Jadeja or Bhuvi for Perth?

[Clarke]

8 minutes ago, rtmohanlal said:

'4 prong pace attack + Vihari spin' supporters are no where to be seen. Any thing to say now??? Oh wait... let us talk when AUS with their deep batting as they proved  'even in first test 4rth inns' scores 400+ and throws India out of the contest then and there.

The prerequisite is a scary green top like Lords earlier this year. That's not the case here. Reading the pitch accurately is so crucial rather than going by gut feeling.

[rtmohanlal]

17 minutes ago, sensible-indian said:

Who are those people?

 

I am curious.

sorry ....  feel not right to spell out  the names.....there are a few here, I suppose

[rtmohanlal]

12 minutes ago, Clarke said:

The prerequisite is a scary green top like Lords earlier this year. That's not the case here. Reading the pitch accurately is so crucial rather than going by gut feeling.

it is not all about reading the pitch alone. reading the opposition players  in detail too is crucial.For instance AUS has several left handers  and hence Ashwin was to be a must thru out.That is 1 important point.Similarly this AUS batting line up is inexperienced and hence not that adept at playing unfamiliar type of bowling.Naturally china man Kuldeep  who is such a rare commodity  would have proved to be so vital. Either he would flop or he would turn it head on for India, no mid level. But he is yet to be given a chance. Similarly Jadeja  who proved his worth in the most batting friendly pitch in  ENG  by taking 7 wkts and also picked 6 wkts in SAF in his lone outing there too.

Means Jadeja can be at the least as worthy as the  least effective  seam bowler. In AUS generally left handed spinners have done well compared to right handed spinners.