CSK Fan Posted May 6, 2012 Posted May 6, 2012 As a CSK supporter I wanted Sachin to carry on and score 100 so that his team MI can lose by 1 run. My grudge against Sachin erupts from fact that he shows bat to umpire on allmost every occassion bowler appeals for LBW even when there is no inside edge. I personally think he is bad sport! You are no CSK supporter, you are a Lahore Badshah supporter and your logic is proof of that Secondly I dont remember Sachin ever showing the bat for a LBW appeal so you are a liar too
Crookbond Posted May 6, 2012 Posted May 6, 2012 MTC, Aap bhi kahaan in C ke peeche lag gaye. Iggy maar aise C ke comments ko.
Crookbond Posted May 6, 2012 Posted May 6, 2012 tis is y umpire should not take fielders word for a catch.. if tats the rule,then umpires should ask the batsman whether there was an inside edge before giving the lbw Sunil Gavaskar on ICF ! :omg:
Crookbond Posted May 6, 2012 Posted May 6, 2012 Thanks. :omg: THAT IS NOT OUT! Where were bhajji and munaf!! feckers! IMO, it was not out too. I think he grassed it before being in full control.
IKnowU Posted May 7, 2012 Posted May 7, 2012 It is not out techinically But thats seriously harsh to give it not out. He took a clean catch, and he was falling and need to use his hands as support. I would keep it out.
sarcastic Posted May 7, 2012 Posted May 7, 2012 It is not out techinically But thats seriously harsh to give it not out. He took a clean catch, and he was falling and need to use his hands as support. I would keep it out. +1 It will be deemed NOT OUT only when the ball is grassed and the fielder LOST control of the ball (EVEN FOR A MOMENT). In other words, only when the ball has bounced back after being grassed and the fielder got the ball in control, then it will be NOT OUT. Otherwise, it will be kept OUT in almost all cases.
xblack888 Posted May 7, 2012 Author Posted May 7, 2012 +1 It will be deemed NOT OUT only when the ball is grassed and the fielder LOST control of the ball (EVEN FOR A MOMENT). In other words, only when the ball has bounced back after being grassed and the fielder got the ball in control, then it will be NOT OUT. Otherwise, it will be kept OUT in almost all cases. he caught the ball in 1 hand... most players r missing catches by trying to take catches in 2 hands so tat they dont graSS the ball...if u can take the catches and grass the ball,then many bad fielders will take difficult catches than this much easily when technically its not out,its always not out...y should an exception be made on this one? he had the ball in control just beacuse he grassed it..if he had tried to keep in fingers under ball,may be the ball could have bounced back from his hand like it happening to many fielders if ur saying to make an exception for this one,then there are many sitauations to be made exceptions in cricket which is not fair..so rules
xblack888 Posted May 7, 2012 Author Posted May 7, 2012 if a fielder takes a good running catch in boundary line and just beacause of his speed,if he crosses the boundary line,will u call it as catch r six? some times fielders used to make good diving saves in boundary line without touching the boundary line and just when they r about to throw the ball,they touch the boundary line unconciously,its only give as a four...
bangladeshifan Posted May 7, 2012 Posted May 7, 2012 he caught the ball in 1 hand... most players r missing catches by trying to take catches in 2 hands so tat they dont graSS the ball...if u can take the catches and grass the ball,then many bad fielders will take difficult catches than this much easily when technically its not out,its always not out...y should an exception be made on this one? he had the ball in control just beacuse he grassed it..if he had tried to keep in fingers under ball,may be the ball could have bounced back from his hand like it happening to many fielders if ur saying to make an exception for this one,then there are many sitauations to be made exceptions in cricket which is not fair..so rules exactly
anbuchelvan Posted May 7, 2012 Posted May 7, 2012 As a CSK supporter I wanted Sachin to carry on and score 100 so that his team MI can lose by 1 run. My grudge against Sachin erupts from fact that he shows bat to umpire on allmost every occassion bowler appeals for LBW even when there is no inside edge. I personally think he is bad sport! The catch was not taken cleanly and the ball has touched the ground.CSK should learn how to win genuinely with out cheating.
Crookbond Posted May 7, 2012 Posted May 7, 2012 It is not out techinically But thats seriously harsh to give it not out. He took a clean catch, and he was falling and need to use his hands as support. I would keep it out. According to the rule book, that's what we call NOT OUT.
Sidhoni Posted May 7, 2012 Posted May 7, 2012 Good that we lost otherwise this would have been made a major issue. Whiners would have been all over the place!
asterix Posted May 7, 2012 Posted May 7, 2012 Good that we lost otherwise this would have been made a major issue. Whiners would have been all over the place! Don't talk rubbish..Nobody's whining about Sachin's wicket. Most of you guys have been whining about that 'wide' although..
Crookbond Posted May 7, 2012 Posted May 7, 2012 Don't talk rubbish..Nobody's whining about Sachin's wicket. Most of you guys have been whining about that 'wide' although.. Pawned! :hysterical:
Recommended Posts