Lord Posted December 25, 2024 Posted December 25, 2024 11 minutes ago, singhvivek141 said: Indeed, Ashwin can be a good coach. He is very similar to Kumble thought wise, Kumble too was very articulate in his planning and was a fighter. Only reservation is people with that kinda mind are generally too rigid with their own plans. It works well with youngsters but experienced players take it up on their ego. yep should be coaching youngsters like Dravid with U19 Senior team needs more of a man manager who can handle inflated egos
Lord Posted December 25, 2024 Posted December 25, 2024 6 hours ago, sensible-indian said: It's not that India has lack of coaches. Ashwin's impact will be far more for Indian cricket if he is allowed to speak his mind. Dude ended the chucking menace with a press conference and his full sleeve antics in a game. He made Mankad normal in IPL. You need massive reach to effect large changes. Being a coach where you can't voice out your opinion might produce 1-2 spinners but you don't get reach there. Today you are seeing memes about Kohli and Rohit which is creating pressure on BCCI. What's happening right now Bad results --> People's eyes opening up --> Criticism --> BCCI forced to take action But we can't always wait for bad results. We lost potentially 2 WTC titles because of this. What we need is: Knowledge --> People's eyes opening up --> Criticism --> BCCi forced to take action Ashwin is more valuable reaching the masses than being in a silent role. My personal take. Nothing forces BCCI to take action, much less criticism. It'll only happen if it hits their pockets. Unfortunately masses will always lineup for IPL. Gavaskar, Sachin were massive but has done nothing with commentary. Even Shastri achieved more as coach New guy 1
sensible-indian Posted December 25, 2024 Posted December 25, 2024 9 minutes ago, Lord said: Nothing forces BCCI to take action, much less criticism. It'll only happen if it hits their pockets. Unfortunately masses will always lineup for IPL. Gavaskar, Sachin were massive but has done nothing with commentary. Even Shastri achieved more as coach When have Gavaskar or Sachin presented insightful views? We need people who present insightful views. Pujara right now is shaping up to be a great expert. If he has decent commentary skills, he could educate people big time.
Lord Posted December 25, 2024 Posted December 25, 2024 26 minutes ago, sensible-indian said: When have Gavaskar or Sachin presented insightful views? We need people who present insightful views. Pujara right now is shaping up to be a great expert. If he has decent commentary skills, he could educate people big time. Both are very good when they talk about batting, but its lost in too much idiotic stuff. Analysis is good for entertainment value but achieves nothing. Commentary requires different skills.
sensible-indian Posted December 25, 2024 Posted December 25, 2024 1 hour ago, Lord said: Both are very good when they talk about batting, but its lost in too much idiotic stuff. Analysis is good for entertainment value but achieves nothing. Commentary requires different skills. Yes. Both Gavaskar and Sachin can give a masterclass when they wish to. But Gavaskar talks nonsense 99% of the time tho. The reason why we have ignorant fans is cos we have poor coverage (where commies & experts only engage in fan service). Anyways, I get your point about coaching too. Lord 1
rollingstoned Posted December 26, 2024 Posted December 26, 2024 15 hours ago, sensible-indian said: When have Gavaskar or Sachin presented insightful views? We need people who present insightful views. Pujara right now is shaping up to be a great expert. If he has decent commentary skills, he could educate people big time. Gavaskar can be extremely insightful and talk sense when he wants to but you have to make sure it is not for an Indian audience. He phones it in most of the time because he feels it's enough.
sensible-indian Posted December 26, 2024 Posted December 26, 2024 1 hour ago, rollingstoned said: Gavaskar can be extremely insightful and talk sense when he wants to but you have to make sure it is not for an Indian audience. He phones it in most of the time because he feels it's enough. True but more often than not...Gavaskar chooses the easy route.
