Muloghonto Posted November 23, 2018 Share Posted November 23, 2018 56 minutes ago, Ankit_sharma03 said: that also says out loud do such thing n at max ull get a rehab Whats wrong with that ? Saying 'if you do something that is a distinct evidence of mental illness, you will be put in a mental ward" seems like a very good message to send to society - certainly more ethical than ' SHADDAP AND DIE". 56 minutes ago, Ankit_sharma03 said: somtimes to handle such things fear is the best solution. Why ? What makes it best ? Why is the Saudi Arabian system of fear-based social policing superior to the remedy-based social policing of nations like Norway ?!? Especially since they are both batting around the same crime levels, so what purpose is fear serving, that makes it required ? 56 minutes ago, Ankit_sharma03 said: When u rape someone ur destroying someone life so punishment shud be very harsh and if if in instances its as harsh as possible so that it set fears in mind for future nothing wrong in it except we see time and time again that : a) fear-based rules do jack $hit unless the enforcement of the law is near 100%. If you think you have a chance of 'beating the system', then the fear component is useless. Which is why fear-based policing gives result in only a minority of cases ( few middle eastern countries and tiny nations like Singapore where laws can be implemented with near 100% rate). b) even if the enforcement of the law is 100%, fear-based dis-incentive is no more successful than simple remedial based dis-incentives. There is no crime that is significantly less prevalent in Saudi Arabia than Norway or Japan. Whereas one can say that the remedy-based justice system IS empirically superior - at the very least, it gives a small % of rehabilitated people. Fear-based death-cult like systems do not have that. The one thing that people need to understand, is retribution has ZERO place in justice. Killing a rapist does not undo the rape. Whether you argue for execution, castration, life in jail or mental help, the objective, in all of them- is prevention and/or remedy. Ie, the argument for executing a rapist is not 'badlaa' or vengeance, it is prevention - so that person doesn't go rape another. The moment you see the function of the justice system as protection and not vengeance, remedy-based system immediately jumps out as a superior system than fear-based system Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
OzGirl Posted November 26, 2018 Share Posted November 26, 2018 Wow, that's disgusting. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts