DomainK Posted July 23, 2009 Share Posted July 23, 2009 How come when batsmen run 2 runs' date=' and some retard paki misfield (not on purpose, but for his lack of skill) 4 extra runs are not given?[/quote'] Its additional/extra only in case of an overthrow. Link to comment
rainy day Posted July 23, 2009 Share Posted July 23, 2009 A fielder chase a ball to a long boundary, by the time he gets to the ball he hears a team mate shout out the batsmen have already completed 4 runs and are on their way for the 5th. Without hesitating, he nudges the ball over the rope with his foot, hoping for a four to limit the damage. What do you do? Give EIGHT runs to the batting side, 4 for the boundary, 4 for the overthrow not nine because the 5th run had not be completed. rainy day got it correct, but im beginning to suspect he has this book, because all his answers are suspiciously precise. nah don't have the book, just seen a lot of this stuff happen in matches every now and then. Like the dead ball one even happened in the recent Pak vs SL series. Plus i really have great curiosity about cricket, my dream job would be a cricket analyst. Link to comment
Malcolm Merlyn Posted July 23, 2009 Share Posted July 23, 2009 How come when batsmen run 2 runs' date=' and some retard paki misfield (not on purpose, but for his lack of skill) 4 extra runs are not given?[/quote'] he delibrately kicked the ball.....so dat asks for a penalty.... Link to comment
Kohum Posted July 24, 2009 Share Posted July 24, 2009 Situation #15 A fielder chase a ball to a long boundary, by the time he gets to the ball he hears a team mate shout out the batsmen have already completed 4 runs and are on their way for the 5th. Without hesitating, he nudges the ball over the rope with his foot, hoping for a four to limit the damage. What do you do? Prize: $40000 ICF Signal a boundary. These are not overthrows, since ball is not thrown to the stumps. Link to comment
Dravid Posted July 24, 2009 Share Posted July 24, 2009 he delibrately kicked the ball.....so dat asks for a penalty.... how does an ump figure out if he deliberately kicked it or not? seen paki player slip and kick ball in the boundary.... Link to comment
Malcolm Merlyn Posted July 24, 2009 Share Posted July 24, 2009 how does an ump figure out if he deliberately kicked it or not? seen paki player slip and kick ball in the boundary.... he sees it...........cmon it isnt tough to make out if u kicked the ball to boundary or not Link to comment
Sachinism Posted July 24, 2009 Author Share Posted July 24, 2009 Situation #15 Decision Award nine runs; the four completed runs, another one because the batsmen have crossed, and a four-run penalty for the fielder kicking the ball over the boundary. Well done sunnyji_2k for the 1st closest answer Link to comment
Sachinism Posted July 26, 2009 Author Share Posted July 26, 2009 Sorry for the delay in posting more of these, have had a very busy few days Situation #16 A fielder is injured and is replaced by the 12th man. A little while later the wicket keeper gets injured too and leaves the field. Is the 12th man allowed to take the gloves? Prize: $15000 ICF ------------ Situation #17 The first day of a Test match is lost to rain. The side batting first make 450 by lunch on day 3 and then bowl out the opposition for 279. The side with the lead want to enforce the follow-on as the match has become a four day game and they lead by more than 150 runs. Their opponents insist the follow-on mark is still 200. Who is correct? Prize: $20000 ICF ------------ Situation #18 A batsman plays a defensive shot and the ball bounces at his feet, spins back and nudges his off stump. He turns quickly and stops the bail from falling by pressing it down with the bat. What is your decision? Prize: $20000 ICF ------------ Situation #18 A batsman shoulders arms (leaves) to a ball as it passes through to the keeper. The batsman holds a pose and then brings his bat down - but on the way down he clips a bail, which falls off. The ball is in the keeper's gloves. Is he out on appeal? Prize: $35000 ICF ------------ Situation #19 A left arm seamer goes round the wicket to bowl to a right handed batmsan. The keeper moves to the leg side of the stump - near him are a fine leg and a backward square leg. There are now 3 fielders behind square leg on the leg side. What decision do you give? Prize: $25000 ICF Guys remember you need to provide an explanation to your answer and the reason behind the decision to get the full prize. Good luck Link to comment
