Should Dinesh Karthik replace Vijay or Rohit?

[Trundler27]

karthik's batting transformation is nothing short of amazing.... he is making each opportunity count and when someone does that he definitely deserves to play ahead of tried and tested failures and out of form hacks. With Kohli and karthik in the middle order in current form, it could provide an ideal platform for smashers like raina, jaddu, and dhoni towards the end. Nohit should not be in the squad let along in the playing XI

[fineleg]

karthik's batting transformation is nothing short of amazing.... he is making each opportunity count and when someone does that he definitely deserves to play ahead of tried and tested failures and out of form hacks. With Kohli and karthik in the middle order in current form, it could provide an ideal platform for smashers like raina, jaddu, and dhoni towards the end. Nohit should not be in the squad let along in the playing XI

:giggle: While he may Sirest of Sirs, he is no smasher (leave aside an odd performance)