Unfixable Computers Are Leading Humanity Down a Perilous Path

[vvvslaxman]

http://www.wired.com/gadgetlab/2012/06/apples-unfixable-devices/ Unfixable Computers Are Leading Humanity Down a Perilous Path I have been writing about Apple and the value of repair for the better part of the last decade. Repair is our mission at iFixit and it always has been. Even so, I didnt expect the scale of the public response when I argued last week that consumers should choose the hackable, fixable non-Retina MacBook Pro over its sleeker-and-shinier-but-locked-down sibling. The debate has been contentious. Garrett Murray argues that repairability is ludditism, old-fashioned inertia dragging down forward progress. He believes that more compact devices will necessarily be less upgradeable and hackable. Others said repair doesnt matter; consumers dont care. On some level, they are right. If something breaks, most computer owners wont grab a screwdriver they will take it to a specialist. And if the computer outlives its usefulness, they wont upgrade their machine, they will just buy a faster one. Some folks correctly pointed out that Apple products are more durable than other computers. Plus, Apple has a reputable extended warranty program. But sending your difficult-to-repair computer off to a Genius doesnt exempt you from repair troubles. About a third of computers break by the fourth year. AppleCare doesnt cover accidents and only lasts up to three years. Less repairable design guarantees that fixing stuff will be more expensive and complicated. Repairability is important for consumers. Yet I think this argument misses the bigger point. The future of this planet depends on the quality of our electronic devices and how long they last. Technology doesnt just make our lives more convenient. It makes life better on a global scale. Modern communications have driven advances in biotechnology, soil science, and medicine. For the first time, farmers are able to get instant weather advisories, pay for fertilizer by phone while standing in the field, and fight back against local monopolies with access to global commodity prices. Globally, we manufactured 1.6 billion cell phones last year, and we will make over 2 billion this year. The problem? The way we are doing it hurts people and permanently damages our environment. I dream of a sustainable technology industry that makes life-changing innovations like the iPad available to everyone on the planet. But I have a message for Jonathan Ive. I think that on top of building amazing new products, the technology industry should have three goals: Make our innovations available to everyone on the planet, not just the richest 12 percent in America and Europe. Stop the devastating environmental and social impacts of hardware manufacturing. Depend far less on mining than we do currently. It is not just the coltan mines fueling wars in the DRC the Berkeley Pit disaster was so devastating that many in Montana wish they had never tapped the copper deposits. That same situation is repeating itself in parts of China and Africa right now. I have spent a lot of time studying these problems. I have visited the electronics scrapyards in Ghana where children burn electronics to mine them for raw materials. I have interviewed product designers at leading electronics manufacturers, including ones that integrate life cycle analysis into their design process. And I have spent a lot of time studying the aftermarket the raw underbelly of the consumer electronics industry, where repair, reuse, and material recovery happen. There is no such thing as a completely green cell phone or computer. Even elective ÃÈreen standards like EPEAT are far from mandating environmentally neutral products. I am on the EPEAT balloting committee, and chemical companies have successfully lobbied for years to water down standards much to the chagrin of everyone, including many manufacturers. I have learned that most of the environmental and social impact of the electronics industry happens outside of the purview of the device manufacturers: It happens in mines and chemical factories well upstream of Foxconn and in unregulated scrapyards around the world. Pit mining is savaging the environment, causing water pollution issues that lead to birth defects and are unbelievably expensive to clean up. Semiconductor manufacturers insatiable demand for a vast array of minerals is also causing geopolitical issues. China is heavily restricting exports of rare earth metals to prop up its domestic manufacturing sector. When the warranty ends, manufacturers would prefer it if stuff disappeared so they could sell you a new product. But the real world isnt nearly so tidy. Only a small fraction of the electronics produced are recycled. And even then, they are usually shredded and separated into component materials. Shredding is a waste of resources and squanders the embodied energy in devices. Worse, many materials, including rare earths and coltan, are not being recovered at all. So, why do we keep making more devices? We are pretty close to manufacturing almost all of the electronics we need. There is no need to make a billion more cell phones next year than we did this year. Increased manufacturing isnt just due to advances in technology we are not very efficient at utilizing things that we already make. If you dont have at least one cell phone in your junk drawer, I bet someone in your family does. That phone could be helping someone else. In an ideal world, after you have moved on to your next gadget, technicians will continue to repair, salvage, and refurbish the old one. It will move on from owner to owner. iFixit is part of that ecosystem in addition to teaching repair, we buy computers from people and resell the components. I once received a computer with a handwritten note on it: Ũoodbye, iBook. In your death, may you give life to a dozen more computers. And that is my hope for electronics everywhere. Fortunately, the migration of usable electronics to the developing world is natural. Lots of people cant afford to buy new computers. Passing along old devices is the best way to share the benefits of technology. In a few years, the computer that you gave to Goodwill could very well end up in a computer lab in Kenya. I know electronics refurbishers that have resold the exact same computer six or seven times. And assuming repair techs have the knowledge and skill required to maintain them, those computers will serve their owners well, costing less each time they are passed along. Long-lasting, repairable hardware is the key to making computers available to people who couldnt otherwise afford them. Upgradeable tech also helps even if you dont upgrade your own computer, somebody else down the line can. It is amazing how long people can keep technology running. Manufacturing electronics results in lots of nasty environmental problems, everything from toxic dumping to aldehyde vapor emissions. We have decided, if only by inaction, that the cost of our hyper-productive modern lifestyle is worth these tradeoffs. I am culpable myself I live at the cutting edge along with all of you. But if we are going to make that tradeoff, the least we could do is to pass on the technology we are enjoying now. That is why I am so eager to promote hardware that lasts and call out products that dont. It is critically important that we fix things when they break. Consumers need to demand products that arent just light and thin, but can also stand the test of time. Because technology is far more than just another new gadget it is our future