rainy day Posted July 26, 2009 Share Posted July 26, 2009 Situation #16 A fielder is injured and is replaced by the 12th man. A little while later the wicket keeper gets injured too and leaves the field. Is the 12th man allowed to take the gloves? Prize: $15000 ICF No, wicketkeeper must be in the initial XI Situation #17 The first day of a Test match is lost to rain. The side batting first make 450 by lunch on day 3 and then bowl out the opposition for 279. The side with the lead want to enforce the follow-on as the match has become a four day game and they lead by more than 150 runs. Their opponents insist the follow-on mark is still 200. Who is correct? Prize: $20000 ICF The follow on can be enforced as it has become a 4 day game. Situation #18 A batsman plays a defensive shot and the ball bounces at his feet, spins back and nudges his off stump. He turns quickly and stops the bail from falling by pressing it down with the bat. What is your decision? Prize: $20000 ICF OUT, Reason: Common sense :p Situation #18 A batsman shoulders arms (leaves) to a ball as it passes through to the keeper. The batsman holds a pose and then brings his bat down - but on the way down he clips a bail, which falls off. The ball is in the keeper's gloves. Is he out on appeal? Prize: $35000 ICF OUT, hitwicket as he's still not completed his action of receiving the ball. Situation #20 A left arm seamer goes round the wicket to bowl to a right handed batmsan. The keeper moves to the leg side of the stump - near him are a fine leg and a backward square leg. There are now 3 fielders behind square leg on the leg side. What decision do you give? Prize: $25000 ICF Wicketkeeper obviously doesnot count as a fielder so nothing wrong here. Link to comment
varun Posted July 26, 2009 Share Posted July 26, 2009 Agree with rainy day above, except for : Situation #17: Opponents are correct, as it is still officially a 5-day game. Situation #19: Not Out, as the ball is in the keeper's gloves and is a dead-ball now Link to comment
Lord Posted July 27, 2009 Share Posted July 27, 2009 Sorry for the delay in posting more of these, have had a very busy few days Situation #16 A fielder is injured and is replaced by the 12th man. A little while later the wicket keeper gets injured too and leaves the field. Is the 12th man allowed to take the gloves? Prize: $15000 ICF no ONLY the players named in the starting XI can take the gloves Situation #17 The first day of a Test match is lost to rain. The side batting first make 450 by lunch on day 3 and then bowl out the opposition for 279. The side with the lead want to enforce the follow-on as the match has become a four day game and they lead by more than 150 runs. Their opponents insist the follow-on mark is still 200. Who is correct? Prize: $20000 ICF the opponents,it is still a 5-day test match,so the follow on mark is still 200 runs,irrespective of how many days r lost to rain Situation #18 A batsman plays a defensive shot and the ball bounces at his feet, spins back and nudges his off stump. He turns quickly and stops the bail from falling by pressing it down with the bat. What is your decision? Prize: $20000 ICF he is out,he cant touch the bail with the bat Situation #18 A batsman shoulders arms (leaves) to a ball as it passes through to the keeper. The batsman holds a pose and then brings his bat down - but on the way down he clips a bail, which falls off. The ball is in the keeper's gloves. Is he out on appeal? Prize: $35000 ICF ------------ no once the ball reaches the keeper the shot is completed,then he can only be run-out,he cant be hit wicket Situation #19 A left arm seamer goes round the wicket to bowl to a right handed batmsan. The keeper moves to the leg side of the stump - near him are a fine leg and a backward square leg. There are now 3 fielders behind square leg on the leg side. What decision do you give? Prize: $25000 ICF Guys remember you need to provide an explanation to your answer and the reason behind the decision to get the full prize. Good luck there must be only two fielders behind square on the leg side,BESIDES the keeper,the keeper is not counted in that Link to comment
DomainK Posted July 27, 2009 Share Posted July 27, 2009 Situation #16 A fielder is injured and is replaced by the 12th man. A little while later the wicket keeper gets injured too and leaves the field. Is the 12th man allowed to take the gloves? Prize: $15000 ICF No, one of the original 11 will take the gloves. ------------ Situation #17 The first day of a Test match is lost to rain. The side batting first make 450 by lunch on day 3 and then bowl out the opposition for 279. The side with the lead want to enforce the follow-on as the match has become a four day game and they lead by more than 150 runs. Their opponents insist the follow-on mark is still 200. Who is correct? Prize: $20000 ICF The opposition. The follow on mark is 200 irrespective of rain delays. ------------ Situation #18 A batsman plays a defensive shot and the ball bounces at his feet, spins back and nudges his off stump. He turns quickly and stops the bail from falling by pressing it down with the bat. What is your decision? Prize: $20000 ICF Out hitwicket. ------------ Situation #18 A batsman shoulders arms (leaves) to a ball as it passes through to the keeper. The batsman holds a pose and then brings his bat down - but on the way down he clips a bail, which falls off. The ball is in the keeper's gloves. Is he out on appeal? Yes, out hitwicket. Prize: $35000 ICF ------------ Situation #19 A left arm seamer goes round the wicket to bowl to a right handed batmsan. The keeper moves to the leg side of the stump - near him are a fine leg and a backward square leg. There are now 3 fielders behind square leg on the leg side. What decision do you give? Prize: $25000 ICF The keeper can place himself wherever he wants. But a smart keeper has no reason to stand outside the leg stump. Link to comment
