"MSD" Third most successful captain of india!!

[ZodiaC]

Lol @ People who thinks Dhobi is the greatest Captain. First let him do what many previous captains couldnt That is beat or draw against the Worlds best Team away from home and Reach the Finals of a WC or win it. If he can manage to do that, surely he will be our greatest, then i wont even take into consideration the fact that he had the best ever Indian team to play with. At this momment by no means he is the greatest.

Even bigger lulzer @ :punter: being the greatest captian eva

[bs_narayan]

I would personally prefer dhoni behind the stumps over DK but that's just me. I have always ranked Dhoni in the average category compared to the other keepers in the world. I don't even rank DK as I haven't seen enough of his work behind the stumps. Dhoni is really satisfactory and someone you can rely on.

Even Dhoni keeping abitlity is not upto to the mark, atleast he is the best available in India . Plus he is more reliable batsman than DK. Regarding Hussey, I do not think he ll be dropped as Ashes is looming large around the corner. If they really need to drop someone the Marcus north becomes the obvious choice

[Andy]

Yeah 3 world cups in a row = Best captian eva, I agree. Lets brush the facts that he's YET to win a test in India (:giggle:) Losing Ashes in England 2 times in 5 years etc under the carpet. In fact I can't see what he has achieved bar the win in SA in all his career :giggle: Less said about his tactical brain farts, the better :giggle:

Yes Ponting is the Greatest ever Captain for Aus, and Joginder Sharma is the best ever Player for India, if not the best offcourse better than Choker Tendulkar. :isalute:

[Andy]

Even bigger lulzer @ :punter: being the greatest captian eva

Offcourse he is, you have No Idea about Cricket so please dont post here anymore :headshake: Even Jogi Baba is beter than your Goddy, he has a CL20-20, 20-20 Wc, IPL. What has the Choker Midget have?

[bs_narayan]

Biggest question is how Dhoni is going to cope up loss of SRK, Dravid,Laxman. in coming years. This will be a test of captaincy for Dhoni.. Even two world cup holder is unable to cope up with sudden loss of big match players

[Andy]

Biggest question is how Dhoni is going to cope up loss of SRK' date= Dravid,Laxman. in coming years. This will be a test of captaincy for Dhoni.. Even two world cup holder is unable to cope up with sudden loss of big match players

:hysterical::hysterical::hysterical:

[ZodiaC]

Offcourse he is, you have No Idea about Cricket so please dont post here anymore :headshake: Even Jogi Baba is beter than your Goddy, he has a CL20-20, 20-20 Wc, IPL. What has the Choker Midget have?

Totally. Mashallah Lahori logic rawkz

[Shane]

MSD is the Best Indian Captain ever and it will only get better for him.

[Andy]

Joginder Sharma is the Best Indian Captain ever and iwe'll not get any beter player than Him. Perhaps greatest cricketer ever played for India.

[Shane]

Exhibit A: Link And we dont even play matches against Kenya, BD and Zim anymore to boost our record, this is against some serious opposition.

[Andy]

Exhibit A: Link And we dont even play matches against Kenya, BD and Zim anymore to boost our record, this is against some serious opposition.

How many tests has he played yet? Am not going to take ODI matches into a/c. I agree that he is our Best ever ODI captain. But as a test, he is doing well ATM. But we can call him the greatest or best once when he leads over 40-50 tests. Its too early to judge now IMO. In the first year of ODI cricket for M Kaif he had an average Excess of 51.

[saneindian]

Lol @ People who thinks Dhobi is the greatest Captain. First let him do what many previous captains couldnt That is beat or draw against the Worlds best Team away from home and Reach the Finals of a WC or win it. If he can manage to do that, surely he will be our greatest, then i wont even take into consideration the fact that he had the best ever Indian team to play with. At this momment by no means he is the greatest.

So when Dada led India to a draw in Australia or to the WC finals , the credit goes to Dada. But for us becoming no 1 in tests and ODIs, its due to the "best ever team" we had. Thora balance rakho bhai. And why call Dhoni names? Did you hear any VVS or Kumble fans abuse Dada when he ruined their ODI careers (and in case of Kumble even his test career)?

