theguyinallblue Posted June 30, 2008 Posted June 30, 2008 i am confused some what...how is this possible... Aamir Khan is launching his own sister's son in a movie.. this new kid happens to be the Grandson of Monsoor Khan..who is the brother of Aamir Khan's Father. so does this mean..Aamir khan's sister married her Father's Brother's Son???? Holy Crap.... they are brothers and sisters... Disgusting...how is this possible...?
Rajiv Posted June 30, 2008 Posted June 30, 2008 ..vow, is this new to you Don't you know that in Islam, cousins get married?
punjabi_khota Posted June 30, 2008 Posted June 30, 2008 i am confused some what...how is this possible... Aamir Khan is launching his own sister's son in a movie.. this new kid happens to be the Grandson of Monsoor Khan..who is the brother of Aamir Khan's Father. so does this mean..Aamir khan's sister married her Father's Brother's Son???? Holy Crap.... they are brothers and sisters... Disgusting...how is this possible...? they are cousins..and afaik, marrying cousins is permitted in Islam. So I guess it is ok.
sandtest Posted June 30, 2008 Posted June 30, 2008 Disgusting...how is this possible...? Disgusting indeed! But a normal practice in ummah. As per Islamic rulings of influencial Deobandi/Salafi Schools in UP, only following two categories of children are not permitted for marriage: (1) Those born from same womb (2) Those sucked the milk of same mother. Rest all is Sunnah.
theguyinallblue Posted June 30, 2008 Author Posted June 30, 2008 yaar kitna Ganda lagega.... i can't even think if this situation... as a kid you grew up addressing them Didi or sister..and then make her your wife...:confused_smile:
theguyinallblue Posted June 30, 2008 Author Posted June 30, 2008 Disgusting indeed! But a normal practice in ummah. As per Islamic rulings of influencial Deobandi/Salafi Schools in UP, only following two categories of children are not permitted for marriage: (1) Those born from same womb (2) Those sucked the milk of same mother. Rest all is Sunnah. so does this means...Yousuf Pathan can marry the sister of Irfan Pathan??
SachDan Posted June 30, 2008 Posted June 30, 2008 so does this means...Yousuf Pathan can marry the sister of Irfan Pathan?? The more you go inside it...the uglier it gets.
cybervickey Posted June 30, 2008 Posted June 30, 2008 so does this means...Yousuf Pathan can marry the sister of Irfan Pathan?? no!
zubinpepsi Posted June 30, 2008 Posted June 30, 2008 I have heard tht muslims can marry their cousin brothers n sisters..as in the children of their father's brothers or mom's sisters.. have any of you(esp ppl frm north India) that in Tamilnadu, for hindus ,its possible to marry the children of ones father's sisters or mom's brothers.... or even can marry the children of their sister (if tht one is a guy) ..
theguyinallblue Posted June 30, 2008 Author Posted June 30, 2008 must be some tribe....as these tribes keep it within themselves...
SachDan Posted June 30, 2008 Posted June 30, 2008 I have heard tht muslims can marry their cousin brothers n sisters..as in the children of their father's brothers or mom's sisters.. have any of you(esp ppl frm north India) that in Tamilnadu, for hindus ,its possible to marry the children of ones father's sisters or mom's brothers.... or even can marry the children of their sister (if tht one is a guy) .. Same in Kerala too.
SachDan Posted June 30, 2008 Posted June 30, 2008 must be some tribe....as these tribes keep it within themselves... Regarding wat Zubi told, its not just restricted to a particular tribe...All hindus follows it.
zubinpepsi Posted June 30, 2008 Posted June 30, 2008 Regarding wat Zubi told' date=' its not just restricted to a particular tribe...All hindus follows it.[/quote'] yea .. its common for hindus.... ofcourse this trend is withering away.... but its still very common in villages....
sandtest Posted June 30, 2008 Posted June 30, 2008 so does this means...Yousuf Pathan can marry the sister of Irfan Pathan?? If Yousuf and Irfan's sister are born out of same mother then cannot! Otherwise they can. Actually GIB, you have to look at Islamism from Muhammad's period in Saudi Arabia, where Saudi tribes of those times like Bani hashim -Quireish etc. from which Muhammade belonged, use to marry each other within family. As per Quran, All acts of Muhammad and his sayings must be considered as "Sunnah" (Halaal or right!), hence since Muhammad himself married his Daughter Fatima to his father's brother son Ali, therefore from there-on, Incest became right since it's an act of Sunnah (Prophet's deed), therefore automatically right! and will even earn some rewards in Jannah.:-D
SachDan Posted June 30, 2008 Posted June 30, 2008 It depends on the individual...Early days it was almost a forced one.
theguyinallblue Posted June 30, 2008 Author Posted June 30, 2008 yea .. its common for hindus.... ofcourse this trend is withering away.... but its still very common in villages.... Its certainly not a RULE in Sanatan Dharam... i am yet to see any such case in WB, Bihar , Haryana or Punjab... there is no such practice in these states.. Heck in Haryana...bosy and girls belonging to same village can not be married to each other..as they are considered as brothers and sisters...and such marriages are not encouraged...
sandtest Posted June 30, 2008 Posted June 30, 2008 I have heard tht muslims can marry their cousin brothers n sisters..as in the children of their father's brothers or mom's sisters.. have any of you(esp ppl frm north India) that in Tamilnadu, for hindus ,its possible to marry the children of ones father's sisters or mom's brothers.... or even can marry the children of their sister (if tht one is a guy) .. Zubin, there is a lot of influence of Islamic culture upon day today life of Dharmic people of India, due to our history. You given an example of South, let me point an example of North. In UP and Rajasthan -- from where Islamists invaded India, even today marraiges are performed in Night time!! Why? Reason is, during those time we North Indians were ruled by Islamists, and under Shariah law any prayer practice other than Islam is discouraged. Since Hindu marraige requires Havan, Yagna etc, to avoid, conflicts with Muslim rulers, our ancestors in north India started performing marraiges in night --- and from their on it took the form of culture. While in South hindus you can still see the marraiges in broad daylight!
theguyinallblue Posted June 30, 2008 Author Posted June 30, 2008 If Yousuf and Irfan's sister are born out of same mother then cannot! Otherwise they can. Actually GIB, you have to look at Islamism from Muhammad's period in Saudi Arabia, where Saudi tribes of those times like Bani hashim -Quireish etc. from which Muhammade belonged, use to marry each other within family. As per Quran, All acts of Muhammad and his sayings must be considered as "Sunnah" (Halaal or right!), hence since Muhammad himself married his Daughter Fatima to his father's brother son Ali, therefore from there-on, Incest became right since it's an act of Sunnah (Prophet's deed), therefore automatically right! and will even earn some rewards in Jannah.:-D i think Yousuf is from one woman...and irfan and the girl is from another... so Mehboob Khan can keep all the wealth at home by marrying Yousuf with his step sister...and keep the things within family..:haha:...
zubinpepsi Posted June 30, 2008 Posted June 30, 2008 Its certainly not a RULE in Sanatan Dharam... i am yet to see any such case in WB, Bihar , Haryana or Punjab... there is no such practice in these states.. Heck in Haryana...bosy and girls belonging to same village can not be married to each other..as they are considered as brothers and sisters...and such marriages are not encouraged... U know TGIB, I thought this is common for all hindus in India.. only 4 yrs ago i realized tht its common only in tamilnadu... one of my hsemate was frm delhi.. he was surprised when i said this thing.. and so was I....
Recommended Posts