Malcolm Merlyn Posted July 27, 2009 Share Posted July 27, 2009 A fielder is injured and is replaced by the 12th man. A little while later the wicket keeper gets injured too and leaves the field. Is the 12th man allowed to take the gloves? Prize: $15000 ICF no only the ones in the starting 11 are allowed to take the gloves. The first day of a Test match is lost to rain. The side batting first make 450 by lunch on day 3 and then bowl out the opposition for 279. The side with the lead want to enforce the follow-on as the match has become a four day game and they lead by more than 150 runs. Their opponents insist the follow-on mark is still 200. Who is correct? Prize: $20000 ICF follow on will be 200 runs as the game is still a 5 day.on what explaination the batting time gives does he expects if 4 days are lost the game to become a ODI A batsman plays a defensive shot and the ball bounces at his feet, spins back and nudges his off stump. He turns quickly and stops the bail from falling by pressing it down with the bat. What is your decision? Prize: $20000 ICF he is out...he cant touch the stumps...if he nudges the stumps he is anyway out hit wicket. down - but on the way down he clips a bail, which falls off. The ball is in the keeper's gloves. Is he out on appeal? Prize: $35000 ICF out hot wicket.....similar thing happened to mark waugh in australia....though he was given not out by third umpire...MCC later clarified it to be out. A left arm seamer goes round the wicket to bowl to a right handed batmsan. The keeper moves to the leg side of the stump - near him are a fine leg and a backward square leg. There are now 3 fielders behind square leg on the leg side. What decision do you give? Prize: $25000 ICF it is all right the wicket keeper can choose to be on either side of stumps...he is not counted among other fielders Guys remember you need to provide an explanation to your answer and the reason behind the decision to get the full prize. Link to comment
Chalks Posted July 27, 2009 Share Posted July 27, 2009 Situation #17 First day of the first test of the 2001 Test series between England and Pakistan at Lord's was washed out. Game became a four-day game, and England enforced the follow on after leading by 188 on the first innings. They went on to win by an innings and 9 runs. http://www.cricinfo.com/ci/engine/match/63932.html Going by that precedent, the game becomes a four-day game, and the follow on mark becomes 150. Link to comment
Sachinism Posted July 28, 2009 Author Share Posted July 28, 2009 Situation #16 Decision A substitute fielder can field in any position apart from wicket keeper. The wicket keeper must be from the 11 nominated players at the start of the game Congrats rainy day Situation #17 Decision Because the game is reduced to 4 days the follow on total is indeed 150 and not 200. So they can enforce a follow on congrats rainy day Situation #18 Decision If the batsman prevents the bail from being dislodged, he is out due to obstruction. Situation #18 Decision (yes I made 2 of them) The umpire here has to decide whether the ball is dead or not when the bail comes off, in a situation like this most umpires would deem the ball dead and the batsman would be not out Well done Varun Situation #19 Decision Wicket keeper doesn't count as one of the fielders, so nothing wrong there. congrats rainy day Link to comment
Lord Posted July 30, 2009 Share Posted July 30, 2009 Situation #18 Decision If the batsman prevents the bail from being dislodged, he is out due to obstruction. i said this he is out,he cant touch the bail with the bat isnt it similar? Link to comment
Sachinism Posted August 7, 2009 Author Share Posted August 7, 2009 Situation #20 In a tense match, both captains are anxious for a result as a draw is no good to either side. There's rain is due later on. Both sides decide they would like to skip tea. Do you allow it? Prize: $15000 ICF Link to comment
Kohum Posted August 7, 2009 Share Posted August 7, 2009 Yes I would. Both sides agree. So it should be ok. Link to comment
DomainK Posted August 8, 2009 Share Posted August 8, 2009 Situation #20 In a tense match, both captains are anxious for a result as a draw is no good to either side. There's rain is due later on. Both sides decide they would like to skip tea. Do you allow it? Prize: $15000 ICF As far as I know, it was not possible earlier. Umpire did not have the right to reduce break times in any condition. However, it has changed recently after one match came within five minutes of a result and ended in a draw. There was severe criticism following which ICC authorized the field umpires to reduce the break times as long as the captains agreed. Link to comment
Lord Posted August 8, 2009 Share Posted August 8, 2009 Situation #20 In a tense match, both captains are anxious for a result as a draw is no good to either side. There's rain is due later on. Both sides decide they would like to skip tea. Do you allow it? Prize: $15000 ICF NO! tea has to taken on pre-decided schedule.however if the umpire is convinced that a result is possible within half an hour of start of tea time,then it can be skipped Link to comment
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now