Jump to content

Rohit Kohli and Bumrah to be rested for SL ODIs Rahul/Pandya to lead- Reports

Lone Wolf

By Lone Wolf
in Cricket Talk

Recommended Posts

Nikhil_cric Grand Master

Nikhil_cric

Posted
Posted
2 hours ago, Suhaan said:

But do you believe we select squads based on conditions?

Seldomly we have done it in history

Iyer is so bad against short deliveries that even an ICC monitored sporting pitch will cause him trouble

 

Conditions are probably what led to Rinku's omission in West Indies.  

 

His record  against spin and against pacers bowling hard lengths into the body and wide lines is quite weak even in IPL.

 

On Caribbean wickets, spin and slower ball hard lengths from pacers are much tougher to play than IPL pitches . So his omission did have some logic 

 

Harder to predict who will succeed though unless they've actually played there. 

 

Imo, BCCI should look to arrange 3-4 ODI tours of SA/OZ  before the next World Cup to figure out who can play in these conditions. 

 

On the recent tour, Sai and Sanju were easily the best batters in SA. 

 

 

 

 

 

Suhaan Grand Master

Suhaan

Posted
Posted
3 hours ago, Frustrated said:

Why do some posters want S Iyer back?  The guy is so trash against quality pace in general & slower off cutters (or bouncers in particular) that he is likely to struggle even on flat asian pattas.  WC2023 Final is a testimony to that.  He didn't last 5 balls.  All he needed to do was anchor the inning for next 10-15 overs. (Ind were 65/2 in 9 overs when this Fraud arrived at the crease)

Aage peeche jau na jau,unsure about his ability play deliveries irrespective of their length is his huge fall

He is very insecure about his ability to play those

Frustrated Grand Master

Frustrated

Posted
Posted
14 minutes ago, Suhaan said:

Aage peeche jau na jau,unsure about his ability play deliveries irrespective of their length is his huge fall

He is very insecure about his ability to play those

Yep.   We hv better players who hv all bases covered.   No need to go back to S Iyer who can't figure out his technical flaws despite having played 5+ yr of intl cricket.  On top of that, he has a history of disciplinary issues.  

Kron Grand Master

Kron

Posted
Posted
5 hours ago, Nikhil_cric said:

 

Conditions are probably what led to Rinku's omission in West Indies.  

 

His record  against spin and against pacers bowling hard lengths into the body and wide lines is quite weak even in IPL.

 

On Caribbean wickets, spin and slower ball hard lengths from pacers are much tougher to play than IPL pitches . So his omission did have some logic 

 

Harder to predict who will succeed though unless they've actually played there. 

 

Imo, BCCI should look to arrange 3-4 ODI tours of SA/OZ  before the next World Cup to figure out who can play in these conditions. 

 

On the recent tour, Sai and Sanju were easily the best batters in SA. 

 

 

 

 

 

Samson never had issues vs pace and bounce. His problem is vs leg spin 

Lord Grand Master

Lord

Posted
Posted
9 hours ago, Nikhil_cric said:

 

Conditions are probably what led to Rinku's omission in West Indies.  

 

His record  against spin and against pacers bowling hard lengths into the body and wide lines is quite weak even in IPL.

 

On Caribbean wickets, spin and slower ball hard lengths from pacers are much tougher to play than IPL pitches . So his omission did have some logic 

 

Harder to predict who will succeed though unless they've actually played there. 

 

Imo, BCCI should look to arrange 3-4 ODI tours of SA/OZ  before the next World Cup to figure out who can play in these conditions. 

 

On the recent tour, Sai and Sanju were easily the best batters in SA. 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Rinku also did well in T20s there IIRC

Ultimate_Game Grand Master

Ultimate_Game

Posted
Posted
11 minutes ago, Majestic said:

Gill

Jaiswal

KL Rahul

S Iyer

Pant(wkt)

Pandya

Jadeja

Kuldeep

Prasidh??

Arshdeep

Siraj

 

 

That's a pretty long tail, and with likes of KL Rahul, Jadeja and Prasidh that's a pretty regressive playing XI. WC 2023 and the recent WT20 should've been enough to show KL Rahul is not needed anymore. Better to give chances to Rinku with List A average of 50 and with temperament to boot, or trying Nitish Reddy or even Venky Iyer would be much better than going back to these TTFs.

 

Prasidh hasn't shown anything to be backed - he was absolutely useless the last time we saw him and he hasn't done anything to show he has improved. I would rather back someone like Harshit Rana, Akash Deep or Mohsin Khan - at least we get to see their potential rather than rehashing the same old.

express bowling Grand Master

express bowling

Posted
Posted (edited)

ODIs .... my preferred squad

 

1. Gill

2. Jaiswal  .. LHB

3. Shreyas

4. Pant .. LHB 

5. Rahul

6. Hardik

7. Axar .. LHB 

8. Harshit

9. Akashdeep 

10. Kuldeep .. LHB 

11. Siraj

 

12. Samson

13. Rinku .. LHB 

14. Washington ?  .. LHB

15. Arshdeep 

 

 

Would be nice if we get a better hitter cum spinner than Washington.

