Jump to content

Champions Trophy Post Mortem Thread

Texan

By Texan
in Cricket Talk

ODI team  

38 members have voted

  1. 1. For each player, vote whether he should be IN (in the team) or OUT (out of the team). Don't vote both IN & OUT for the same player

    • Dhoni - IN (should continue in the team)
      12
    • Dhoni - OUT
      23
    • Yuvraj - IN (should continue in the team)
      0
    • Yuvraj - OUT
      36
    • Ashwin - IN (should continue in the team)
      1
    • Ashwin - OUT
      37
    • Jadeja - IN (should continue in the team)
      10
    • Jadeja - OUT
      21

  2. 2. Should Kohli continue as ODI captain?

    • NO, better choices available
      9
    • YES, still better than other options
      29

Recommended Posts

Pollack Mentor

Pollack

Posted
Posted (edited)
6 minutes ago, StriKe said:

How do you come up such criteria and filters ?

 

As a bowlers only bowls 4 overs, his skills are sh!t ?

 

Can i say Rohit captaincy was **** for entire tourney and because his **** captaincy got 3 freaking trophy from a high pressure game.

 

:facepalm:

Wouldn't read much into captaincy in shorterst format.. Same applies to bowlers and batsman. The batsman fans want in the team based on IPL haven't done bad in domestics over the years. 

Wouldn't read much into Rohit winning IPL trophies. Mumbai Indian has won trophy with harbhajan as captain. :cantstop: Not saying he is bad but captaincy in t20 format is very over rated IPL or otherwise.In ODIs and tests there is more importance to captain comparatively with captaincy in Tests being of absolute importance.

 

Edited by Pollack
Link to comment
StriKe Newbie

StriKe

Posted
Posted
Just now, Pollack said:

Wouldn't read much into captaincy in shorter formats. Same applies to bowlers and batsman. The batsman fans want in the team based on IPL haven't done bad in domestics over the years. 

Wouldn't read much into Rohit winning IPL trophies. Mumbai Indian has won trophy with harbhajan as captain. :cantstop: Not saying he is bad but captaincy in t20 format is very over rated IPL or otherwise.In ODIs and tests there is more importance to captain comparatively with captaincy in Tests being of absolute importance.

 

Shane Warne did this in 2008 with bits and pieces player, Same for Gambo for his aggressive captaincy.

 

You can't take out of the credits of the captaincy, Shall we make Pandya as captain for next WT20 as you said "

As game gets shorter captaincy worths sh!t."

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...