MS Dhoni and Suresh Raina LBW decisions

[MUMBAISKIPPER]

MS Dhoni and Suresh Raina dubious LBW decisions..both should have been given not out..benefit of doubt...P@ki bowlers applied pressure on umpires...their dismissal cost us the match...please discuss

[Nova]

Dude...What discuss? .:dash1: Get over the loss. It's embarrassing to come up with excuses.

[The Outsider]

What whinage! Dhoni was plumb!

[MUMBAISKIPPER]

Dude...What discuss? .:dash1: Get over the loss. It's embarrassing to come up with excuses.

for pakistanis the best way to beat India is to cheat,isn't it?

[king2be98]

Dhoni was absolutely plumb, he was lucky that the first LBW appeal wasn't given either, cause that looked stone dead too. As for the Raina wicket, I thought not out straight away, but there was one camaera angle which showed ball hitting pad first and others showing bat and pad together and at the same time. To be honest, India were only ever in the hunt because of Gambhir also Pakistani giving them abotu 50 extra runs.

[Mr. Wicket]

Dhoni was a goner.

[vvvslaxman]

Dhoni was out. He tried his spoon shot lol Didn't work out. It usually works for him. He left too soon or too late whatever. He missed it. I will give benefit of doubt to him.

[Nova]

for pakistanis the best way to beat India is to cheat' date='isn't it?[/quote'] :omg: They beat us fair and square. Here this is for you -->

[MUMBAISKIPPER]

Dhoni was absolutely plumb, he was lucky that the first LBW appeal wasn't given either, cause that looked stone dead too. As for the Raina wicket, I thought not out straight away, but there was one camaera angle which showed ball hitting pad first and others showing bat and pad together and at the same time. To be honest, India were only ever in the hunt because of Gambhir also Pakistani giving them abotu 50 extra runs.

but dhoni came a long way forward

[The Outsider]

^MUMBAIWHINER, where in the rule book does it say you can't be given leg before if you have come forward?

[MUMBAISKIPPER]

^MUMBAIWHINER' date=' where in the rule book does it say you can't be given leg before if you have come forward?[/quote'] P@kiterrorizer, he was miles forward...the ball could have missed the stump as it had to travel some distance

[Guest Hiten.]

P@kiterrorizer' date=' he was miles forward...the ball could have missed the stump as it had to travel some distance[/quote'] That would have been taken into account if there was a pace bowler bowling at him and had the ball not struck him on the full.

[The Outsider]

P@kiterrorizer' date=' he was miles forward...the ball could have missed the stump as it had to travel some distance[/quote'] How would a ankle high straight delivery miss the stumps, MUMBAIWHINER?

[Jabu]

Does Dhoni came to bat !!. Look like his walking on the pitch.:giggle:

[Mr. Wicket]

P@kiterrorizer' date=' he was miles forward...the ball could have missed the stump as it had to travel some distance[/quote'] P@kiterrorizer? WTF? And did you even see the delivery, that looked to be hitting middle and leg clearly and struck MSD low on his feet?

[riya]

Well If I was a mod I would have certainly banned this guy for making such humiliating threads.I can very well take this defeat,but never such whining threads.

[Jersey #10]

Does Dhoni came to bat !!. Look like his walking on the pitch.:giggle:

:hysterical::hysterical::hysterical::hysterical::hysterical::hysterical::hysterical::hysterical::hysterical::hysterical: Exactlly, He was properly plumb. The ball was going straight into the middle stump. It was like a flipper (as invented by warnie). It looked as if the ball was going to spin but It was a straight ball on the stumps. Dhoni was getting down on his knee for almost every ball against spinners...wtf? is that the only way to play spinners? looked very awkward. If they had bowled that ball to viru, it would have sailed out of the ground. :hysterical::hysterical::hysterical: Raina's LBW was confusing, I still think that the balls struck both bat and pad at the same time. In which case the benefit of doubt should have been rewarded to Raina. But that doesn't define us losing by almost 50 runs.

[Ram]

We lost, fair and square. End of story.

[yoda]

Dhoni was out clearly, Raina was not out I think.

[jusarrived]

Dhoni was out clearly' date=' Raina was not out I think.[/quote'] 9 out of 10 times Dhoni would have been given not out , but unfortunately it was the second appeal in quick time which dint help imo ..unlucky , but wont blame the umpire . raina was clearly not out ..but these things happen , we dint exactly get Bucknored here . so no complains !!