Edited by express bowling
singhvivek141 Grand Master

singhvivek141

Posted
Posted

For SL ODI's, my choice will be

 

1. Gill

2. Jaiswal

3. Shreyas 

4. Pant (wk)

5. Rinku

6. Hardik

7. Axar

8. Rana

9. Kuldeep

10. Arshdeep

11. Siraj

 

12. Gaekwad

13. Jurel (wk)

14. Washington

15. Avesh 

 

I don't want Rahul anywhere near the team in any format. 32 year old already.

MK55 Grand Master

MK55

Posted
Posted (edited)

I’ll prefer KL as the captain in ODIs any day over this clown Pandya. KL is also more likely to play some quick bowlers in the side.

Pandya is a disaster for bowling selections n ultra defensive in giving them spells during the match. He has done this every single time he has access to such bowlers. That clown may even open up the bowling himself if the conditions are slightly favorable to bowl.

This will be magnified as I’m sure that World Cup win must have gone to his small head lol.

Edited by MK55
vayuu1 Mentor

vayuu1

Posted
Posted (edited)
On 7/8/2024 at 8:57 PM, Kron said:

Rutrajaa

Jaiswal

Giĺly

Pant

Rinku

Pandya

Venky iyer

Axar

Arshdeep

Bumrah

Mayank

 

That would be some team

Bumrah is rested 

Team should be 

Ritu/gill

Jaiswal 

Rahul

pant 

sky

Iyer/rinku

Panda/washi/venky

Axar 

Kuldeep/Bishnoi 

Arshdeep 

Mayank 

Siraj 

U can also take Harshit rana, Abhishek,rinku in t20's

Edited by vayuu1
vishalvirsingh Veteran

vishalvirsingh

Posted
Posted
8 hours ago, vayuu1 said:

Bumrah is rested 

Team should be 

Ritu/gill

Jaiswal 

Rahul

pant 

sky

Iyer/rinku

Panda/washi/venky

Axar 

Kuldeep/Bishnoi 

Arshdeep 

Mayank 

Siraj 

U can also take Harshit rana, Abhishek,rinku in t20's

Rituraj is ideally a Test Batsman- i would not  pick him as I am spoilt for choices.

ODI Squad-

  1. Yashasvi
  2. Abhishek Sharma 
  3. GILL
  4. Shreyas Iyer
  5. Hardik Pandya-captain
  6. Tilak Verma - left-arm batsman OR Nitish Reddy if he is fit - can't consider Dube as An all-rounder for ODI, he is just a batsman. i will probably drop him from both teams as His bowling capability is very Bad. as a batsman SKY in t20/Rinku Singh
  7. Riyan Parag- Spin All rounder
  8. Washington -Spin All-rounder
  9. Harshit Rana- PACER who can bat
  10. Mayank Yadav- I won't pick arshdeep in ODI.
  11. Siraj..if BOOM is out we need Siraj to lead the attack in ODI's.
  12. Rinku Singh
  13. Sanju Samson as Wicketkeeper in ODI, I feel he deserves more than PANT in ODI.
  14. Tushar Deshpande- he is probably better than AVESH and Mukesh.
  15. Khaleel ahead of Yash dayal
  16. Bishnoi as Kuldeep can be picked in tests and can relax in this series.

 

t20 squad

  1. SKY - captain
  2.  Abhishek
  3. tilak verma
  4. riyan parag
  5. Washington- SPIN AR
  6. harshit rana- pacer who can bat
  7. Siraj- Pace lead
  8. vijay kumar vyashak- known as a restrictive pacer and bowls 140 + too.
  9. khaleel- left arm Pace.
  10. Arsh deep- left arm 
  11. Pant - as keeper for t20
  12. Rinku singh
  13. Hardik Pandya
  14. Jaiswal yashasvi

 

 

 

 

 

MumInd Proficient

MumInd

Posted
Posted

ODI

 

Rutu

Jaiswal

Gill

KL

Pant

Pandu

Jadeja

Washy

Kuldeep

Deshpande

Siraj

 

T20

 

Sharma

Rutu

SKY

Samson

Dube

Rinku

Pandya

Washy

Bishnoi

Arshadeep

Deshpande

 

 

Lone Wolf Grand Master

Lone Wolf

Posted
  • Author
Posted
On 7/10/2024 at 8:39 PM, Nikhil_cric said:

Jury still out on Rinku. 

Rinku is a closest we have to a complete left hand middle order bat we need who can rotate strike and hit big vs spin and pace & is not a leg side hack vs spin and Pace.

Strong slog sweeper and can hit over extra cover.

Rare combo among Indian batters 

Lone Wolf Grand Master

Lone Wolf

Posted
  • Author
Posted
1 hour ago, Gollum said:

Was very impressed by Sai Sudarshan and Samson in RSA last year. Both should be given a long run, Shreyas Iyer won't do anything in 2027 WC. 

Iyer had a near ATG performance as a middle order bat in WC.  Understandable if they are offering him CT at least.

From there we can identify if he is still good enough or not.

Sudarshan is directly competing with Gill Jaiswal types.  Post CT if Ro Ko go out (unlikely) then only he will get a proper run 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...