Police complaint filed against Yuvraj

[King Tendulkar]

NEW DELHI, Dec 13: A police complaint has been filed against cricketer Yuvraj Singh for allegedly assaulting a woman and her son, at his birthday party in Gurgaon. The police, however, had reportedly not filed any first information report (FIR) in the case till Wednesday afternoon. The incident allegedly took place during Yuvraj's birthday party in which Yuvraj Mahajan was also invited. His mother, Neelam Mahajan Singh alleged in her complaint at the DLF Police Station that her son was beaten up badly by Yuvraj and his associates. In her complaint, Neelam Mahajan has alleged that Yuvraj, his mother Shabnam and girlfriend Kim Sharma had assaulted and threatened her. "When I went to rescue my son, Yuvraj's mother, his brother and nine others assaulted me", she said. She said even after several hours, the local police had not registered a FIR report against the cricketer. According to her, she had called up the police emergency number (100) in Delhi and informed them of the incident. The Delhi Police alerted their Haryana counterparts, she said. "My son's medical examination was carried out in the night after I agreed to it. But, no medical examination of the others has been carried out", alleged Neelam Mahajan. However, Yuvraj Singh's mother Shabnam Singh told a private TV channel that Neelam Mahajan's charges were false. "She was the one who abused me a lot. We didn't say a word or do anything," Shabnam Singh said. SSP Hanif Quereshi said medical tests were being conducted on the complainant to ascertain the nature and extent of the injuries. An FIR could be lodged against the cricketer thereupon, he said. Quereshi said Yuvraj also sustained some injuries in the incident. Yuvraj Singh is recuperating after a knee injury and missed being part of the Indian team for the South Africa series.

[Guest dada_rocks]

Re: Police complaint filed against Yuvraj Now why would u invite someone to your birthday party and then assault him. Atithi devo bhaw, is this concept lost on this punk. HE seems to have anger issue assaulted some camerman recently now this.

[maatugaara]

Re: Police complaint filed against Yuvraj did they have their cake by then?? i hate going to birthdays and not getting to eat cakes...we can kick around later...

[shailesh]

Re: Police complaint filed against Yuvraj zee news was prompt as always with a detailed report apparantly this guy went along with someone who knew Yuvi..then later that night he calls his mom saying he was beaten and locked in a room etc..then the drama of his mom arriving there, confronted by Kim :wtg: and Yuvi's mother..the lady also stated that both provoked Yuvi and there was plenty of abuse, threats made etc all with the police present there who later had to escort her out :hmph: in the detailed report I found only 2 words of interest - there were girls and booze at the scene :wtg:

[Guest dada_rocks]

Re: Police complaint filed against Yuvraj Don't understand this sample either gate-crashing parties on basis of acquaintance and creatign scene..... Try not to et noticed if u are an uninvited guest.. Self-respect naam ki koi chiz hi nahin hai lagta hai

[beetle]

Re: Police complaint filed against Yuvraj this neelam person is quite something....she called up someone in BCCI to take action against yuvraj...i have no sympathy for this slut boy but looks like uninvited yuvraj's mother wants to milk the issue for as much as possible. :lmao:

[PaiN_KiLLeR]

Re: Police complaint filed against Yuvraj the issue has been settled ... police complaint withdrawn

[gator]

Re: Police complaint filed against Yuvraj tht guy mus have died in the scuffle, then Yuvraj would have been Siddhu's cell mate....

[yoda]

Re: Police complaint filed against Yuvraj

tht guy mus have died in the scuffle' date=' then Yuvraj would have been Siddhu's cell mate....[/quote'] yes, if he beat the guy and he had died, it would be manslaughter. standard for everyone, cricketer or not.

[gator]

Re: Police complaint filed against Yuvraj hypothetically, what if tht guy had slapped Yuvi first.... does it still amount to man-slaughter?

[jf1gp_1]

Re: Police complaint filed against Yuvraj If yuvraj had indeed killed the man and proved that it happened during self defence then yuvraj would just walk.

[yoda]

Re: Police complaint filed against Yuvraj

If yuvraj had indeed killed the man and proved that it happened during self defence then yuvraj would just walk.

Alternatively, he could also plead insanity. :hic: Seriously, yes, self defence will let you off, but you have to prove it beyond a resonable doubt, if charged. Gator, there is also a category called negligent homicide which is also unintentional killing, but one where the person should have known that their actions were negligent and could cause serious harm to the other person. Basically, as long your response is proportional, you should be ok. If you respond to a slap with a whole bunch of wacks and the guy dies, you will be in serious trouble.

[gator]

Re: Police complaint filed against Yuvraj but how will u prove tht the other guy was not gonna stop with jus a slap though u start lashin out immediately after the slap?

[jf1gp_1]

Re: Police complaint filed against Yuvraj Actually, yuvraj would have been booked under Section 304A of the Indian Penal Code. If yuvraj was drunk then it would come under rash and negligent act, causing death. His only relief in that case would have been section 88A ie if the act was done under good will, agreed by both party and not with an intention leading to death.

[jf1gp_1]

Re: Police complaint filed against Yuvraj we have pretty weird law Section 96 of the Code declares that nothing is an offence, which is done in the exercise of the right of private defence. But Section 99 says that the right to private defence in no case extends to the inflicting of more harm than it is necessary to inflict for the purpose of defence, i.e. the principle of proportionality. So if yuraj felt threatend then he along with his friends should have tied up the guy and handed him over to police rather than killing him.

[gator]

Re: Police complaint filed against Yuvraj but sometimes, a slap accidentally landing on the temple or something can lead to death too... then wat happens....

[jf1gp_1]

Re: Police complaint filed against Yuvraj That should come under Section 304A of IPC accidental death due to negligence. Oh by the way incase people didnt know it, not knowing the law is no defence under Indian law.

[gator]

Re: Police complaint filed against Yuvraj wat i am trying to get at is, how under the same circumstance Sidhu was unlucky and Yuvi and million others everyday are lucky...

[jf1gp_1]

Re: Police complaint filed against Yuvraj Sir Sidhu hit this guy with a stump or bat, this person was 50+ and i believe a heart patient in not so good health. How the hell could sidhu + friend prove self defence. It was road rage.

[gator]

Re: Police complaint filed against Yuvraj do u have proof tht Sidhu hit the person with a stump or bat.... or proof tht the other person did not raise his hand "first"