bulbul Posted August 22, 2011 Posted August 22, 2011 Which is perfectly fine. Except when you say people, the one million odd protestors do not represent the entire 1billion population of India. Secondly, this bill, if passed will represent a whole change in India's constitution for all times so its a big, big decision. A non-elected body, comprimising of people who are selected on such subjective qualities like honesty, upstanding, having sway over the country's prime-minister and supreme court judges? and you dont see anything wrong with this? What do you think... Entire Billion people votes in this country.. or when constitution formed taking into evrybody at that time.. agree there will be difference among people also... But we have to see the Benifits over disadvantages...more over the System is not working properly so some initiative needed rather than sitting idle
mishra Posted September 27, 2011 Posted September 27, 2011 First i support Anna and respect his views. But that doesnt mean i will support him lbindly. I dont get it. What makes anyone think that a body called lokpal will not be corrupt. Because you think If body is as independent as Election commission it will act just as honest. The only reason EC is honest is because it cant afford to be dishonest. If it is corrupt It impacts lawmakers in most direct way. Still the three commissioners have there affiliations. It was Some how a guy called TN Sheshan gave credibility to EC. I once got access to case study from LBS Academy on corruption in RTO. Believe me it had details on how money went from the hand of Bus Khalasi to RTO headoffice and how legal loopholes were used. So they know everything. For me creating a independent Lokpal will mean creating a biggest corrupt body with no check to it. MMS is not wrong The way we implement our services is key here. The day a government employee will fear for his job because of cuts, The day a government employee finds itself that if he cant meet targets consistently he will be out of job or his salary will be impacted or department work will be outsourced that day corruption will be automatically routed out of office. Infact, I have few ideas for running a common department like Police and Income tax.
Recommended Posts