Will you accept Mohd Aamir's return to Intl Cricket? I will. Give your opinion on Poll

[Desi Cartman]

He admitted and was sentenced, once he has served his time then he should be allowed to do whatever he wants. If one gets booked for drunk driving which is more dangerous than match fixing, the person is allowed to drive again, isnt he ?

[Old guy]

He admitted and was sentenced' date=' once he has served his time then he should be allowed to do whatever he wants. If one gets booked for drunk driving which is more dangerous than match fixing, the person is allowed to drive again, isnt he ?[/quote'] not if he is a pilot of plane .. xD

[daryl1985]

Let's not go there. Your big three, barring one, have been guilty as well. On topic, I said it before in another thread. He has been punished quite severely for an 18/19 year old kid. He is reaping what he sowed. Jail sentence in a foreign country and a 5 year ban from Cricket. Unlike Asif, if Aamer shows remorse, he has every right to make a comeback. Based on performance of course.

Explain. On the topic. Yes he should be allowed because he was very young and it is possible to make big mistakes at his age. However, i think he should serve the duration of his ban 1st in order to send out a strong message to anyone who thinks of cheating in the future.

[Desi Cartman]

not if he is a pilot of plane .. xD

If the rules state that then definitely not, my point is either ask for rules to be changed or let him do what he is free to do after serving his time :protest:

[Tendulkar_Bhai]

Personally yes, he didnt try to hide what he did and cricket in general would benefit from him, plus you know he wont do this again! Ponting and co cheated in 2008 along with Bucknor and Benson, did we ban them?

[King Tendulkar]

I would accept it after a further 2 years.

[Old guy]

If the rules state that then definitely not' date=' my point is either ask for rules to be changed or let him do what he is free to do after serving his time :protest:[/quote'] yes i agree with wht ur saying.. and icc is not stopping him from playing after 5 years but owuld his own country allow him to play .. i guess thats the question and i really dont know.. was he forced to fix or was he equally responsible even these things depend ..i guess people who matter have more clear information and would be able to decide much better then us ;P

[Old guy]

Personally yes, he didnt try to hide what he did and is a talent cricket in general would benefit from plus you know he wont do this again! Ponting and co cheated in 2008 along with Bucknor and Benson, did we ban them?

what when ? it wasnt proved or anything..so its diff matter all together

[Sarkar]

Let's not go there. Your big three, barring one, have been guilty as well. On topic, I said it before in another thread. He has been punished quite severely for an 18/19 year old kid. He is reaping what he sowed. Jail sentence in a foreign country and a 5 year ban from Cricket. Unlike Asif, if Aamer shows remorse, he has every right to make a comeback. Based on performance of course.

Lets not got there how u r team had saints in cricket for your kind info azhar jadeja never played for India again i dare pcb to do that on their players they couldnt do they never will.

[Sarkar]

arent underworld dons cheaters aswell:winky:

Nah they dont play for National Teams.

[Old guy]

Nah they dont play for National Teams.

but they still spoil name of country and take lives of people i think lives matter more then any game:facepalm:

[Tendulkar_Bhai]

what when ? it wasnt proved or anything..so its diff matter all together

what wasnt proved? you dont remember this? [ame=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gI1O0uwx2Mc]Shameful Umpiring in India-Australia Sydney Test- 2008 - YouTube[/ame]

[Sarkar]

but they still spoil name of country and take lives of people i think lives matter more then any game:facepalm:

Chalo Lives matter

[Old guy]

what wasnt proved? you dont remember this?

i do but its totally diff things i really dont want to remember this cost us a series but still imho its diff form this situation not even close to it

[NeutralCat]

No the guys is a cheat simple as that, betrayed the country as well ,no way he should play any form of cricket.

[MCcricket]

This is a cardinal sin , I am not sure how u can redeem urself from something like that.It is sick to hear about fixing, it is same as what a conman does and rips people of their money and faith.IT IS TOO EARLY TO COMEBACK, LET HIM LAY WAITING FOR 2 YEARS ATLEAST, HE DOESN'T EVEN SEEM LIKE HE IS REPENTING.Many more people have been involved in fixing, from our cricket legends to all teams , especially in mid 80's to 2000.

[Pakistan]

Yes after his 5 Year Ban for corruption by ICC is served. Hopefully, he will complete his education during the ban.

[Magneto]

Yes after his 5 Year Ban for corruption by ICC is served. Hopefully' date=' he will complete his education during the ban.[/quote'] Will he cheat in his exams? :giggle:

[Old guy]

Will he cheat in his exams? :giggle:

:nervous: is cheating in exams= fixing will i be but in jail? :facepalm:

[Zelch]

No... Any professional cricketer if caught doing something like this should never be allowed to enter a cricket match under ICC and its affiliates. Things like he was young, he was talented are irrelevant and will only compromise the integrity of a cricket match if he plays again. There were several cricketers in 90's in India who were dirt poor and never cheated when Azhar and Jadeja were betraying their country. And its useless to engage Paki fans in a debate about this (except UTalk), they have a very suspect moral compass. Pakis are fixing matches since god knows when. They let off all their Wasims, Waqars using the same logic that they were talunted resulting in Amir, Butt, Asif fixing case. Pakis will start fixing again when things cool down. Until then we must atleast punish those that were caught. If Amir wants to play cricket then he can play in one of those local matches between Altaf Bhai bradford wale vs Khurram khan londonwale in karachi or somewhere.