Gary Kirsten's role in selection

[Guest Gunner]

I see everyone moaning about Dhoni but what is Kirsten's role in all this? He is part of the team think tank which is into selection making, does he actually contribute or is it just cruise and collect from BCCI. Your thoughts please.

[DomainK]

No one was complaining when India was winning mach after match. One loss and we are out with knives. Its a game....we are bound to lose some. Some of the decisions by the captain, the coach and the players will look bad. Some of them will look downright stupid. Its a part of it all.

[Anakin]

Not sure who exactly is to blame for the retarded batting order in every single match, it's not just one bad match.

[Guest Gunner]

No one was complaining when India was winning mach after match. One loss and we are out with knives. Its a game....we are bound to lose some. Some of the decisions by the captain' date=' the coach and the players will look bad. Some of them will look downright stupid. Its a part of it all.[/quote'] I think it is food for thought. Who makes the selection and batting order decisions and what does Gary do?

[Guest gaurav_indian]

[Guest Gunner]

I am wealthier for having opened this thread.:haha::haha::haha::haha:

[The Realist]

Disappointed in Kirsten so far. Seems to be far too passive. What exactly is he doing?

[DomainK]

Disappointed in Kirsten so far. Seems to be far too passive. What exactly is he doing?

Why exactly?