Does it justiy to have dharmasena in ICC's Elite panel of umpires?

[virufan]

not just about being in elite panel or not. We just need quality umpires and dharmasena sucks. who cares about nationality. Even if a bangladeshi umpire or any other country...is good at what he does...im all for it

The pak umpire, who once got best umpire of the year, is very good. I forget his name.

[zep1706]

No no dude..It was not a very tough decision to make for an elite panel Umpire IMO. And not only do I think he was poor, many else does. I would ve said this even if it were by Eng and not us.

Whoever thinks that Dharmasena has had a poor series is either blind or has no basic understanding of cricket. Once again, the impact on both those decisions were umpire's call, which means they were marginal calls, could go either way. They were NOT mistakes. Even with DRS they would have stayed as it is. Why would you call that an error?

[Midfielder]

Problem is Indians dragging their feet. Time to bring DRS.

[TheWall]

Problem is Indians dragging their feet. Time to bring DRS.

After 2 reviews are over, what if the umpire makes a mistake?

[SLICKR392]

India against DRS should not be an excuse for the filth of an Umpire Dharmasena is. They booted Bowden from the elite panel, and this guy deserves nothing less.

[Gollum]

Adharma ******* Mooli over today. Joke of an umpire. Ravi at present is deserving of the Elite Panel.

[Crookbond]

India against DRS should not be an excuse for the filth of an Umpire Dharmasena is. They booted Bowden from the elite panel' date=' and this guy deserves nothing less.[/quote'] India is NOT against DRS - Dharmasena Review System