Saint Gilly is a cheat

[King Tendulkar]

I am sick of people potraying this guy as upholding the spirit of the game and being a great sportsman. So what he declares he walks, many other walk but dont make a song and dance about it. He is a hypocrite as he appeals for absolutley everything as a keeper even when clearly not out. Out of all the keepers in world cricket he is the biggest cheat at this. And his face when not getting the decision for these and then complaining/manipulating to umpires when they are not given out is a disgrace. He is the worst culprit at this among keepers in world cricket today. Great player but as big a cheat as they get in appealing when batters are not out!

[IndianRenegade]

Appealing is not cheating. Period.

[King Tendulkar]

Really!!! Appealing ridiclously when clearly not out and then complaing to umpires about it! Cant believe he is never hauled up to match referee for over appealing and dissent when not given

[bharat297]

No I wouldn't say Gilchrist is a cheat. I have no problems with players appealing for everything. its up to the umpires to get the decisions right. The Indian team do the same thing. I have no problem with players not walking, as well as appealing for everything. The players word should not be taken. Its up to the umpires. Thats what they are their for.

[IndianRenegade]

Really!!! Appealing ridiclously when clearly not out and then complaing to umpires about it! Cant believe he is never hauled up to match referee for over appealing and dissent when not given

There is no way of proving that he knows that the batsman is not out. He can always come up with an excuse, as for the referees not fining him, I have already said that the Aussies get away with lot of things, the refrees seem to be biased.

[Donny]

dsr: Fined 150% of match fee for excessive and mindless whinging.

[Mr. Wicket]

dsr: Fined 150% of match fee for excessive and mindless whinging.

Now watch him scream about how Donny's trolling and should be banned...

[Shehezaada]

wouldn't say he's a cheat but a definite attention seeker. Notice how he walked AFTER the umpire shook his head no in the WC 2003 semi final. If you know you nicked it, walk man! Don't stand there trying to make the umpire look like an idiot. He's done this plenty of time in his career..waited until the umpire's decision, then walk to show him up.

[Anakin]

But the way that guy whines and makes faces when umpires by mistake make the right decisions off his ridiculous appeals doesn't say a lot about his sainthood.

[Donny]

It's really only clowns like you and the topic starter who talk 'sainthood' about Gilly.

[Pancho]

wouldn't say he's a cheat but a definite attention seeker. Notice how he walked AFTER the umpire shook his head no in the WC 2003 semi final. If you know you nicked it, walk man! Don't stand there trying to make the umpire look like an idiot. He's done this plenty of time in his career..waited until the umpire's decision, then walk to show him up.

this is absolutely priceless :hysterical: gilly walks to show up the umpires :haha: including a world cup semi final.. gee.. what will they come up with next ?

[King Tendulkar]

dsr: Fined 150% of match fee for excessive and mindless whinging.

Typical bias match official hammering the Indian. Seems donny is also prejudicial and is bitter at the indian exposing him as a troll and a cheerleader of the aussie cricket team like his buddy Healy. Donny probably sports the pom poms as well!

[16 str8]

Typical bias match official hammering the Indian.

:haha::haha::haha: So now it's West Indians, South Africans and New Zealanders that are biased against the Indians? Paranoid much?

[Donny]

Donny probably sports the pom poms as well!

Wash your mouth out, dsr !! That's clear cut abuse.

[Kartikey]

I also believe he is a great player, one of the few civilised players in the Aussie team. But remember he appealed against Dravid at Sydney, Gilly would have seen that the ball hit his pad not bat or glove......................

[DomainK]

Gilly walks every time and it takes a lot of determination to do that. The temptation of standing can be hard to resist. He should get the credit for that. As far as appealing is concerned, there is no harm in appealing. I dont think any team does it more than our own team.

[King Tendulkar]

:haha::haha::haha: So now it's West Indians, South Africans and New Zealanders that are biased against the Indians? Paranoid much?

I was refering to aussie donny and his fining of me:hysterical:

[King Tendulkar]

Wash your mouth out' date=' dsr !! That's clear cut abuse.[/quote'] eh???? How is stating facts abuse?

[King Tendulkar]

Wash your mouth out' date=' dsr !! That's clear cut abuse.[/quote'] :hysterical::hysterical:Classic aussie behaviour. Proves my point and many other posters point. The aussies are happy to dish it out but as soon as they get some of the same they cry like babies and go running to the officials to tell tales:hysterical::hysterical:

[Anakin]

It's really only clowns like you and the topic starter who talk 'sainthood' about Gilly.

It is because of the condescending things he said about everyone else who doesn't "walk" except of course his beacons of morality in the form of his team mates. And apparently he tries to be honest only when batting, his appealing and subsequent acting is something different.