What is Dhoni's contribution to the team?

[vaibhav_delhi]

He needs a rest. He has been idiot over last few years playing in everyting from 20/20, odis , champ leagues ets etc He needs to play all tests and then rest from some odi series and games. Simply impossible to play all the games he does as Keeper/Captain and Batter. Has to rest from masala odis. Must not play in odi series v NZ. If he does he is dumb or obssessed with not giving any keeper a sniff

they cant rest all the important players in 1 series. last time they did do, they lost 2 consecutive matches to zimbabwe

[vaibhav_delhi]

Dhoni is a real liability to the test team' date= in fact even to the ODI team. Really dont see him being of use to the team as much as Gilchrist and Sanga or even Katmal.......ok apart from his captaincy..........n his average is just inflated

ok champion

[King Tendulkar]

but dhoni never rests always plays. gonna suffer from burn out

[vaibhav_delhi]

yeah. he should skip the NZ ODI matches atleast after india has won the ODI series or taken 2-0 lead

[saneindian]

yeah. he should skip the NZ ODI matches atleast after india has won the ODI series or taken 2-0 lead

No sir, he should sit out of the entire ODI series.

[King Tendulkar]

^ Exactly he needs to rest big time physically and mentally

[vaibhav_delhi]

^ Exactly he needs to rest big time physically and mentally

well. i would leave the decision upto him while sharing your sentiment

[King Tendulkar]

well. i would leave the decision upto him

I wouldnt if I was selector. As if left to him he will play in all games. Just tell him you aint playing for this series. REST.

[Sid]

I wouldnt if I was selector. As if left to him he will play in all games. Just tell him you aint playing for this series. REST.

Talking about a man who rested from test series in SL himself,so this arguement of yours doesnt count

[King Tendulkar]

Talking about a man who rested from test series in SL himself' date='so this arguement of yours doesnt count[/quote'] That was pathetic moment in Dhonis career. The worst decision he ever made. At the time disgusted me and still was unforgivable

[King Tendulkar]

Talking about a man who rested from test series in SL himself' date='so this arguement of yours doesnt count[/quote'] But dont you agree how should rest odi series?

[Sid]

But dont you agree how should rest odi series?

FOR ME HE SHOULD HAVE RESTED IN IND-AUS ODI SERIES ALSO

[King Tendulkar]

^ agree. So why do you want to leave it up to him?

[Sid]

^ agree. So why do you want to leave it up to him?

BECOZ I KNOW HE WILL NOT PLAY AND ALSO SENIORS ARE GOING TO BE SENT SA EARLY,SO I AM GUESSING HE WILL ALSO BE SENT

[vaibhav_delhi]

^ agree. So why do you want to leave it up to him?

because he knows better about his body and mind.

[King Tendulkar]

^ If he did that he would not have played oz odi series

[vaibhav_delhi]

^ If he did that he would not have played oz odi series

maybe he knew tht india was going to play only a single game.:giggle:

[King Tendulkar]

maybe he knew tht india was going to play only a single game.:giggle:

I wish he used such foresight in his field settings

[Guest Gunner]

FOR ME HE SHOULD HAVE RESTED IN IND-AUS ODI SERIES ALSO

BECOZ I KNOW HE WILL NOT PLAY AND ALSO SENIORS ARE GOING TO BE SENT SA EARLY' date='SO I AM GUESSING HE WILL ALSO BE SENT[/quote'] Stop using caps. Edit your post.

[Sid]

Stop using caps. Edit your post.

will remember it next time :two_thumbs_up: