Sandz Posted May 25 Posted May 25 9 hours ago, Lord said: how is Stuart Broad an all format great if thats the criteria? And Clouderson better than Bumrah across all formats Lord 1
cricspirit Posted May 26 Posted May 26 (edited) Sangakkara was good but his numbers are inflated. He isn't higher than Smith.... Watched the entire career of Sangakkara. For some reason he never appeared scary or super impressive to me even when he just kept scoring runs... He was decent to watch but still felt nothing special. Even Chanderpaul got 10K runs playing with determination at higher average than Jayawardene. Chanderpaul will never be found on any list. Anyways.. these exercises always have opinions of bunch of people.. Another bunch will select a different mix of players in different order. Someone always misses out. Edited May 26 by cricspirit tapandrun and Nikola 2
test fan Posted May 26 Posted May 26 On 5/22/2026 at 1:19 PM, deathmonger said: Cricinfo is running this. Currently done 11-25. 25. R Ashwin 24. Stuart Broad 23. Kevin Pietersen 22. Virender Sehwag 21. Mahela Jayawardene 20. Pat Cummins 19. Ben Stokes 18. Chris Gayle 17. Mitchell Starc 16. Kane Williamson 15. Jasprit Bumrah 14. MS Dhoni 13. James Anderson 12. Rahul Dravid 11. Adam Gilchrist Top 10 guesses? Sanga, Murali, Kohli, Sachin, Ponting, Steve Smith, Joe Root, Kallis, ABDV, Steyn Are you Hitman from PP ?
deathmonger Posted May 26 Author Posted May 26 (edited) 8 hours ago, test fan said: Are you Hitman from PP ? Naah, I am banned there. I was SaimAyubEra lol. I was thinking of going back someday but considering how bad they are, I don't even feel the need to troll them. Edited May 26 by deathmonger
New guy Posted May 30 Posted May 30 (edited) Kallis has been voted no 1 cricketer Sachin at no 2 and also no 1 batsmen Kohli at 3 Murali at 4, no 1 bolwer. Ponting at no 5 Edited May 30 by New guy
coffee_rules Posted May 30 Posted May 30 Fair list, but cannot accept Kallis as number one. He may be good on stats, but he has a lot of non-performances in Australia and England. Stats maybe good for both bowling and batting, but it was never as impactful as others. Kallis he is a big india bachelor like panting, but the latter had great impactful innings against all.. Tendulkar is number one.
zen Posted May 30 Posted May 30 Those on the list should ideally have been from those who made their debut in the 2000 to 2026 period. Or had 80% of their career fall in the period. Lord 1
putrevus Posted May 30 Posted May 30 (edited) Kallis being number 1 is correct decision, he might be the greatest cricketer ever, Sobers comes close but this guy was excellent slip fielder. Edited May 30 by putrevus tapandrun 1
coffee_rules Posted May 30 Posted May 30 Kallis is a stats padder of the Dravid mold , stacking up useless 100s and 5fers, somebody who has never him on play will read statsguru and vote him greatest cricketer of the century
Prabhdeep Singh Posted May 31 Posted May 31 (edited) Potential players who could have been in terms of impact based on all formats: Mitchell Johnson Josh Hazelwood Rohit Sharma Ravi Jadeja Mohammed Shami Edited May 31 by Prabhdeep Singh
putrevus Posted May 31 Posted May 31 (edited) Come to India we will see,Rohit Sharma is not even in top 50. Edited May 31 by putrevus
DeepSpace Posted May 31 Posted May 31 No McGrath is a joke. Even in 2000s, he was taking heaps of wickets, winning matches and troubling batsmen on all surfaces. putrevus, KV244 and GoldenSun 1 2
Gollum Posted May 31 Posted May 31 They should have gone with a cutoff like players who debuted post 2000. GoldenSun, cricspirit, putrevus and 2 others 5
putrevus Posted May 31 Posted May 31 1 minute ago, Gollum said: They should have gone with a cutoff like players who debuted post 2000. So true.
BacktoCricaddict Posted June 1 Posted June 1 18 hours ago, Gollum said: They should have gone with a cutoff like players who debuted post 2000. Or played more than 50% of their international cricket post-2000. putrevus 1
zen Posted June 1 Posted June 1 (edited) The list is flawed because it does not feature me - Tons of runs against the best players of all time - Tons of wickets against the best players of all time - Some amazing catches taken and run out effected (usually featured in the best segments) - Lucky and strategically sound captaincy - Major series and tournaments won And still I am not on the list Edited June 1 by zen
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now