Jump to content

Is there more to Rohtak sisters' story than they claim?


Recommended Posts

Posted

Rohtak sisters fail polygraph test; their `molesters` pass: Report http://zeenews.india.com/news/haryana/rohtak-sisters-fail-polygraph-test-their-molesters-pass-report_1549037.html

Rohtak: In a shocking development, two Rohtak sisters, who had hogged limelight last year when a video of them thrashing their alleged molesters on a moving Haryana Roadways bus emerged, have failed polygraph test, a report said on Thursday. According to a daily, the alleged `molesters` have passed the test. However, senior superintendent of police Shashank Anand and SIT head DSP Yashpal Khatana have refused to make the report public, added the daily. A local court had, on December 15, 2014, granted permission to the Special Investigation Team of Haryana Police to conduct polygraph test on the two Rohtak sisters and their alleged molesters. The SIT had been set up after the incident. The case had grabbed headlines after the two sisters thrashed their alleged molesters on the moving bus, but later came under criticism after conflicting versions of the incident emerged. Pooja and Aarti had alleged that they were not only molested, but also physically assaulted and thrown out of the bus by the three boys. However, an 'eyewitness' – an old lady – later came out in the open and said nothing of that sort happened. She claimed that the fight between the girls and the boys started over a seat. Also, police could not trace the 'pregnant woman' who had recorded the incident on her mobile phone. What also put the sisters' claim in doubt was the surfacing of another video, taken about a month before the bus incident, which showed the sisters beating up a boy in a park after he allegedly teased them. Accused in the bus incident and others questioned how someone was always present to record the actions of the Rohtak sisters and whether they had a penchant of entering into a fight with boys.
Posted
THE FINAL SIDE OF ROHTAK BRAVEHEARTS
Maker of this documentary, Deepika Bharadwaj got police complaint registered against her for making of this video for putting "objectionable content" against these rohtak Sisters. From her facebook page.
Deepika Narayan Bhardwaj June 6 at 1:40pm · Price you pay for bringing the other side of the story to the world - what i shared months ago has happened. Rohtak sisters have initiated a police complaint against me and The Logical Indian Page for posting "objectionable content" online against the sisters and maligning their image in public. The ACP who called me said she has checked our pages and did not find anything objectionable but I still would be required for investigation since they have made a complaint and she has to investigate the matter. The complaint ofcourse is specifically against me. Let's see what happens to the other side and the final side videos on YouTube. THIS is just the beginning......and THIS validates and exposes the need for doing what I am doing.
Posted
Rohtak Sisters’ Molestation Claim False, Says Police SIT; Counsel Alleges Bias] The police have said that the allegations of eve-teasing and molestation levelled by Rohtak sisters Pooja and Aarti against three boys of a village in the Sonepat district seem to be untrue after investigations. rohtak_girls The SIT investigating the matter has filed a chargesheet before a local court in this regard. Sources said the police had submitted a 200-page chargesheet in the case, which included the statements of 50 witnesses. The charge sheet says that none of the 50-odd witnesses in the case had supported the sisters’ version. Even the girl who had shot the video of the incident had refuted the sisters’ contention of eve-teasing. Moreover, the polygraph tests of the complainants as well as the accused had also indicated the sisters were concealing some information while the accused boys had come out clean in the test. However, the Sonepat sisters’ lawyer has expressed reservation over the turn of events. He said it was not clear whether the charge-sheet had been submitted by the Rohtak police SIT or the crime branch of the state police. ”We demand a fresh probe into the matter by the CBI or any other Central investigating agency as we doubt a fair inquiry by the state police,” said their lawyer Attar Singh Pawar. The sisters had thrashed three boys on board a moving bus in November, 2014, alleging that they had molested them. They also lodged a police complaint following which the boys were arrested. The boys, however, maintained that they had not molested the girls and the real issue was getting a seat vacated for an elderly woman, which triggered an altercation. An SIT was constituted to investigate the matter. http://focusnews.com/india/rohtak-sisters-molestation-claim-false-says-police-sit-counsel-alleges-bias/110831/
Posted
Rohtak Molestation Case: Will Media Pay Back The Accused Boys? t’s been nine months since this country saw the media coverage of Rohtak Sisters made famous as Rohtak Bravehearts. It’s been nine months since Kuldeep, Mohit and Deepak were called “sexual predators, molesters, blot on the face of nation” and much more. Finally, in as much time as a new life enters this world, police has submitted a report in this case, reportedly pointing towards innocence of the boys in the entire episode. We have all moved on in life but not those boys or the people of their village. Kuldeep – one of the main accused in the case – wasn’t allowed by the Army to sit for an exam, even though he had cleared all the preliminary tests. These boys have already served a sentence and been punished – not only mentally but also in terms of their career – for a crime they did not commit. Why? “All because of Media” Kuldeep tells me. One of the