champ Posted October 28, 2009 Posted October 28, 2009 hrithik roshan has acted in many films as a muslim although he is a hindu.. ex: fiza, mission kashmir , akbar .. i could think these .. may have missed some .. my gf pointed this out to me. what could be the reason ? is it a concidence or something else.. my take is role as a muslim could be more challenging and interesting .. do u agree ?
punjabi_khota Posted October 28, 2009 Posted October 28, 2009 To please his wife... ...just kiddin. On the other hand, the Muslim dudes like Salman khan,aamir khan haven't played a muslim character AFAIK and shahrukh played only once in Chak de (plus now obviously in My name is Kkkkkhan)
flamy Posted October 28, 2009 Posted October 28, 2009 you have a gf?? how can he? when you steal everyone's GF with your irascible metrosexuality, irresistible sense of humour, super good looks and your cotton balls?
Desi Cartman Posted October 28, 2009 Posted October 28, 2009 whats the point of this thread ? Kadar Khan played roles as Muslim some as hindu and I think couple as sikh .. please discuss................... why :wall:
punjabi_khota Posted October 28, 2009 Posted October 28, 2009 you have a gf?? You don't ? Loser :hehe: Now I understand how you got ginormous forearms and biceps (on the right arm)
punjabi_khota Posted October 28, 2009 Posted October 28, 2009 how can he? when you steal everyone's GF with your irascible metrosexuality' date=' irresistible sense of humour, super good looks and[b'] your cotton balls? :hysterical::hysterical: Wtf does that supposed to mean ?
Shane Posted October 28, 2009 Posted October 28, 2009 how can he? when you steal everyone's GF with your irascible metrosexuality' date=' irresistible sense of humour, super good looks and your cotton balls?[/quote'] :hysterical::hysterical::hysterical::hysterical::hysterical:
ViruRulez Posted October 28, 2009 Posted October 28, 2009 lame thread :P all roles are challenging unless great actors like Kamal R Khan acting in the movie :hehe:
champ Posted October 28, 2009 Author Posted October 28, 2009 you have a gf?? so shocking eh ? :yikes:
champ Posted October 28, 2009 Author Posted October 28, 2009 lame thread :P all roles are challenging unless great actors like Kamal R Khan acting in the movie :hehe: hrithik's choice of these roles more made me put up this question.. i gave one reason .. ie . could be challenging .. wanted to know other's opinions as well if they think same..
CricketGirl Posted October 28, 2009 Posted October 28, 2009 i dont think its about whether a role is muslim or hindu or whatever i suppose actors take on role depending on what the character is personality wise, ok granted that being muslim may be part of that but i dont think that entirely is the reason for taking on a role
Sooda Posted October 28, 2009 Posted October 28, 2009 Hmm. I guess muslim roles in films are a bit more complex because of the nature of the films theyre in Cheesy romatic films are simpler and dont seem to have muslims in the leads often- for whatever reason But roles where muslims are the main character(s) are about- terrorism or religious issues which are quite topical these days and which are naturally more complex due to the demands of the character. Lots of films along those lines out/coming out- My Name is Khan as you mentioned; also Kurbaan with Saif and Kareena; New York- is N N Mukesh a muslim in that? I thought Hrithiks Portrayal of a militant in Mission K was pretty good. Fiza OTOH was poor, too simplistic. Havent seen J.Akbar, but I think with Hrit the fact that he has done a few is coincidence In Rang de Basanti the guy who plays a mulsim does a pretty good job.
champ Posted October 28, 2009 Author Posted October 28, 2009 Hmm. I guess muslim roles in films are a bit more complex because of the nature of the films theyre in Cheesy romatic films are simpler and dont seem to have muslims in the leads often- for whatever reason But roles where muslims are the main character(s) are about- terrorism or religious issues which are quite topical these days and which are naturally more complex due to the demands of the character. Lots of films along those lines out/coming out- My Name is Khan as you mentioned; also Kurbaan with Saif and Kareena; New York- is N N Mukesh a muslim in that? I thought Hrithiks Portrayal of a militant in Mission K was pretty good. Fiza OTOH was poor, too simplistic. Havent seen J.Akbar, but I think with Hrit the fact that he has done a few is coincidence In Rang de Basanti the guy who plays a mulsim does a pretty good job. yes u echo my opinions .. :two_thumbs_up:
CricketGirl Posted October 28, 2009 Posted October 28, 2009 Hmm. I guess muslim roles in films are a bit more complex because of the nature of the films theyre in Cheesy romatic films are simpler and dont seem to have muslims in the leads often- for whatever reason But roles where muslims are the main character(s) are about- terrorism or religious issues which are quite topical these days and which are naturally more complex due to the demands of the character. Lots of films along those lines out/coming out- My Name is Khan as you mentioned; also Kurbaan with Saif and Kareena; New York- is N N Mukesh a muslim in that? I thought Hrithiks Portrayal of a militant in Mission K was pretty good. Fiza OTOH was poor, too simplistic. Havent seen J.Akbar, but I think with Hrit the fact that he has done a few is coincidence In Rang de Basanti the guy who plays a mulsim does a pretty good job. Romance is haram!
Sooda Posted October 28, 2009 Posted October 28, 2009 Well, not romance per se. Its pre/extra marital romance that is. Somehow I dont think thats the reason why they dont have muslims in those kinda roles. :P I forgot Aamir Khan in Fanaa- he does a good job in that film.
Lurker Posted October 28, 2009 Posted October 28, 2009 hrithik roshan has acted in many films as a muslim although he is a hindu.. ex: fiza, mission kashmir , akbar .. i could think these .. may have missed some .. my gf pointed this out to me. what could be the reason ? is it a concidence or something else.. my take is role as a muslim could be more challenging and interesting ..do u agree ? No I do not. For starters you have totally missed the fact that for every 10 Muslim male roles you would be hard pressed to find a single female role. The reasons are rather obvious - status of female in Muslim society and also the sheer hungama that follows anytime a Muslim female role has even a bit of controversy(and this controvery can range from wearing skirts to drinking, forget big contentious topics). As for Hrithik for every role of his you can find a corresponding Hindu role as well. For a Jodha Akbar you have an Ashoka for example. You obviously can not compare with an Islamic terrorist role because simply there has not been many Hindu terrorists really. xxx
CricketGirl Posted October 28, 2009 Posted October 28, 2009 Well, not romance per se. Its pre/extra marital romance that is. Somehow I dont think thats the reason why they dont have muslims in those kinda roles. :P I forgot Aamir Khan in Fanaa- he does a good job in that film. naah come on they do show muslim characters in pre marriage romance!! dont ask me to name as i cant remember any apart from fanaa
Sooda Posted October 28, 2009 Posted October 28, 2009 The might do, because it happens. Dosent change the fact that it is, as you quite rightly say, haram in real life. No I do not. For starters you have totally missed the fact that for every 10 Muslim male roles you would be hard pressed to find a single female role. The reasons are rather obvious - status of female in Muslim society and also the sheer hungama that follows anytime a Muslim female role has even a bit of controversy xxx How do you mean? Films about 'muslims', or with muslims in them as the primary focus be it re: terrorism in Kashmir or whatever, have actresses playing muslims in them too. :hmmm: Unless you mean a muslim woman as the main lead type. Having ANY woman is rare in that respect.
punjabi_khota Posted October 28, 2009 Posted October 28, 2009 Fiza was a movie with a muslim lady as a lead.
Recommended Posts