[Andy]

So when Dada led India to a draw in Australia or to the WC finals , the credit goes to Dada. But for us becoming no 1 in tests and ODIs, its due to the "best ever team" we had. You are a bitter fan who still cannot digest the fact that Dada's ODI and test career under Dhoni's captaincy. Why call him names? Did you hear any VVS or Kumble fans abuse Dada when he ruined their ODI careers (and in case of Kumble even his test career)?

Got it wrong completly and started jumping on Guns. As Long as Sir Jadea keeps playing for India and the likes of Nohits get chances ahead of Kohli, i'll call him a Dhobi. And its not just me who started it on this board, many others do it as well if you can see. And you call that a abuse seriously? When Ganguly got it wrong for India fans used to call him "Dadu" too. So beter get used to this from the fans, for us no one is bigger than India. And if you categorise me as bitter Dada fan, then 4 other fingers are pointing towards you and Calling you a Lunatic Dhoni fan. And really Souravs ODI career is offcourse under Dhoni's captaincy, i consider Dhoni much beter in ODIs. But in tests not as yet, he needs to lead the team allover the world and play som handfull of matches, and then if he continues to do as well as he is now, surely he is the best then. You beter dont categorise Indian Cricket fans here.

[Shane]

How many tests has he played yet? Am not going to take ODI matches into a/c. But as a test' date=' he is doing well ATM. But we can call him the greatest or best once when he leads over 40-50 tests. Its too early to judge now IMO. In the first year of ODI cricket for M Kaif he had an average Excess of 51.[/quote'] He wouldnt need 40 Tests to become the No.1 Indian Test Skipper, I guess a couple of years would do just fine. By that 50 Test mark he would be the Best Captain ever to have played the game.

I agree that he is our Best ever ODI captain.

:nice:

[Andy]

Did someone say Dhoni is a NON performing skipper? :regular_smile: Averages only 58 in both ODIS and TESTs whilst keeping wicket AND captaining. Ganguly's (the specialist batsman) average as skipper. 38. Ouch! PS: The riled up *** are back to calling him DHONI. Well done!

Agreed there, Dhoni is a performer unlike Sourav. As far as calling name goes, dont bring regionalism here. Many Non-Bongs call him Dhobi on this board too. I dont call Dhobi because am a bong, in fact i never used too few months back, i had the highest respect for him.

[saneindian]

How many tests has he played yet? Am not going to take ODI matches into a/c. I agree that he is our Best ever ODI captain. But as a test' date=' he is doing well [b']ATM. But we can call him the greatest or best once when he leads over 40-50 tests. Its too early to judge now IMO. In the first year of ODI cricket for M Kaif he had an average Excess of 51.

It's 2 years now, not ATM.

[Andy]

He wouldnt need 40 Tests to become the No.1 Indian Test Skipper' date=' [b']I guess a couple of years would do just fine. By that 50 Test mark he would be the Best Captain ever to have played the game. :nice:

Yes atleast let him play all over the world. Declaring him as the best now is too early.

[Andy]

It's 2 years now' date=' not ATM.[/quote'] The person you are comparing him too had 5 years stint as a captain.

[saneindian]

Got it wrong completly and started jumping on Guns. As Long as Sir Jadea keeps playing for India and the likes of Nohits get chances ahead of Kohli, i'll call him a Dhoni. And its not just me who started it on this board, many others do it as well if you can see. And you call that a abuse seriously? When Ganguly got it wrong for India fans used to call him "Dadu" too. So beter get used to this from the fans, for us no one is bigger than India. And if you categorise me as bitter Dada fan, then 4 other fingers are pointing towards you and Calling you a Lunatic Dhoni fan. And really Souravs ODI career is offcourse under Dhoni's captaincy, i consider Dhoni much beter in ODIs. But in tests not as yet, he needs to lead the team allover the world and play som handfull of matches, and then if he continues to do as well as he is now, surely he is the best then. You beter dont categorise Indian Cricket fans here.

Your bitterness is shining through in each of your posts. Keep the hate to yourself. I did not call Ganguly any names, I never would unlike you and your ilk who have no qualms in shamelessly calling names to our own Indian players.

[saneindian]

The person you are comparing him too had 5 years stint as a captain.

Err, its you who is comparing Dhoni with Dada, I am not the one doing that. For me both are great captains and if one deserves praise for wins, so does the other!!