Wriddhiman Saha's test career

[Cricket Tragic]

+1

Bring back Ganguly as captain as well.

[India-KXIP fan]

impressed by his keeping :) in countries like england he will not drop/struggle like dhoni he has good technique.. and from looks of it he is technical kind of batsmen better suited to play in these conditions then dhoni

+1 As a keeper he i better. But if he scores big with the bat in the 2nd innings he will put pressure on Dhoni to retain his spot.

[J P K]

dhoni should start practicing his bowling now

[BeautifulGame]

He scored a decent 35 but in a flat track but failed the same way like Dhoni always does.The big issue with Dhoni has been his struggles against moving ball and Saha failed today as soon as the new ball was taken. If we are replacing Dhoni it should be with a WK who has good technique against moving ball.Saha deserves a decent run though just like anyone else.

[Magneto]

Saha has been India's 2nd highest scorer in 2 of the 3 innings he's played. In both the innings, he's come in the midst of a collapse. Got out shouldering arms in 2 innings, and this is something he needs to work on. If Dhoni wants to retire from Test cricket in a year's time, it's better to give Saha a run rather than glorify Dhoni's averages in some home matches.

[asterix]

Saha's test career is over till Dhoni gets next ban..

[Old guy]

Saha has been India's 2nd highest scorer in 2 of the 3 innings he's played. In both the innings, he's come in the midst of a collapse. Got out shouldering arms in both innings, and this is something he needs to work on. If Dhoni wants to retire from Test cricket in a year's time, it's better to give Saha a run rather than glorify Dhoni's averages in some home matches.

and he is so much better then dhoni with gloves on :winky:

[FreakazoiD]

35 + 3 = average of 19 on a flat track. Not good enough. No better than Deep Dasgupta, Saba Karim or Sameer Dighe.

[Ultimate_Game]

Saha hasn't shown anything special to keep Dhoni out of the team. He is in the same category as Parthiv and co. who can't get past 30s at best.

[Cricket Tragic]

You can't judge him based on 1 match as a keeper. Let him play a few tests.

[J P K]

http://www.boredcricketcrazyindians.com/2012/01/song-for-unsung-hero-saha.html

[Dravid_TheWall]

Saha is not much better than Dhoni, although I agree it is too early to tell. He cannot always judge the line and also has played on flat pitches yet without a good contribution. But what I like about him is a desire to bat. He wants to spend time at the crease and make the bowlers work for his wicket. This means he will be useful in having partnerships with the top order. DK is much better than both. It was unfortunate he was made to open in ODI's as at no7 in tests I know this guy would contribute hard runs. Sound technique and good wicket keeper.

[saneindian]

DK's keeping is at par with Parhtiv's these days. Talent wise, he maybe the best batsman out of the current lot but unless he improves his keeping, especially to spinners, he will find it hard to make a comeback. Saha has been the understudy to MSD for a long time now and deserves a decent run in the side before we try any other keeper.