Vijy Posted December 26, 2024 Posted December 26, 2024 23 hours ago, singhvivek141 said: Indeed, Ashwin can be a good coach. He is very similar to Kumble thought wise, Kumble too was very articulate in his planning and was a fighter. Only reservation is people with that kinda mind are generally too rigid with their own plans. It works well with youngsters but experienced players take it up on their ego. Both Ash and Kumble were too much for this team of entitled egotists
Ultimate_Game Posted December 26, 2024 Posted December 26, 2024 1 hour ago, Vijy said: Both Ash and Kumble were too much for this team of entitled egotists I think there're only two players which fall in that category. I doubt Bumrah and others are like that. Vijy 1
Vijy Posted December 26, 2024 Posted December 26, 2024 8 minutes ago, Ultimate_Game said: I think there're only two players which fall in that category. I doubt Bumrah and others are like that. Pandu is/was also an entitled brat Muloghonto 1
Ultimate_Game Posted December 26, 2024 Posted December 26, 2024 11 minutes ago, Vijy said: Pandu is/was also an entitled brat He doesn't have the veto power and was put in his place. Doubt we can do so with the two superstars Vijy 1
figo6762 Posted December 27, 2024 Posted December 27, 2024 I hope Ashwin takes this oppty to take a new path .. I think he has retired at the right time with 2-3 years of cricket in him . He will play bbl , 100 , cpl .. building his sky sports career . He is smart he knows that he needs to settle overseas for his daughters sake .. he is not as fortunate as kohli or rohit .. good move .. give his kids oppty to study in the Uk .. hopefully other cricketers see this as oppty to give a “fu” to bcci ..
Vijy Posted December 27, 2024 Posted December 27, 2024 7 minutes ago, figo6762 said: I hope Ashwin takes this oppty to take a new path .. I think he has retired at the right time with 2-3 years of cricket in him . He will play bbl , 100 , cpl .. building his sky sports career . He is smart he knows that he needs to settle overseas for his daughters sake .. he is not as fortunate as kohli or rohit .. good move .. give his kids oppty to study in the Uk .. hopefully other cricketers see this as oppty to give a “fu” to bcci .. We may see most of the recently retired cricketers move out of the country eventually.
Gollum Posted August 27, 2025 Posted August 27, 2025 (edited) Retires from IPL as well, good decision. Didn't like that I had to root against him this season because of my CSK hate. 2 IPL trophies, few more finals from CSK, RR, DC. 2 CLT20s, was player of the series in the first CLT20 win by an Indian franchise, that too in RSA (2010). His best IPL performance probably the 2011 final against RCB, when he ended the game in the first over, 16/3 in 4 overs. Till around 2014-15 he was a legit MVP in T20s. Edited August 27, 2025 by Gollum
figo6762 Posted August 27, 2025 Posted August 27, 2025 9 hours ago, Gollum said: Retires from IPL as well, good decision. Didn't like that I had to root against him this season because of my CSK hate. 2 IPL trophies, few more finals from CSK, RR, DC. 2 CLT20s, was player of the series in the first CLT20 win by an Indian franchise, that too in RSA (2010). His best IPL performance probably the 2011 final against RCB, when he ended the game in the first over, 16/3 in 4 overs. Till around 2014-15 he was a legit MVP in T20s. Nice a good path to be like a bravo or pollard .. looking forward for 100 , CPL, BBL..
Vilander Posted September 8, 2025 Posted September 8, 2025 (edited) Can't spin well in India. Can't bat well in India. Retires because he is not an athlete and more a thairsadham. But now wants to spin in sena.. ok. That's not going to work Edited September 8, 2025 by Vilander
Vilander Posted September 8, 2025 Posted September 8, 2025 On 8/27/2025 at 6:08 AM, Gollum said: because of my CSK hate. Dhoni ?
tapandrun Posted September 8, 2025 Posted September 8, 2025 On 8/27/2025 at 6:08 AM, Gollum said: Retires from IPL as well, good decision. Didn't like that I had to root against him this season because of my CSK hate. 2 IPL trophies, few more finals from CSK, RR, DC. 2 CLT20s, was player of the series in the first CLT20 win by an Indian franchise, that too in RSA (2010). His best IPL performance probably the 2011 final against RCB, when he ended the game in the first over, 16/3 in 4 overs. Till around 2014-15 he was a legit MVP in T20s. Think that there is some rule with bcci that player has to take off a 2 yrs of cooling off period after retirement to play other leagues
Gollum Posted September 8, 2025 Posted September 8, 2025 38 minutes ago, Vilander said: Dhoni ? Him and Srinivasan.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now