main trainings given by the Army in my opinion would be to not let the gender of the enemy attacking you come in. But in this case, this boy, who was an army aspirant was punished for mere act of saving and defending himself from repeated attacks by the opposite gender. Kuldeep – one of the main accused in the case – wasn’t allowed by the Army to sit for an exam, even though he had cleared all the preliminary tests While his behaviour should have been applauded for not thrashing the girls back, though he could have, he was in turn branded as a criminal because the Indian Media was too hungry for its next target. No one wanted to know the real story; everyone wanted another “hang the molesters” slogan loudest on their channel. Debates were organised, OB vans rushed to girl’s village. Reporters asking the girl’s mother what did she eat to give birth to girls so courageous! Who cared who these boys were like? Who cared if they actually did something? The only yardstick for analysing bravery of the country’s women today is their thrashing of men. Slap a man and you have done a great job! We are seeing that happening around us more and more and we are all okay with it. My issue is not with punishing people who have done something wrong but the whole idea of presuming that a man is always wrong and even when it is proven that the woman was wrong – being quiet about it. ALSO READ: Rohtak Sisters’ Molestation Claim False, Says Police SIT; Counsel Alleges Bias Just two days ago, news reports came in of a 50-year-old woman Geeta Patel in Mumbai, who blackmailed rich elderly men through threats of false molestation cases. She feigned a fall in front of these men and then requested them to support her till her building. When they got inside the building she threatened them by screaming of molestation and took away their watches, chains and anything valuable. Fearing they would never be believed of their innocence, many gave her what she wanted until someone complained. This news is of course not a headline in any of the dailies or breaking news in any channel even though this woman conned so many men this way. Why would it be? It would become viral only if the woman hit the man after alleging molestation and someone made the video of the episode. A woman aged 50 thrashing a man would fetch a bigger bravery award and example for others to emulate! A screaming headline would be – “Even A 50-Year-Old Woman Is Not Safe In Mumbai”. No one would bother to know the other side of the story. Geeta could very well become Mumbai’s braveheart had she complained before the men complained against her. I discussed at least three more cases where Rohtak Sisters and her family had threatened people of false cases in the video I made on this episode. No one in the mainstream media bothered to follow up. The life of a young boy who was falsely accused of kidnapping by this family wasn’t important – neither for the police, nor for the media. It is not a crime that matters for them, but perhaps gender does. With the police giving a clean chit to the Rohtak boys, shouldn’t all those people apologise who left no stone unturned to declare the boys guilty before the actual trial? Should the nation not know the developments in a case where the honourable judges and juries in media courts passed their verdict without any evidence? Would they apologise after our courts also free the boys of the charges? Who would give back the three days these boys spent in the jail just because of media trial? Who would give back Kuldeep’s dreams of joining the Army? Who would pay back for the tears of their village ‘Assan’ that was defamed by media to no end? Who would pay back for the tears of the old parents who beat up their own sons because that was the right thing to do with so much media pressure in the case? Who would pay back for the tears of Kuldeep’s sister who kept pleading that her brother should not be declared guilty before any actual trial takes place? How the lives of men and their families are ruined because of false allegations is still not a subject that the Indian media is interested in Who would give me back my four days of stress because these girls had an axe to grind with me too and complained about me to the police just because I wrote and brought out the facts of the case which were inconvenient to them? NO ONE!!! And it doesn’t matter. Media has moved on from the story. They would not apologise, especially when the accused were boys from a remote village who cannot sue them with a 100-crore-rupee defamation suit. So they can afford to just let it be. Not only them – all of us would actually do nothing except just feeling little sad about it. The ”Pain of a Man” is only a cliché, justice and concern are gender-specific. How the lives of men and their families are ruined because of false allegations is still not a subject that the Indian media is interested in. I would not harp on the pain of these boys either. They will make their own future and I am positive about that. What I am happy about is that these boys survived, did not resort to any extreme steps and faced the battle. Kuldeep has told me with conviction that he would appeal to the Chief Minister to give him and the two other boys a job as he promised in case they are found innocent. I hope the Chief Minister listens. I hope the media does anything – anything at all – to return the lost respect these boys! http://focusnews.com/opinion/rohtak-molestation-case-will-media-pay-back-the-accused-boys/111986/
Posted
8 hours ago, Singh bling said:

How many now remember this case. Blind support of media, liberals and feminists  ruined the lives of those who were then going to join army

Media trial had already convicted those boys. Who cares for the courts!

×
×
  • Create New...