Should Dinesh Karthik replace Vijay or Rohit?

[Rocky Balboa]

Wat do u guys think? DK looks in great form...:clap:

[PriyankaSR]

This thread should be in Cricket Talk. :agree:

[PriyankaSR]

Par, Kuchh bhi karo Rohit Sahrma ko mat nikalo plis :((

[Rocky Balboa]

Oops opened wrongly here. Mods pls move it to Cricket Talk.

[Sachin=GOD]

I said this a few days ago - Karthik and Dhawan should open. This should be the betting order: Karthik Dhawan Kohli Rohit Raina Dhoni Pathan/Jadeja.

[PriyankaSR]

I said this a few days ago - Karthik and Dhawan should open. This should be the betting order: Karthik Dhawan Kohli Rohit Raina Dhoni Pathan/Jadeja.

Aap toh sabko jail bhijwa doge. :phehehe:

[Sachin=GOD]

Aap toh sabko jail bhijwa doge. :phehehe:

galti se mistake ho gayi :--D but I won't edit it until the investigation into Indian players is over :giggle:

[asterix]

Where's the poal? :hitler:

[1983-2011]

Where's the poal? :hitler:

tomorrow in the emergency meeting

[PriyankaSR]

galti se mistake ho gayi :--D but I won't edit it until the investigation into Indian players is over :giggle:

Fair enough. :hatsoff: :haha:

[DomainK]

galti se mistake ho gayi :--D but I won't edit it until the investigation into Indian players is over :giggle:

Admit it, you are Guru Meiyappan. :ohmy:

[Sachin=GOD]

Admit it' date=' you are Guru Meiyappan. :ohmy:[/quote'] :secret:

[1983-2011]

Dk Sd Vk Sr Rs Msd Rj Ra Bk Vk Uy

[zumi]

since Vijay and rohit both look out of their league, and with players we have, it shud be: Shrikar, DK, Virat, Raina, MSD, Jaddu, Irfan, Ashwin, Kumar, Ishant, Yadav despite having only five specialist batsmen, jaddu, irfan, ashwin, and kumar are capable batsmen. and it gives us PLENTY of bowling options.

[Pagalpanti]

With Yuvi out I'd like DK at no.4 we need someone to stablize the innings if India lose quick wickets (like today vs SL) Rohit is a better bet than Vijay atm for opening spot (still its like crap replacing poop).

[Number]

He should play in the XI. Give both Rohit and VJ a chance in the next warm up, whoever does better, stays.

[Lord]

He should play in the XI. Give both Rohit and VJ a chance in the next warm up, whoever does better, stays.

what if both suck?

[Number]

what if both suck?

If they score equal runs off equal no. of balls, then Dhoni should do akkad-bakkad(or inki-pinki-ponky) and chose one.. lol. :giggle:

[NameGoesHere]

He deserves to be backed given how he's batting presently...replace Rohit, IMO.

[Pagalpanti]

Dhoni has hinted as well that Vijay would be a starter (unless Rohit impresses in warm ups). and DK will be used as specialist batsman.

"It's good to have Shikhar and Vijay back in the side. They both scored runs in Test matches against a good side. Vijay had a decent T20-League whereas Shikhar did well after coming back from injury. It's always better to start off with two proper openers. Rohit will be the back-up option while I consider Dinesh as a specialist middle-order batsman," he explained. India will be playing outside the sub-continent for the first time since the new rules have been implemented and Dhoni is a touch worried.