ravishingravi Posted October 4 Posted October 4 Greatest politician ever. No two ways. Narendra Modi comes next. And I don't mean greatest necessarily always in a good or bad sense. I am just looking at effectiveness. I am looking at myth making and branding capacity. Messaging.
Nikhil_cric Posted October 4 Posted October 4 Greatest Indian? Not even close. The man romanticised villages like they're the future of this country. Nehru and Ambedkar, for all their faults, were much better thinkers. Our lack of proper urbanism even today is because both central and state governments justifies this nonsense of looking at cities as cash cows and spending majority of the tax generated elsewhere. Nikola, Lone Wolf, Stan AF and 3 others 6
Lord Posted October 4 Posted October 4 18 minutes ago, ravishingravi said: Greatest politician ever. No two ways. Narendra Modi comes next. And I don't mean greatest necessarily always in a good or bad sense. I am just looking at effectiveness. I am looking at myth making and branding capacity. Messaging. That too without officially having a political position.
zen Posted October 4 Posted October 4 Does the greatest discussion only covers the post independence, after the division of subcontinent, period since 1947?
zen Posted October 4 Posted October 4 3 hours ago, Lord said: That too without officially having a political position. He was likely built up by others as the face of a movement as he connected with the masses.
Vk1 Posted October 4 Posted October 4 (edited) Gandhiji was instrumental in uniting India across religions (not completely though) and states and forming this nationhood appeal amongst Indians. It was no mean feat considering the diversity, illiteracy and other barriers. His ability to negotiate with British or his extreme ideologies of peace or his running of congress deserve much less credit in comparison. Edited October 4 by Vk1 Tillu, Lord and Lone Wolf 3
Lone Wolf Posted October 4 Posted October 4 (edited) Most famous Indian figure without a shadow of doubt globally.. there is no one remotely close. Pandit Nehru in his pomp was the second most popular Indian during his time... So much so that Mao was threatened when Nehru projected himself as leader of Asia. He had PR before PR was a thing. What defines Greatness though? Chanakya, Chandragupta, Skandagupta hold the title in Ancient times. Edited October 4 by Lone Wolf
Trichromatic Posted October 4 Author Posted October 4 10 hours ago, Nikhil_cric said: Greatest Indian? Not even close. The man romanticised villages like they're the future of this country. Nehru and Ambedkar, for all their faults, were much better thinkers. Our lack of proper urbanism even today is because both central and state governments justifies this nonsense of looking at cities as cash cows and spending majority of the tax generated elsewhere. Who is greatest Indian according to you?
Trichromatic Posted October 4 Author Posted October 4 10 hours ago, ravishingravi said: Greatest politician ever. No two ways. Narendra Modi comes next. And I don't mean greatest necessarily always in a good or bad sense. I am just looking at effectiveness. I am looking at myth making and branding capacity. Messaging. Who is greatest Indian then?
MechEng Posted October 4 Posted October 4 3 hours ago, Lone Wolf said: Chanakya, Chandragupta, Skandagupta hold the title in Ancient times. I would leave out Ancient era kings from the discussion, since India as a nation never existed back then. Lets take the Roman Empire itself - the greatest Roman king could have been considered as the greatest Briton and Turk ever simultaneously, since both Turkey and England were ruled under the same king at that time.
zen Posted October 4 Posted October 4 (edited) 2 hours ago, MechEng said: I would leave out Ancient era kings from the discussion, since India as a nation never existed back then. Lets take the Roman Empire itself - the greatest Roman king could have been considered as the greatest Briton and Turk ever simultaneously, since both Turkey and England were ruled under the same king at that time. I don’t think people look at merely borders, which have changed throughout the history and will likely keep changing in future, when considering ancient era but factors such region, ethnicity, historical associations, etc. So in your above example, ancient Britons and ancient Turks would be different from ancient Romans, even though Rome ruled those areas much like greatest Indian can be from India under the British Rule, which was around 190 years. For example, Rabindranath Tagore would not be considered among greatest Briton just because he lived under the British Rule. Similarly, Robert Browning would not be considered as greatest Indian just because of the British Rule. Edited October 4 by zen
rangeelaraja Posted October 5 Posted October 5 1.Chhtrapati Shivaji Maharaj - It is he who prevented the Mughals from going south of Maharashtra. It is because of the Maratha empire under him that Sanatan Dharm is still alive and thriving. 2. Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel - Architect of India’s unity and boundaries of modern India. It is because of him that India did not Balkanize and became a SINGLE united political entity. Nobody else is even close.
kepler37b Posted October 5 Posted October 5 (edited) 21 hours ago, ravishingravi said: Greatest politician ever. No two ways. Narendra Modi comes next. And I don't mean greatest necessarily always in a good or bad sense. I am just looking at effectiveness. I am looking at myth making and branding capacity. Messaging. I will thank modi for his demonetisation, the inevitable pain that pushed lethargic india towards UPI. Also, how he is pushing for manufacturing might. But he has messed up partially by pandering to ambedkarite groups, failure to improve urban living standards, prostrating to farmer lobby and making indian tax system predatory. Edited October 5 by kepler37b Lord 1
bsriharsha Posted October 5 Posted October 5 Modern India. Then yes. Gandhi was the greatest. That's not to say that he wasn't without his faults etc.
ravishingravi Posted October 5 Posted October 5 In all honesty, it has to be Sachin Tendulkar. In modern times, cant think of a more maryada pushottam than him. Lord 1
MechEng Posted October 5 Posted October 5 7 hours ago, kepler37b said: Also, how he is pushing for manufacturing might. Bro this is beyond peepee level delusion.
Recommended Posts