over a period of time. No country picks teams based on one season or it could be changing players after every season, impacting consistency and long-term team-building initiatives!

 

 

Edited by zen
Link to comment
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...