[vvvslaxman]

In USA they toss away electronic goods even for small issues either because it was unfixable or exorbitant inspection costs and labor charges . Are you one of them. I had this flat screen TV panasonic for 7 years.. twice it didn't power up. I removed it completely changed fuse twice. Gave me 3 extra years. But i did not have same luck with my toshiba laptop. Power connector was flimsly attached to board. It came off after few months. While trying to fix it myself i damaged the board. It became useless. There was one delll desktop which i bought on sale. It blew in 1 years after a power failure. Repair cost was going to be more than the computer price. I just did some salvaging. Lot of electronic goods are becoming more and more difficult to fix

[Desi Cartman]

Its all about the cost. If cost of repair is high then why would anyone get it repaired

[Yoda-esque]

In USA they toss away electronic goods even for small issues either because it was unfixable or exorbitant inspection costs and labor charges . Are you one of them. I had this flat screen TV panasonic for 7 years.. twice it didn't power up. I removed it completely changed fuse twice. Gave me 3 extra years. But i did not have same luck with my toshiba laptop. Power connector was flimsly attached to board. It came off after few months. While trying to fix it myself i damaged the board. It became useless. There was one delll desktop which i bought on sale. It blew in 1 years after a power failure. Repair cost was going to be more than the computer price. I just did some salvaging. Lot of electronic goods are becoming more and more difficult to fix

I agree..I lost 2 laptops that way because of power cord issues :((

[vvvslaxman]

Its all about the cost. If cost of repair is high then why would anyone get it repaired

I took it to toshiba repair center. They could have fixed it by soldering it to board. Pretty simple for an experienced guy. They insisted on replacing the motherboard which cost 700$. I bought laptop for 590$. One reason i avoid cheap models is because of this.

[Cricketics]

VVs, SAME SHYt happend to my SonY VAIO. Mine was expensive though. I dropped Cranberry Juice on it. Didn't dry it. After few minutes the whole keyboard programming got screwed. "S" would bring "k" and so on. I got it fixed from some dude from Guatemala or Honduras. After some time, it started giving same old problem. And than I took it to the same Spanish guy who told me that the mother board is messed up and it might cost a lot to repair. I love that laptop for some reason and I have a goal to fix that one day, regardless of how much I have to pay. Hopefully cheap deal from somewhere

[Crookbond]

VVs' date=' SAME SHYt happend to my SonY VAIO. Mine was expensive though.[b'] I dropped Cranberry Juice on it. Didn't dry it. After few minutes the whole keyboard programming got screwed. "S" would bring "k" and so on. I got it fixed from some dude from Guatemala or Honduras. After some time, it started giving same old problem. And than I took it to the same Spanish guy who told me that the mother board is messed up and it might cost a lot to repair. I love that laptop for some reason and I have a goal to fix that one day, regardless of how much I have to pay. Hopefully cheap deal from somewhere

I just remember this The Departed scene whenever someone guy says Cranberry juice. :D 0kPZPkAePfY