Shocking umpiring by Dar.

[King Tendulkar]

Compton was plumb And Cook was so plumb it was not even funny.

[Sidhoni]

Completely agree. Some horrible decisions in first innings as well. Absolutely plumb and not given.

[King Tendulkar]

Frankly you have to wonder if he is bias. Ebgland doing crazy over appeals and said nothing. As soon as india did one appeal Dar was telling indians to calm down. Then 2 shockers by dar the innings smack of classic paki bias

[kubrickian]

He is a terrible umpire.

[panther]

great umpiring, bcci deserves every howler.

[panther]

how many Indians in elite panel?

[Crookbond]

:blink: Aleem Dar is having a bad game here. Why bring the conspiracy theories into it?

[panther]

I want DRS to become mandatory (icc should pay) because it is vital especially with so many poor umpires around.

[India-KXIP fan]

Zaheer got a wicket when it wasn't out of Dar. BCCI to blame, if you don't use DRS this will happen.

[kubrickian]

how many Indians in elite panel?

What's the point of this elite panel when such elementary plumb lbws are not given ? He is either cheating for whatever reason or just plain terrible. No other explanation.

[King Tendulkar]

Zaheer got a wicket when it wasn't out. BCCI to blame' date=' if you don't use DRS this will happen.[/quote'] Yes it was. Would have hit leg

[Magneto]

Yes it was. Would have hit leg

Nope. That wouldn't have hit leg at all. Would have moved further down. Ditto for Yadav. Both of those decisions were howlers. Aleem Dar just had a terrible day in office. Nuttin more.

[SLICKR392]

Nope. That wouldn't have hit leg at all. Would have moved further down. Ditto for Yadav. Both of those decisions were howlers. Aleem Dar just had a terrible day in office. Nuttin more.

Agreed. Swann's was plump but that wasn't given out so was one of the LBW of Broad's. Poor umpiring all around.

[Crookbond]

Nope. That wouldn't have hit leg at all. Would have moved further down. Ditto for Yadav. Both of those decisions were howlers. Aleem Dar just had a terrible day in office. Nuttin more.

Exactly - IDK why the conspiracy theories around.

[King Tendulkar]

Nah cheating pak. How did not give Samit patel out LBW was another one. Cook and Patel were so plumb even a village umpire would have given them.

[Magneto]

Nah cheating pak. How did not give Samit patel out LBW was another one. Cook and Patel were so plumb even a village umpire would have given them.

Mischief maker u are :giggle:

[don_corleone840]

Bcci should be ashamed of itself

[carnish]

Guys who was the umpire who gave Yuvi notout when he was plumb on start of Day 2??

[zep1706]

Nah he's a fine umpire, just had a bad game, no need to throw a hissy fit.

[BERGKAMP]

don't blame the umpires for turning on india and bcci. every man and his dog can see drs is the way forward and bccis ego is hurting the game. they are sub consciously teaching india a lesson.